Surprised by the deficit? You shouldn’t be

Shocking, isn’t it? The Alberta government — the richest government in all the land — is running a deficit.

Shocking, isn’t it? The Alberta government — the richest government in all the land — is running a deficit.

No, not really. Anyone who has looked through the Alberta government’s books for any period of time could see this one coming.

In fact, in 2007, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) authored a report entitled Trouble on the Horizon, warning “if this government continues to act as recklessly as they have over the past decade, they will begin to run deficit budgets as quickly as Budget 2009 and as late as Budget 2012.”

The “recklessness” came in two ways: the over-reliance on the high price of oil and gas to prop up revenues, and the insanely large hikes in spending.

To be fair, few knew there would be such a significant drop in the price of oil and natural gas.

Nevertheless, the CTF report warned: “One lesson to be learned from (Don Getty’s experience in 1986) is not to believe non-renewable resource revenues will continue to stay high, just because they have been high for the past few years. The Alberta government has no control over the price of oil or natural gas; both are set on a world market. They can fall just as easily as they climbed.”

The deficit warning issued by the CTF in 2007 wasn’t based on a doomsday scenario where oil and gas prices would plummet. Those warnings were based on oil and gas royalty revenues staying fairly constant.

In fact, the government’s own assumptions published a year ago put oil and gas prices at $74 a barrel and $6.40 a GJ respectively for 2009-10.

Yet, even if oil prices average $74 a barrel and natural gas prices average $6.40 a GJ during the 2009-10 fiscal year, the government will still run a $1-billion deficit. Why? Because despite running the largest deficit in this province’s history, they still managed to increase operating spending by $1.1-billion in this budget.

In 2009-10, Alberta will spend $9,957 per Albertan, second only to Newfoundland and Labrador, but still $1,300 more than the government of British Columbia.

This government does not have a revenue problem, it has a spending problem.

Had the government limited the increase in its annual program spending to the combined inflation and population growth rate starting in 2005 once the debt had been retired, this year the government would be running a $2.9-billion surplus, rather than a $4.7-billion deficit.

Apparently you can’t increase spending by 13 per cent a year (Alberta’s five-year average increase) forever. Who knew? Oh right. . . .

What’s next? The government claims it will try to find $2-billion to narrow next year’s gap. While many assume this means spending cuts, the government hasn’t yet, however, ruled out tax hikes as a way to create an additional $2 billion.

But why not make the cuts today, in Budget 2009? Clearly this government figures the longer they wait, the more likely oil and gas prices will rebound, the recession will end and they can resume spending like frat boys on a Friday night.

If prices don’t rebound and the recession continues, Albertans had better start bracing for tax hikes. Better not say you weren’t warned.

Scott Hennig is Alberta director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.

Just Posted

Lacombe calls on residents to participate in census

Municipal census runs April 2 to June 20

Rocky Mountain House man charged after drug bust

March 9 drug bust in Rocky Mountain House turned up methamphetamine and cocaine

Hunting Hills High School repairs top priority for Red Deer Public Schools

Repairs on Red Deer Public Schools’ list of priorities

WATCH: Celebrating francophone Canadians at the 10th annual Red Deer Winter Carnival

The event was hosted by the Red Deer region of the French-Canadian Association of Alberta Saturday

Chelsea Carey rink registers two wins at world women’s curling event

SILKEBORG, Denmark — Canada’s Chelsea Carey rebounded nicely Sunday at the world… Continue reading

Canadian Bianca Andreescu has her first WTA title, winning BNP Paribas Open

INDIAN WELLS, Calif. — Canadian Bianca Andreescu has her first WTA title.… Continue reading

‘Captain Marvel’ soars even higher with stellar 2nd weekend

LOS ANGELES — “Captain Marvel” has continued to dominate the global box… Continue reading

Budget to focus on affordable housing changes on supply, demand, regulation

OTTAWA — The Trudeau government will take steps in Tuesday’s federal budget… Continue reading

Kenney lieutenant denies running ‘puppet’ candidate in party leadership race

EDMONTON — The staffer at the centre of a spreading scandal over… Continue reading

RCMP find ammunition, machete after searching for ATV reported stolen

FROG LAKE, Alta. — Police say they found 600 rounds of ammunition… Continue reading

US-backed forces admit to ‘difficulties’ beating IS in Syria

BAGHOUZ, Syria — U.S.-backed forces fighting to recapture the last Islamic State… Continue reading

Most Read