The door to free speech

Stephen Boissoin’s views on homosexuality are ignorant and offensive, but they should never have been censored, nor brought before the Alberta Human Rights Commission.

Stephen Boissoin’s views on homosexuality are ignorant and offensive, but they should never have been censored, nor brought before the Alberta Human Rights Commission.

Darren Lund’s views on Boissoin and his views on the Red Deer Advocate’s decision to run a letter on gays by Boissoin in 2002 have been counterproductive, wasteful and spurious. They effectively put a chill on the aggressive debate of certain ideas in Alberta.

The commission should never have entertained, let alone heard or ruled on, Lund’s complaint about the letter, which carried the headline Homosexual agenda wicked. Lund sought to stifle open debate about homosexuality and the role of schools and others in espousing and supporting gay rights and alternate lifestyles.

His complaint to the Albertan Human Rights Commission about Boissoin’s letter, and the Advocate, subsequently launched a vigorous debate about the validity of the commission and the sanctity of free speech in this province (for that, at least, we should be thankful).

In the end, the commission ruled that Boissoin’s letter defied the legislation by discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation and may have played a role in the Red Deer beating of a teenager. It ordered Boissoin to pay two people — $5,000 to Lund and $2,000 to a witness — who were not direct subjects nor victims of his letter. It also ordered the Advocate to publish a letter of apology by Boissoin. Boissoin would not write such a letter.

It was an intrusive ruling that left the malingering impression that newspapers should not be left to their own time-tested judgments about how to run their own businesses.

It was also a ruling without the due process of a court of law, without the vigorous rules of evidence and investigation.

And it has taken seven and a half years for the debate over Boissoin’s letter to the editor to reach a conclusion — providing that Lund, a former Red Deer school teacher who is now a University of Calgary professor, chooses not to appeal Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Earl Wilson’s decision last week to overturn the 2007 human rights commission ruling.

In 2007, a commission panel agreed with Lund’s complaint, which was based on Section 3 of Alberta’s human rights legislation. Yet the panel’s examination of evidence was hardly thorough, in part because the legislation does not demand the thoroughness of a court of law. The process is a quasi-judicial mishmash that costs all participants dearly, and drains public resources that could be better spent on such initiatives as education about tolerance and inclusion.

Conducting a tribunal is not the way to expose insidious ideas. To examine such ideas, and to determine what bit of truth may rest within even the most contemptible of those ideas, we need open public discourse. We must be willing and able to challenge even the most central of ideas, so that they may continue to evolve and, ultimately, inspire.

To do otherwise, either by official dictum or choice, is to create a conspiracy of silence, and that breeds stagnation and, ultimately, revolt.

Hateful ideas should not go unchallenged in the court of public discourse and in the courts of the land if those ideas are judged to break our criminal laws.

By setting aside the human rights commission’s decision, the Court of Queen’s Bench has helped to ensure that fair, open examination of ideas will continue.

Now the provincial government must follow suit and remove those parts of the human rights legislation that allow such specious claims.

John Stewart is the Advocate’s managing editor.

Just Posted

Chemical analysis may provide clues to cause of huge Red Deer industrial fire

Fire on April 17 caused $9 million in damage to oil and gas industrial building

New loonie reason to celebrate and educate: central Alberta LGBTQ community

The new LGBTQ2 loonie is a conversation starter and a reason to… Continue reading

C & E Trail property owner wants to use land as RV storage yard

Red Deer city council gives initial approval

Indigenous cultural centre needed in Red Deer

Urban Aboriginal Voices Society hosts annual community gathering

Red Deer youth recognized for his compassion

Blackfalds man dies after vehicle collision

MISSING: Joshua Arthur Sanford

37-year-old Ponoka man last seen on Tuesday morning

Inspired by a galaxy far, far away, these ‘Star Wars’ mementos could be yours forever

CHICAGO —The stuff of “Star Wars” —and there is unfortunately no better… Continue reading

Shoppers Drug Mart launches second online medical pot portal in Alberta

TORONTO — Medical cannabis users in Alberta can now get their therapeutic… Continue reading

Oh, yes! Nurse, Raptors look to finish series with Magic

DENVER — In response to an early call, Toronto coach Nick Nurse… Continue reading

Delay of game calls, goalie interference top worst rules for NHLers: survey

The pace and excitement of 3-on-3 overtime isn’t just a thrill for… Continue reading

Avengers get epic send-off at ‘Endgame’ world premiere

LOS ANGELES — There were more than a few sniffles from the… Continue reading

Writers’ Trust launches program pairing rising writers with established mentors

TORONTO — The Writers’ Trust has launched a program that gives five… Continue reading

Family: A potpourri of Easter egg hunts, music and politics

The election is a thing of the past. Albertans have spoken. They… Continue reading

Most Read