Scheer misses his opportunity to deliver proper climate change plan

Andrew Scheer is right when he says there are ways to fight climate change without imposing a carbon tax. Unfortunately, the Conservative leader hasn’t found them.

His climate change plan, recently released with much fanfare, is a mishmash of ideas — some good, some irrelevant, most ineffective.

Missing from the plan is any concrete notion of how Canada under a Conservative government would meet its Paris greenhouse-gas emission targets.

This is too bad, because in questioning the conventional wisdom around carbon taxes (or what its proponents call carbon pricing), Scheer was onto something.

Economists tend to love carbon pricing, because it uses market forces. Conservative thinkers, such as Reform Party founder Preston Manning, support it for the same reason.

They like the fact carbon pricing bypasses the heavy hand of government. It does not require, for instance, a ban on gas-guzzling SUVs. It merely makes explicit the real social costs of using fossil fuels to power them.

Once consumers are faced with the real cost of gassing up their vehicles, the theory goes, they will respond by driving less or by switching to some other form of transportation, such as electric cars.

Carbon pricing is neat, elegant and — in theory — the most efficient way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Like other solutions beloved by economists, it assumes people have perfect information, act rationally and will adjust to the new price instantaneously and painlessly.

In the real world, however, people are not always so co-operative.

Even when government promises to rebate the proceeds of any carbon tax, they remain skeptical.

This is the anti-tax mood that Conservative politicians like Scheer and Ontario Premier Doug Ford have managed to exploit.

Yet opposition to carbon taxes need not mean giving up on the fight against global warming. As Mark Jaccard, a respected climate change economist at Simon Fraser University, has pointed out, there are other tools available.

Writing in the Globe and Mail last year, Jaccard said that what he called flexible regulation would work just as well, if not better.

He argued that in British Columbia, regulations requiring BC Hydro to close generating plants fuelled by coal and natural gas have proved to be three times more effective than the province’s famed carbon tax.

Similarly, he wrote, California regulations on electricity generation and automobile fuel account for the bulk of carbon-emission reductions in that state. Its cap-and-trade carbon pricing system accounts for only 15 per cent of reductions.

Had he wished, Scheer could have built on Jaccard’s critique to come up with a compelling alternative to the federal Liberal government’s carbon price strategy.

Alas, he did not.

Thomas Walkom is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta legislature to resume with throne speech, tabling of blockade bill

EDMONTON — Alberta politicians are returning to the legislature with a promise… Continue reading

Drugmaker readies possible coronavirus vaccine for testing

Drugmaker Moderna has shipped its first batch of a possible coronavirus vaccine… Continue reading

Scotiabank reports $2.3B first-quarter profit, tops expectations by analysts

TORONTO — Bank of Nova Scotia is optimistic its international ventures are… Continue reading

A look at carbon prices across the country

OTTAWA — As of Jan. 1, every Canadian and all Canadian businesses… Continue reading

More Red Deer seniors could be dealing with homelessness, inadequate housing in future

Red Deer is short 200 affordable seniors’ housing units: Bridges study shows

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

Kids under 12 banned from heading soccer balls in practice

LONDON — Children up to the age of 12 will be banned… Continue reading

Oilers among winners, Panthers losers at NHL trade deadline

Mired in a run of one playoff appearance in 13 seasons, the… Continue reading

‘Mixed verdict’ in Weinstein case may disappoint some #MeToo supporters: scholar

The verdict in Harvey Weinstein’s sexual assault trial is in, but Canadian… Continue reading

Ex-coach gets 6 months in college scam, runs from courthouse

BOSTON — The former men’s tennis coach at the University of Texas… Continue reading

Kenney says investor confidence needed after Teck mine project killed

EDMONTON — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says his government is taking action… Continue reading

‘They loved life’: Family and friends give tearful tributes at Kobe Bryant at memorial

LOS ANGELES —Tears streamed down Vanessa Bryant’s face as she spoke about… Continue reading

Feds introduce bill dropping some restrictions on assisted dying

OTTAWA — The Trudeau government has introduced legislation aimed at making it… Continue reading

Most Read