Outcome in Mulroney-Schreiber case hazy

In a court of law, Justice Jeffrey Oliphant would likely dismiss a case against Brian Mulroney at this juncture.

In a court of law, Justice Jeffrey Oliphant would likely dismiss a case against Brian Mulroney at this juncture.

With the fact-finding part of the commission’s work completed, Oliphant has been presented with no proof that criminal behaviour was involved in the relationship of the former prime minister and lobbyist Karlheinz Schreiber.

But the commission operates within different parameters and its purpose is not to make criminal findings. Instead, it’s Oliphant’s unique and rather unenviable task to pronounce on the behaviour of a former Canadian prime minister.

According to his terms of reference, Oliphant is expected to answer 17 questions in his year-end report. To do that, he will have to determine whether he finds either of Mulroney’s or Schreiber’s conflicting versions credible. That will not be an easy call.

The two former associates agree neither on the sum they exchanged, nor on the purpose of the payments. Neither has written evidence to back him up. Both stories have changed substantially over the years.

The first five questions deal with the timing of the beginning of the business relationship between the two men and the nature of the mandate involved.

If Oliphant went with Schreiber’s version of events, he could conclude that Mulroney negotiated his lobbying services while he was still in office and with the goal of lobbying his former government. Both would amount to significant ethical breaches.

Alternatively, Mulroney has maintained that he had no business relationship with Schreiber until he stepped down as prime minister and that his activities were restricted to the international scene.

What is certain is that the two men met around the time that Mulroney was handing over the reins to Kim Campbell and that money changed hands between them for the first time while he was still an MP.

There is no evidence that Mulroney ever lobbied the Canadian government on Schreiber’s behalf. But then, after his party was wiped off the map in the 1993 election, there was no one left to lobby on Parliament Hill.

The next five questions deal with the nature of payments and the actual services performed in return.

Here again, the commission is in muddy waters. With the exception of a draft mandate, put together after the fact by the Mulroney clan, there is no paperwork to back up the terms of the cash transactions.

The heads of state Mulroney says he approached as part of his mandate have all passed away. The former prime minister kept no written record of his expenses and he only reported verbally.

In total, Mulroney had fewer face-to-face encounters with Schreiber after he took up a mandate on his behalf than over his time as prime minister.

Three more questions deal with the fiscal treatment of the money. It was declared for income tax purposes, but only after the fact and at a time when its existence was about to become public.

The last three questions deal with Stephen Harper and opposition allegations that he tried to protect Mulroney by expediting Schreiber’s extradition to Germany and dismissing an accusatory letter the lobbyist sent him in 2007. The prime minister maintains he did not see the letter.

In the end, question 11 is the pivotal one.

It asks: “Were these business and financial dealings appropriate considering the position of Mr. Mulroney as a current or former prime minister and member of Parliament?”

That answer will go in the history books.

Chantal Hebert writes for The Toronto Star Syndicate.

Just Posted

Fredericton police release scene of shooting spree, but ‘damage’ remains

FREDERICTON — Police have released the Fredericton apartment complex that was the… Continue reading

Google Generation’s push for more technology transforming health care: survey

TORONTO — Digitally savvy Canadians who make up the Google Generation are… Continue reading

UPDATED: Officials tour Hwy 2/Gaetz Avenue interchange

Deputy Premier Sarah Hoffman and local MLAs visit construction site

Bike thefts becoming ‘significant problem’ in Red Deer

Residents are sounding the alarm on the growing problem of bike theft… Continue reading

Red Deer approves 10 cannabis retail stores

Locations approved around the city

WATCH: A horse was neglected by its owner. Now the horse is suing

ESTACADA, Ore. - Justice is an 8-year-old American quarter horse who used… Continue reading

Red Sox old-timer’s memorabilia going up for sale

BIDDEFORD, Maine — Some items belonging to one of the Boston Red… Continue reading

Rival Korea leaders to meet in Pyongyang in September

SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of — The rival Koreas announced Monday that North… Continue reading

Charlottesville anniversary: Peaceful protests, few arrests

WASHINGTON — Thousands of people wanting to send a message that racism… Continue reading

‘I believe music heals people’: 12-year-old records tribute for shooting victims

YARMOUTH, N.S. — Twelve-year-old Josh Cochrane of Yarmouth, N.S., watched the news… Continue reading

Fallen officers’ families gather with Justin Trudeau after tragedy

The prime minister laid flowers at the growing memorial to the four victims of Friday’s violence

Fallen officers’ families gather with prime minister after tragedy

FREDERICTON — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau met with families of fallen Fredericton… Continue reading

Liberals showcase benefits of billions spent on infrastructure projects

OTTAWA — Little more than a year before the next federal election,… Continue reading

Fredericton parade ‘a way to celebrate even in the midst of this grief’: mayor

FREDERICTON — Two days after four people were gunned down in a… Continue reading

Most Read

Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month