Starting over on Senate reform

Alberta is pursuing an elected Senate for Canada; however, it won’t function as hoped, even if Prime Minister Stephen Harper succeeds with implementation.

Alberta is pursuing an elected Senate for Canada; however, it won’t function as hoped, even if Prime Minister Stephen Harper succeeds with implementation.

As experience from other countries shows, elected senates in parliaments don’t represent regions well. Australia’s elected senate votes by party, not region. The reason is parliaments have non-confidence votes that can overturn governments, making party solidarity strong. COAG (Council of Australian Governments) represents regions.

Elected senates are more often found in presidential systems, such as the U.S., which lack confidence votes, making co-operation across party lines on local matters not unusual. The U.S. also grants some powers to Washington that in Canada are provincial and beyond our Senate’s review.

Canada’s appointed Senate slows controversial legislation, alerting the public for lobby of MPs; it rarely blocks the elected Commons if public opinion doesn’t alter government plans.

Two elected houses are more likely to deadlock when controlled by different parties. Alberta’s plan has no deadlock provision. Australia’s deadlock-breaking process does not work well. Other parliaments with elected senates, such as Spain’s, have a weak senate to avoid deadlock.

Is a more legislatively powerful Canadian Senate, one that would also represent regions, even possible in our parliamentary system?

Representation by population for the House of Commons gives Ontario and Quebec together 60 per cent of seats. The Senate was to balance that with representation by area; it has never done so.

Alberta seeks to fortify the present Senate by election; with Alberta’s six seats and Ontario’s and Quebec’s 24 each, that would weaken Alberta. The previous plan, a Triple E Senate — equal numbers of senators by province, elected, effective, would have given the six smallest provinces a majority with 13.5 per cent of the population. Neither plan can achieve regional balance, let alone regional representation in national affairs.

Regional representation includes not only means to protect vulnerable areas, but also co-ordination of government levels on economic and social challenges where both the provinces and Parliament have roles. Case in point is the standoff over the Canada Job Grant.

Reform also should retain a capacity for what the current Senate does well: creation of good quality policy studies at low cost.

Suitable persons appointed to the Senate for lengthy terms specialize through committee work, gaining more expertise in a policy field than MPs with frequent turnover and more diverse duties. Senate committees usually hold more extensive public hearings than do Commons ones. Absence of election facilitates co-operation, and multi-party endorsement of well-researched Senate reports. Final say for policy and political accountability remain with the elected Commons.

For example, the Senate Committee on National Security and Defence, when chaired by Liberal Colin Kenney with Liberal majorities, was a critic of Liberal government rust-out of military equipment. Later, minority Conservative governments better equipped our troops in Afghanistan.

After, when Canadians suffered twice the casualty rate as allies from road-side bombs, Kenney pushed for helicopters. When acquired, they saved limbs and lives.

Harper seeks a Supreme Court opinion on his Senate reform initiative, including “elected-appointee” senators. A “no” could create an opening for ideas from other parliamentary systems.

Exhibit A: Germany’s senate (Bundesrat) is the actual provincial governments. Voting is weighted, ranging from three for the smallest province to six for the largest. It does not hand control of the central government to provinces because the elected chamber (Bundestag) has final say in most matters, unlike Canada’s already powerful provinces.

Exhibit B: Australia’s COAG brings government levels face-to-face, but outside parliamentary transparency and accountability, where an elected senate fails to represent regions.

I believe Canada should a) add an intergovernmental dimension to our Senate, making room for both government levels; b) retain the Senate’s research and public consultation functions but add joint appointment: many policy fields today have local and national aspects and are occupied to some extent by both levels.

Senate powers should be on a sliding scale, with regional control (absolute veto) for shared matters that are closer to the local; federal final say (suspensive veto) for matters more national. Weighted voting by region and government level can assist communitarian justice: a topic too extensive for this space today.

The Council of the Federation is the place to begin — now only a premiers’ meeting, by adding the federal government similar to COAG. There, evolve practical final says between government levels for shared powers.

Lastly, merge the Council of the Federation with the Senate: for a policy-strong, regionally balanced parliamentary Senate.

David Baugh, PhD, is an instructor and head of Political Science in the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences at Red Deer College.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

More Red Deer seniors could be dealing with homelessness, inadequate housing in future

Red Deer is short 200 affordable seniors’ housing units: Bridges study shows

Federal carbon tax is unconstitutional, says Alberta Court of Appeal

EDMONTON — The Alberta Court of Appeal has ruled that the federal… Continue reading

Red Deer man’s aggravated assault appeal says judge erred

Legal test for self defence not properly applied, says appeal

Farming organization recognizes climate crisis

National Farmers Union speaks to central Albertans

Red Deer RCMP looking for missing 15-year-old girl

Red Deer RCMP are asking for the public’s assistance to locate a… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

Kenney says investor confidence needed after Teck mine project killed

EDMONTON — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says his government is taking action… Continue reading

‘They loved life’: Family and friends give tearful tributes at Kobe Bryant at memorial

LOS ANGELES —Tears streamed down Vanessa Bryant’s face as she spoke about… Continue reading

Feds introduce bill dropping some restrictions on assisted dying

OTTAWA — The Trudeau government has introduced legislation aimed at making it… Continue reading

StatCan says 3.2 million living in poverty, including 566,000 children

OTTAWA — Canada’s poverty rate has fallen to a historic low in… Continue reading

Teck withdraws application for Frontier mine, citing discourse over climate change

VANCOUVER — Teck Resources Ltd. has withdrawn its application for a massive… Continue reading

Alberta Appeal Court sides with Alberta on federal carbon tax

EDMONTON — The Alberta Court of Appeal gave opponents of the federal… Continue reading

Raptors Uprising GC offer second chance to gamer suspended for 2019 season

TORONTO — Raptors Uprising GC, the gaming arm of the Raptors, has… Continue reading

Most Read