Opinion: Trudeau’s NAFTA talk draws line in the sand

By any measure, the past week will go down as the defining one in Justin Trudeau’s current term of office.

With back-to-back make-or-break decisions on the pipeline and the trade files, the prime minister is rewriting the terms of engagement on two crucial battlefronts for his government, but also for Canada.

For better or for worse, he is also recasting the image he projected to voters a little more than two years ago.

Back in the 2015 campaign, Trudeau offered himself to Canadians as a climate-change champion. On Tuesday, his government announced it was purchasing a pipeline in a dogged attempt to bring more Alberta bitumen oil to the Pacific coast.

Then on Thursday, the prime minister traded his so-called sunny ways for fighting words vis-à-vis the United States, ordering more than $16 billion worth of tariffs on U.S. products in the process.

At the time of his election victory no one, including Trudeau himself, could have predicted that there would come a week when he would nationalize a pipeline and engage in a tit-for-tat tariff battle with Canada’s largest trading partner.

But then it is a rare prime minister who is the master of his own circumstances.

Jean Chrétien, at the time of the unity crisis, and Stephen Harper, when he had to deal with a global financial meltdown, could both testify to that.

One may come to look back on the past week as the moment when Trudeau’s government came of age – with both the baggage and the experience that attends to that.

Voters will have to decide next year if they are comfortable with the grown-up version of the political leader they invested with a majority government in 2015. But whether Trudeau remains at the helm or not after the next election, the consequences of the two calls he made this week will outlast the current Parliament.

The choice to take over the expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline almost certainly commits the federal government to the project for the longer haul. And the events of this week have marked a watershed moment in the Donald Trump-era Canada-US relationship.

One has to go back more than a decade, to Chrétien’s refusal to join the American-led war on Iraq, for the last really big bump on the Canada-U.S. road.

Over the course of 45 minutes, Trudeau uttered some of the harshest words a prime minister has directed at an American administration in decades.

It is not every day that a Canadian head of government pointedly notes that they are dealing with a U.S. administration that is short on common sense.

It is also not every day that a prime minister uses a news conference to dig in his heels in a trade negotiation.

By revealing that he renounced an attempt to try to settle the NAFTA file face to face with Trump last week, after the administration made the talks conditional on Canada accepting a five-year sunset clause on the tripartite trade arrangements, Trudeau did just that.

This is a line that Canada had drawn in the NAFTA sand early on.

With his comments on Thursday, the prime minister cemented that line in what appears to be fast solidifying concrete on both sides of the NAFTA negotiating divide.

Against the backdrop of potentially polarizing Liberal decisions, one might have expected the Conservative opposition to end the week on a high.

Instead, the reflexive partisan instincts that attend opposition politics ended up getting the better of Andrew Scheer and his party.

By turning their guns on the Trudeau government on a day when the U.S. was turning its protectionist cannons on long-standing allies in the international community, the Conservatives missed the forest for the partisan trees.

On that score, it will suffice to contrast Scheer’s tone-deaf contention that Trudeau is responsible for Trump’s latest indiscriminate round of tariffs with the unequivocal support given to the prime minister’s response by, among other leading Conservatives, Alberta’s Jason Kenney and former Saskatchewan premier Brad Wall.

At last check, neither is a member of Trudeau’s fan club.

Chantal Hébert is a national affairs writer.

Just Posted

Windstorm: One year later

Signs remain of the devastation from windstorm that toppled hundreds of trees

Flair Airlines moving headquarters from Kelowna, B.C, to Edmonton

EDMONTON — Flair Airlines Ltd. has found a new place to roost.… Continue reading

Study seeking cause of Crohn’s disease hopes to develop predictive test

TORONTO — With three brothers affected by either Crohn’s disease or ulcerative… Continue reading

Reported grizzly bear sightings near Penhold

Two people called in reported sightings Saturday

Urgent need for blood donors at Red Deer clinic

Though summer and the coming long weekend may mean a slowdown for… Continue reading

VIDEO: What separation from parents does to children: ‘The effect is catastrophic’

This is what happens inside children when they are forcibly separated from… Continue reading

Camargo lifts Braves over Blue Jays with first career grand slam

Braves 11 Blue Jays 4 TORONTO — Jaime Garcia is searching for… Continue reading

A beetle brings a nightmare on ash street

Introduced pests and diseases put the fear of God into plant biologists… Continue reading

Photos: Blair House is where the president’s guests get VIP treatment

WASHINGTON - Diagonally across the street from the White House is a… Continue reading

Ten Humboldt Broncos bus crash survivors meet in Las Vegas for NHL awards

HUMBOLDT, Sask. — Ten of the 13 survivors from the Humboldt Broncos… Continue reading

Triathletes young and old prepare for weekend event in Red Deer

Woody’s Triathlon goes Saturday and Sunday

Driver knocks over metal barricade, rolls several times in crash near Olds

A man is in hospital after his SUV crashed into the QEII… Continue reading

In tit-for-tat, Trump threatens more tariffs against China

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump has directed the U.S. Trade Representative to… Continue reading

Commons Speaker says no to Tory calls for emergency debate on Canada-U.S. trade

OTTAWA — The official Opposition is calling for an emergency debate in… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month