Smith hardly a right-wing boogey man

I was recently taken aback by an Advocate editorial wherein John Stewart raked Danielle Smith over the proverbial coals for comments she made about the premier.

I was recently taken aback by an Advocate editorial wherein John Stewart raked Danielle Smith over the proverbial coals for comments she made about the premier.

“I think Ms. Redford doesn’t like Alberta all that much,” Smith said. “She doesn’t like who we are. She doesn’t like our character. She wants to change it.”

Stewart opined that Smith’s comments (his words were “rant” and “diatribe”) at a news conference on day three of the campaign were “offensive and more than a little disturbing.”

“She’s decided to draw a line in the sand,” said Stewart, “suggesting that anyone who doesn’t think the way that she does is not truly an Albertan.”

Does anyone really believe this is what Smith meant to imply? What she genuinely believes? It’s preposterous.

Are we honestly that afraid of the right-winged boogey-man?

I’m not sure this response is even warranted, since there are so many substantive issues to address in this election, but Stewart’s depiction of Smith (and by association her party) are so over-the-top reactionary as to demand fair context and balance.

Admittedly, Smith’s comments were badly-worded and unnecessarily personal; taken out of context, they do seem harsh and mean-spirited. So here’s some context:

Firstly, Smith was responding to comments earlier made by Redford.

“I think it’s about the future,” said Redford, “understanding that we’re a different community, that we’re a different society, that we have the opportunity to make some really wise and long-term decisions that will change the character of our province.”

The substance of Redford’s words echo what many political commentators have repeated since she assumed office: that the influx of people moving to Alberta for work over the past couple of decades has changed the cultural and political climate of our province.

We are collectively now less conservative is the theory advanced — more amenable to leftward shifts in “the character of our province.”

As an electorate, we are left to surmise what sorts of character changes Redford envisions for our future, but one thing is clear: it’s headed left on the political spectrum.

And this is precisely the distinction Smith was trying to make.

“Ms. Redford — who has only ever worked in government or for government, and spent many, many, many years working outside of Alberta — has a great deal of faith in what big government schemes can do,” said Smith later in the same news conference. “I don’t believe we need to have a pan-Canadian multi-jurisdictional government-led program on anything.”

“She is a big government liberal,” continued Smith. “I’m a small government conservative. That’s really what it comes down to.”

When Smith says that Redford doesn’t really like the character of our province — that she wants to change it — Smith is, in fact, playing off the premier’s own words and stated aspirations.

Should Smith have been more diplomatic in her discourse? Less personal? Absolutely, but I would call it a minor misstep in an otherwise civil campaign thus far.

Essentially, Smith is saying that many Albertans like the conservative nature of our collective character, and aren’t comfortable with left-leaning change.

Secondly, Stewart not only jumps, but flat-out free-falls, to all manner of puzzling conclusions respecting the concept of change in his aforementioned editorial.

“If you believe that change in Alberta is good and necessary,” said Stewart, “if you believe that evolution is part of the political and social process, then you apparently don’t belong in Smith’s Alberta. She may not even like you very much.”

What? I feel like I just stepped into the twilight zone or something.

Not only does Smith believe that change is good and necessary, but her entire campaign hinges upon it.

Every page of the Wildrose playbook speaks of changing the politics of complacency and entitlement, of inertia and bureaucracy, of promises broken and resources squandered by the embattled PC dynasty.

No one speaks louder for change than Danielle Smith.

Finally, Stewart ended his piece with an abstruse reference to polling numbers: “The latest polls show that Smith and the Wildrose party have between 34 and 41 per cent of the popular support,” said Stewart. “If those numbers are anywhere near accurate, that still means that the overwhelming majority of Albertans aren’t interested in a stand-pat Alberta.”

Again, here’s the context: based on Forum Research’s latest poll, if the election were held today, the Wildrose would form a majority government with 58 seats, and the PCs a distant second with 22.

Another poll ( projects as follows: Wildrose — majority with 50 seats (39.6 per cent of popular vote) and PCs — 27 seats (30.3 per cent of popular vote), at time of writing.

Evidently, enough Albertans are interested in Danielle Smith and her message of meaningful change that they just may hand Redford and her Tories an historic pass directly to opposition. The race is clearly on.

Vesna Higham is a local lawyer, former Red Deer city councillor and a freelance columnist.

Just Posted

Separate lightning strikes hit two vehicles near Ponoka

No one injured in lightning strikes on Thursday morning

Government changes working conditions to meet wildfire observers’ needs

Wildfire observers opposed mandatory days off with no pay

More RCMP resources recommended for Red Deer’s downtown and other priorities

City council to consider where to designate three additional officers

Red Deer rents among the lowest in Canada

One-bedroom unit averages $1,056 per month

Rain doesn’t scare visitors away from Westerner Days

Attendance steady at Red Deer fair and exhibition

Fashion Fridays: 5 casual summer dress styles

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

American father, two sons among passengers on plane in fatal Labrador crash

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — An American father and his two sons vacationing… Continue reading

Apollo 11 astronauts reunite on 50th anniversary of moonshot

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — Apollo 11 astronauts Buzz Aldrin and Michael Collins… Continue reading

Fast-growing web of doorbell cams raises privacy fears

The woodsy community of Wolcott, Connecticut, doesn’t see a lot of crime.… Continue reading

Statistics Canada reports retail sales fell 0.1 per cent in May to $51.5B

OTTAWA — Canadian retail sales fell for the first time in four… Continue reading

Bank of Canada lowers qualifying rate used in mortgage stress tests

OTTAWA — The Bank of Canada has lowered the rate used by… Continue reading

Stop CBSA policy requiring bulletproof vests in immigrant detention: advocates

OTTAWA — A group of doctors, lawyers, legal scholars and human-rights organizations… Continue reading

Ontario attorney general invokes PM in spat over refugee legal aid

OTTAWA — Ontario’s attorney general is taking his fight for more federal… Continue reading

Judge finds Dennis Oland not guilty of murder in multi-millionaire father’s death

SAINT JOHN, N.B. — Dennis Oland was cheered and applauded by supporters… Continue reading

Most Read