Separation means different things to Alberta and Quebec

Separation means different things to Alberta and Quebec

In the ongoing Alberta-versus-Quebec debate, it is increasingly hard to differentiate facts from fiction.

For example, to believe some of the commentary, both provinces — for different reasons — are deeply unhappy with Justin Trudeau’s re-election victory. The return in strength of the Bloc Quebecois tends to be exhibit one in those analyses.

But in reality, while Alberta did soundly reject the federal Liberals on Oct. 21, it is the Conservative alternative to the current prime minister that was left standing at the altar by the Quebec electorate.

In last month’s election, Andrew Scheer earned his best score in the popular vote in Alberta and his worst in Quebec.

Last week, the polling firm Abacus reported that a majority of Quebecers would be OK with Alberta leaving the federation.

That high proportion stands in stark contrast with the results in the other provinces. Nowhere else is a majority on side with the idea. In Alberta, only 36 per cent responded positively to the notion of their province’s secession.

But are those numbers really a symptom of ever-increasing frictions between the two provinces, or do they mostly reflect a stark difference in the perception of secession?

Quebecers have lived with the sovereignty debate for the better part of five decades and have twice over that period voted on whether to remain in the federation.

In 1995, half of them believed independence was the better option.

These days, separation does not generate the enthusiasm it did back then, but that does not make it any less legitimate in the eyes of the province’s electorate.

At this juncture, two of the parties represented in the national assembly are pro-sovereignty. From one poll to the next, anywhere from 30 per cent to 40 per cent of Quebecers still say they would vote yes to the province’s secession in a referendum.

From the perspective of the voters who have spent the most time thinking about life outside the federation, it is not automatically negative for a province to consider a future independent from the rest of Canada.

From the perspective of sovereigntist supporters, the secession of Alberta would actually be a positive development, inasmuch as it could amount to the kiss of life for their own independence project.

A few weeks ago, Alberta Premier Jason Kenney tasked a commission to study a list of made-in-Quebec options liable — at least in his mind — to increase the province’s leverage in the federation.

The options range from Alberta opting out of the CPP to create its own pension plan to the setting up of a provincial police force to replace the RCMP and the collection by the province of the income taxes.

In Quebec, Kenney’s proposals barely elicited a shrug. Given that those policies have been in place in Quebec for as long as its people can remember, it would have been hard for anyone to find the Alberta premier’s moves particularly bold.

Quebec has long been governed by parties with much more ambitious constitutional agendas than anything Kenney is considering.

Indeed, were there to be another constitutional round, the Coalition Avenir Quebec government would likely bring the province’s traditional demands and more to the negotiating table.

Polls also show Quebec to be the province most hostile to new pipeline projects.

That reality is reflected in the fact that no provincial party will support plans for a pipeline to link Alberta’s oilfields to the refineries of the East coast.

But Quebecer’s hostility to developments related to fossil fuels extends beyond out-of-province industries.

In 2011, Quebec’s shale gas industry recruited former premier Lucien Bouchard as its chief lobbyist.

Bouchard may be Quebec’s most influential ex-politician. But in the case of shale gas, he hit a wall. The hope was that his image would improve that of the industry. The reverse happened. He relinquished the position after two years.

At around the same time, the province’s then-Parti Quebecois government announced plans to impose a moratorium on shale gas development.

Shortly after he became premier last year, Francois Legault told Quebec’s federation of municipalities that his government was no more open to shale gas projects than its Liberal and PQ predecessors.

In recent days, there have been musings in both Alberta and Quebec’s provincial capitals of the two governments finding common ground in their respective desire for more provincial autonomy.

After all, is not Quebec intervening in support of Alberta in its court battle against Bill C-69 and the reinforced environmental assessment powers that law vests in the federal government?

But Legault’s government is also in court with British Columbia over that province’s contention that it has the constitutional power to regulate the amount of oil and gas that transits through its territory.

All of which is to say that political autonomy means different things to different provinces. What B.C. and Quebec would like to do with more autonomy is not at all what Kenney has in mind.

Chantal Hebert is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The Red Deer Boxing Club has raised money to expand programming but still needs a larger space to operate in when it’s allowed to reopen. (Contributed photo).
Red Deer Boxing Club has obtained $70,000 in grants but is still seeking a larger space

Without expanded programming, the grants must be returned: manager

Red Deer city council gave final approval to a mask bylaw that will go into effect on Nov. 30. (Black Press file photo).
Red Deer city council approves mask bylaw that takes effect Monday

It could be ‘superceded’ by a provincial mask bylaw, if one is announced Tuesday

Alberta’s chief medical officer of health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, announced more than 1,500 active cases in Alberta Monday afternoon and five additional deaths. (Photo by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
New COVID rules coming

Central zone active cases up by 100 in last 24 hours

Lynn Van Laar, chair of this year’s Christmas Wish Breakfast, said the event was planned outdoors to minimize the risk of COVID. Photo by Mamta Lulla/Advocate staff
Outdoor Christmas Wish Breakfast helps central Alberta families this holiday season

The coronavirus pandemic isn’t going to stop children from having a merry… Continue reading

Hockey Canada president and CEO Scott Smith speaks during a news conference in Calgary, Alta., Wednesday, Dec. 6, 2017. Hockey Canada announced Tuesday that two players at its nation junior selection camp have tested positive for COVID-19. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Two players at Canada’s World Junior selection camp test positive for COVID-19

Canada’s World Junior selection camp in Red Deer came to a screeching… Continue reading

Los Angeles Rams cornerback Jalen Ramsey (20) knocks a pass away from Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Mike Evans (13) during the first half of an NFL football game Monday, Nov. 23, 2020, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Mark LoMoglio)
Goff throws for 376 yards, 3 TDs in Rams’ 27-24 win vs Bucs

Goff throws for 376 yards, 3 TDs in Rams’ 27-24 win vs Bucs

New York Red Bulls midfielder Dru Yearwood, left, fights for the ball against Toronto FC midfielder Jonathan Osorio during an MLS soccer match in Harrison, N.J., on November 8, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Eduardo Munoz Alvarez
Experienced Toronto FC ready to take on upstart Nashville SC in playoff action

Experienced Toronto FC ready to take on upstart Nashville SC in playoff action

Canada's head coach Dave Lowry during practice at the IIHF World Junior Championship in Helsinki, Finland, on Wednesday, December 30, 2015. The Winnipeg Jets have hired Lowry as an assistant coach. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Former WHL head coach Dave Lowry joins Paul Maurice’s staff in Winnipeg

Former WHL head coach Dave Lowry joins Paul Maurice’s staff in Winnipeg

Felix Auger-Aliassime, of Canada, returns a shot to Dominic Thiem, of Austria, during the fourth round of the US Open tennis championships in New York on September 7, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Seth Wenig
A steady if unspectacular season comes to a close for Canada’s Auger-Aliassime

A steady if unspectacular season comes to a close for Canada’s Auger-Aliassime

Sacramento Kings' Alex Len (25) collects a rebound against Brooklyn Nets' Jarrett Allen (31) during the first half of an NBA basketball game Friday, Aug. 7, 2020 in Lake Buena Vista, Fla. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Ashley Landis
Raptors continue to shore up frontcourt, signing Alex Len to one-year deal

Raptors continue to shore up frontcourt, signing Alex Len to one-year deal

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau speak to the media about the COVID-19 virus outside Rideau Cottage in Ottawa, Friday, Nov. 20, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Freeland says Liberals will deliver economic, fiscal update on Nov. 30

Freeland says Liberals will deliver economic, fiscal update on Nov. 30

Most Read