Scheer faces an uphill battle

Scheer faces an uphill battle

Since he lost the federal election last month, Andrew Scheer has tried, but mostly failed to make the case that his maiden campaign as leader has resulted, if not in the hoped-for return to power, at least in a moral victory.

To sustain his thesis, Scheer has pointed to the party’s first place in the popular vote, the larger caucus he is about to bring in the House of Commons and the loss by the Liberals of their majority.

He has cast the result as the first of a two-step return to government. After all, less than 24 months elapsed between Stephen Harper’s initial defeat in 2004 and the start of a Conservative decade in government.

Whether any of those arguments will allow Scheer to avoid the many knives headed for his back since election night is very much an open question.

In almost every significant way, he is in a much weaker position than Harper was in the aftermath of the 2004 defeat. Notwithstanding the larger caucus that will be gathering for the first time on Wednesday, so is the Conservative party.

When he lost his first campaign to Paul Martin, Harper had just co-engineered the reunification of the conservative movement under a single party.

He had won two successive leadership elections on the first ballot.

Only months before he led the reunited Conservatives in his first campaign, Harper had secured the support of 69 per cent of those who participated in that party’s leadership vote.

It would have been next to impossible to find a high-profile Conservative to challenge Harper’s leadership, let alone to do so successfully.

By comparison, Scheer, who became leader on a 13th ballot, was not the first choice of many of those who eventually helped him defeat Maxime Bernier.

They saw Scheer as a caretaker for the party during its spell in opposition rather than the person most likely to bring them back to power.

Harper’s A-team in cabinet sat out the contest.

Some of those who took a pass back then were said to be biding their time, in the expectation that it would take more than one election for voter fatigue with the Liberals to really set in.

The survival of any major political leader is always contingent, if not on victory, at least on a result that puts the party on a winning track.

Scheer’s results point in the opposite direction.

In 2004, Harper’s 99 seats amounted to the best Conservative score since Brian Mulroney won the 1988 free trade election.

But it was not so much the seat total that made the Conservative result encouraging as it was the location of those gains.

In Ontario, where the Canadian Alliance had won just two seats in 2000, the Harper-led Conservatives took 24. That number suggested the reunited party and its leader were both viable options in the electoral market of central Canada.

Scheer’s results suggest otherwise.

On his watch, the Conservatives finished with a smaller share of the popular vote of Canada’s largest province than they got in their 2015 defeat.

And in Quebec, where Harper had become deeply unpopular by the time of his last campaign, Scheer fared as poorly as his predecessor.

The Conservatives lost to the Liberals — decisively, in many cases — in most of the large urban areas outside of the Prairies, including Toronto and Montreal.

In the big picture, Scheer’s post-election Conservative party is more dependent on the support of the Prairie provinces than the Reform Party used to be.

In Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta, the Conservatives won a larger share of the popular vote last month than Preston Manning’s Reform Party did in its final appearance on the federal ballot in 1997.

Going forward, that regional strength stands to sap the partyís growth nationally.

That’s because much of the glue that Scheer and his team used to bind the Conservative base in the Prairies is the signature commitment to turn back the clock on the federal fight against climate change and to move forward on pipelines.

Whether Scheer remains as leader or not, it will be hard for the federal Conservatives to find their way back to the environmental mainstream without alienating their base, not to mention the region’s vocal premiers. But if they stay the course, their Prairie fortress could turn into an electoral jail.

For today’s Conservatives, climate change could become the same kind of political albatross that constitutional reconciliation became for Brian Mulroney’s Tories.

After the Meech Lake Accord failed in 1990, they were damned in Quebec if they stopped pursuing the issue, but damned in much of the rest of the country if they did not.

A big difference is that while the Constitution was eventually chased off the radar by other pressing issues, climate change is set to hold pride of place for years to come.

