Rewriting the rules won’t make Bloc go away

It’s been 19 years since Gilles Duceppe was elected as the first Bloc Quebecois member of Parliament.

It’s been 19 years since Gilles Duceppe was elected as the first Bloc Quebecois member of Parliament. His victory and the Bloquiste tide that soon followed turned decades of accumulated Canadian conventional wisdom about Quebec on its head.

In the lead-up to the 1990 by-election, it was widely assumed that the blue-collar voters of Montreal’s Laurier-Sainte-Marie would not care enough about the demise of a constitutional proposal such as the Meech Lake accord to elect a maverick. Today Duceppe is one of the longest-standing members of Parliament.

A significant section of the Canadian political class also argued that Quebecers would never trade their influential place on the governing side of the Commons for a permanent opposition berth. Six elections later, the Bloc continues to dominate the Quebec francophone landscape.

Finally, it was presumed that the Bloc would sabotage Parliament and undermine Canadian unity.

In fact, the Bloquistes have largely turned out to be model parliamentarians and, much to Duceppe’s chagrin, Canadian unity has done well on his watch.

Since 1990, support for sovereignty has gone from a post-Meech high of 65 per cent to just under the 40 per cent mark, a 25-point decline no single federalist strategy could possibly account for.

More so than any past attempt at constitutional accommodation, the Bloc’s presence in Parliament seems to have reinforced Quebecers’ comfort zone within the federation.

To this day, the Bloc has regularly thrived on the miscalculations of its opponents. The latest involves the notion that, short of beating Duceppe fair and square in an election, it would be a) possible and b) desirable to deal the sovereignist party a devastating blow by cutting off its federal funding.

In fact, the Bloc survived on individual donations for most of its existence.

In his first federal incarnation as a Tory cabinet minister in the late 1980s, Lucien Bouchard tried to bring a Quebec-style public financing system to a reluctant Progressive Conservative party. From day one, he put his new party on a regimen that excluded big corporate and union donations.

The public funding formula Jean Chretien introduced in 2003 was a gift to the Bloc but hardly a lifeline.

In its aftermath, the party suspended its Quebec-wide fundraising drives, vacating the field in favour of the Parti Quebecois.

According to federal Democratic Reform Minister Steven Fletcher, many Canadians are frustrated with the notion that their taxes are funding a sovereignist party. Given that the subsidy is based on a per-vote formula, that is a bogus argument, unworthy of Fletcher’s ministerial title.

The Quebecers who support the Bloc are taxpayers, with no less right to have the $1.95 subsidy tied to their vote channelled to the party of their choice.

To craft new rules so as to disqualify the Bloc from receiving the subsidy would amount to treating its supporters like second-class voters. And it is hard to see how Parliament could become more relevant by trying to make it a private federalist club.

The escalating debate over the public funding of the Bloc is really another symptom of the growing frustration over the fact that the party poses a formidable mathematical obstacle to the securing of a governing majority. But the predictable result of a frontal attack on the Bloc’s election subsidy would be the disappearance of the already eroded Conservative beachhead in Quebec.

On that basis, it looks like this idea comes from the same playbook as the culture cuts that changed the game for the worse in Quebec for Stephen Harper in the last election.

Chantal Hebert writes for The Toronto Star Syndicate.

Just Posted

Person airlifted to hospital after collision near Innisfail

One person was airlifted to hospital after a serious collision west of… Continue reading

Sunny weather improves farmers’ prospects

A harvester kicking up dust. It’s a picture that will bring a… Continue reading

Rural transit pilot project being considered

Penhold, Innisfail and Red Deer County councils to decide whether to go ahead with project

Red Deer fire station up for sale

Home sweet home at Fire Station 4

‘Stupid’ law preventing Canada’s re-engagement with Iran: retired envoy

OTTAWA — The real reason the Liberal government hasn’t been able to… Continue reading

Voters head to polls for BC municipal elections today

VANCOUVER — Voters in British Columbia will head to the polls today… Continue reading

All sharks tagged in N.S. expedition can now be tracked on Ocearch website

HALIFAX — All six of the sharks tagged in Nova Scotian waters… Continue reading

Memorial service for former PQ minister Lise Payette today in Montreal

MONTREAL — Mourners will gather to remember former Parti Quebecois cabinet minister… Continue reading

Immunotherapy scores a first win against some breast cancers

For the first time, one of the new immunotherapy drugs has shown… Continue reading

‘Mom I’m in trouble:’ Canadian, Brit face 10 years in jail for alleged graffiti

GRANDE PRAIRIE, Alta. — The mother of a Canadian who was arrested… Continue reading

Coyote on the prowl near Penhold

This coyote was out on the prowl in a field just west… Continue reading

Most Read