Sell Alberta’s air fleet

I don’t care a whole lot that Thomas Lukaszuk took his daughter with him on three Alberta Air Transportation Services flights while he was a cabinet minister. That would be to focus on a problem’s detail while ignoring the problem itself.

I don’t care a whole lot that Thomas Lukaszuk took his daughter with him on three Alberta Air Transportation Services flights while he was a cabinet minister. That would be to focus on a problem’s detail while ignoring the problem itself.

The Alberta cabinet has been using the province’s four aircraft as a limousine service for years, only patching up the rules when ethical problems crop up.

Remember in 2004, then-premier Ralph Klein stonewalling questions of his use of government aircraft with: “You don’t believe me? You don’t believe me? You don’t believe me?” This wasn’t the first instance of questionable use of free flights by a long shot.

The problem is that the Alberta government, registered as a Canadian airline, has four aircraft in the first place. That’s a situation unique in all of Canada.

Public interest groups have scanned thousands of pages of flight manifests since 2007 (when they were first made public), to see whose spouse or family member got a free ride on a plane on which date. They cross-reference that information with cabinet itineraries to see whether individual trips were for government work, or for private or party benefit.

That’s a heck of a lot of tedious work, and I’m glad somebody has the patience to do it and report back.

What bothers me is that the government has its own airline at all.

Technically, the government isn’t in competition with private business — until the tedious studies of the flight manifests are revealed, and one cabinet minister or another finds it prudent to pay back the estimated commercial cost of a flight that might have taken place outside the rules.

What bothers me is the line that’s been overlooked in auditor Merwin Saher’s report in August that says that if all these flights had been booked commercially, taxpayers would have saved $3.9 million.

Just before the Labour Day weekend, an anonymous tipster sent a report to CBC News that Progressive Conservative party leadership candidate Thomas Lukaszuk took his daughter with him on seven flights.

Lukaszuk has since narrowed that down to three, saying that as a single parent, he needed his daughter with him on “non-school” days.

When Saher’s report was made public, Lukaszuk repaid the estimated cost of the trips — $1,400 — on his own initiative “so that no one could question my integrity.”

OK, it’s a bit late but I can accept that.

But consider how Lukaszuk dropped a party bombshell in an interview later.

“But if my cutting a cheque is setting an example, boy, there will be a lot of very large cheques (cut by other ministers),” he told the Edmonton Journal.

Think about the subtext there. These flights are approved under the rules of the Alberta Treasury Board. It’s chairman is Finance Minister Doug Horner.

Horner is reported to have brought his wife with him on 23 flights since the 2007 reporting rule was in place. And his is only one example here.

I have a small problem with spouses accompanying elected officials on flights at my expense.

I quite understand that the hours are long for cabinet ministers, that quiet time with a spouse may be at a premium, much less to have a meal together.

It’s no treat being a political spouse, either.

All this is understood.

So filling an empty seat on a flight to a meeting in Grande Prairie and back, what’s the harm?

None, really, if the flight was booked charter and non-government passengers were not charged to the taxpayer.

Does anyone doubt that there is a charter airline in Alberta willing to be on call to the government, at a significant discount? That, given a bit of notice, they could have the right type of aircraft at any given airport on any given day, at a competitive price for a preferred customer?

That’s pretty well standard practice in other Canadian provinces. And it would save Alberta taxpayers millions.

The unseemly manner in which the whole Tory party dog-piled on former premier Alison Redford for red-lining a standard government practice looks pretty hypocritical right now.

Lukaszuk says he wants all flights by cabinet ministers since 2007 re-examined. Boy, won’t there be a lot of big repayment cheques made then, he said.

What does that tell you? It tells me that it’s time to liquidate Air Alberta. It tells me that open bidding for charter services is a good idea, since all Tories believe private industry is better than public industry, 100 per cent of the time, anyway.

About $3.9 million better, according to Saher’s report.

The Air Transportation Service is a while elephant, fiscally and ethically. Get rid of it.

Greg Neiman is a retired Advocate editor. Follow his blog at readersadvocate.blogspot.ca or email greg.neiman.blog@gmail.com.

Just Posted

Smaller, more affordable, lots wanted in Red Deer’s Evergreen neighbourhood

Council approves first reading of requested lot-size changes

Political shifts, sales slump cast shadow over gun industry

When gunmakers and dealers gather this week in Las Vegas for the… Continue reading

Yellow vests in Canada bear no resemblance to protesters in France: ambassador

OTTAWA — Canada’s ambassador to France says this country’s yellow-vest protest movement… Continue reading

China demands U.S. withdraw request for Canada to extradite Huawei executive

BEIJING — China issued fresh demands Tuesday that the U.S. abandon its… Continue reading

Health Canada ready to unveil newly revamped Canada Food Guide

OTTAWA — Canadians will finally see Health Canada’s modern spin on healthy… Continue reading

New Canada Food Guide nixes portion sizes, promotes plant-based proteins

Guide no longer lists milk and dairy products as a distinct food group

B.C. animators land Oscar nominations

‘Animal Behaviour’ by Vancouver’s David Fine and Alison Snowden among several Canadians on the short list

Canadian talent abound on newly revamped Vancouver Whitecaps squad

VANCOUVER — The Vancouver Whitecaps may need to stock up on maple… Continue reading

China demands US drop Huawei extradition request with Canada

China detained two Canadians on Dec. 10 in an apparent attempt to pressure Canada to release Meng

Rugby Canada Hall of Fame a family affair for hard-nosed forward Hans de Goede

Hans de Goede, a hard-nosed lock forward who captained Canada at the… Continue reading

5 burning questions ahead of the Oscar nominations

NEW YORK — The Oscars still don’t have a host, but on… Continue reading

‘Bao,’ ‘Animal Behaviour,’ ‘Weekends’ among Canadian Oscar nominees

LOS ANGELES — Several Canadians have landed Oscar nominations. The category for… Continue reading

Hollywood announces 2019 Oscar nominations

Netflix has scored its first best picture nomination, something the streaming giant has dearly sought

Opinion: Faith in immigration must be preserved

Canada has a deserved reputation for extending its arms to newcomers, but… Continue reading

Most Read