Chantal Hebert is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Whistle Stop Cafe owner Christopher Scott and his sister Melodie are serving sit-down customers in their Mirror diner to protest health restrictions that they say are unfair to restaurants and other small businesses. Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
Central Alberta restaurant owner defies health restrictions by serving diners

Whistle Stop Cafe owner says pandemic restrictions unfair to restaurants and small businesses

Alberta’s chief medical officer of health Dr. Deena Hinshaw said in her daily update on Monday that 362 new COVID cases have been identified and 7,200 tests done in the last 24 hours. (File photo)
COVID-19: UK variant may have entered broader community says Alberta health minister

25 cases of two variants identified in Alberta and one not linked to travel

An ice sculpture of a bee with a timely message was created near the Ross Street Patio. It’s party of a Downtown Business Association initiative to draw more people downtown to support local businesses. (Photo by LANA MICHELIN/Advocate staff).
Ice sculptures created to draw more people to downtown Red Deer

Three sculptures can be seem at various venues

Lab and x-ray technologist Rebecca Walter demonstrates a new digital radiographic X-ray unit funded by an $850,000 donation. The new unit is at the Sylvan Lake Advanced Ambulatory Care Service.
Photo contributed
New Sylvan Lake X-ray unit up and running

Radiographic x-ray unit made possible by $850,000 donation from Sylvan Lake couple

(Black Press file photo)
Police seeking suspects in Bowden armed robbery

Man was beaten and robbed of his wallet

Terrance Josephson of the Princeton Posse, at left, and Tyson Conroy of the Summerland Steam clash during a Junior B hockey game at the Summerland Arena in the early spring of 2020. (John Arendt - Summerland Review)
QUIZ: How much do you know about hockey?

Test your knowledge of Canada’s national winter sport

Green Bay Packers' Adrian Amos pauses after losing the NFC championship NFL football game to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in Green Bay, Wis., Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021. The Buccaneers defeated the Packers 31-26 to advance to the Super Bowl. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)
Aaron Rodgers’ ‘uncertain’ future hangs over Green Bay

Aaron Rodgers’ ‘uncertain’ future hangs over Green Bay

Toronto Argonauts head coach Scott Milanovich calls the plays on the sideline against Winnipeg Blue Bombers during the first half of CFL action in Winnipeg on August 14, 2015. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
Scott Milanovich steps down as Edmonton’s head coach to pursue opportunities in NFL

Scott Milanovich steps down as Edmonton’s head coach to pursue opportunities in NFL

Toronto Raptors guard Fred VanVleet (23) goes under Indiana Pacers guards Malcolm Brogdon (7) and Jeremy Lamb (26) to shoot during the second half of an NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Monday, Jan. 25, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Michael Conroy
Brogdon scores 36 points to lead Pacers over Toronto Raptors

Brogdon scores 36 points to lead Pacers over Toronto Raptors

FILE - In this Feb. 14, 2020, file photo, baseballs occupy a bucket after use during fielding practice during spring training baseball workouts for pitchers and catchers at Cleveland Indians camp in Avondale, Ariz. Major League Baseball is suspending all political contributions in the wake of last week's invasion of the U.S. Capitol by a mob loyal to President Donald Trump, joining a wave of major corporations rethinking their efforts to lobby Washington. “In light of the unprecedented events last week at the U.S. Capitol, MLB is suspending contributions from its Political Action Committee pending a review of our political contribution policy going forward,” the league said in a statement to The Associated Press on Wednesday, Jan. 13, 2021. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File)
Cactus League asks MLB to delay spring training due to COVID

Cactus League asks MLB to delay spring training due to COVID

Patrick Cantlay, right, bumps fists with Andrew Putman before teeing off on the first hole during the final round of The American Express golf tournament on the Pete Dye Stadium Course at PGA West Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021, in La Quinta, Calif. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez)
Si Woo Kim holds off Cantlay to win The American Express

Si Woo Kim holds off Cantlay to win The American Express

Danielle Kang winds up to hit her tee shot on the fifth hole during the final round of the Tournament of Champions LPGA golf tournament, Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021, in Lake Buena Vista, Fla. (AP Photo/Phelan M. Ebenhack)
Jessica Korda rallies to beat Kang in playoff at LPGA opener, Henderson ninth

Jessica Korda rallies to beat Kang in playoff at LPGA opener, Henderson ninth

COVID-19 scare prompts cancellation of Canada-U. S. soccer scrimmage in Florida

COVID-19 scare prompts cancellation of Canada-U. S. soccer scrimmage in Florida

Coach John Herdman prepares for practice with Bev Priestman, a member of his coaching staff, ahead of Sunday's soccer game against the United States in the final of the CONCACAF Women's Olympic Qualifying Championship, in Houston on Saturday, Feb. 20, 2016.  THE CANADIAN PRESS/Neil Davidson
Priestman includes six uncapped players in her first roster as Canada soccer coach

Priestman includes six uncapped players in her first roster as Canada soccer coach

Most Read