The right to control thought

If human rights commissions have a place, it should be as public witnesses to social conduct gone awry. By examining the conduct, and the ideas behind that conduct, a human rights body can lay the issues bare for society to evaluate.

If human rights commissions have a place, it should be as public witnesses to social conduct gone awry. By examining the conduct, and the ideas behind that conduct, a human rights body can lay the issues bare for society to evaluate.

But by creating laws that must be arbitrated by a human rights commission, a government further entrenches the growing — and insidious — notion that rights commissions are another extension of the judiciary.

And by pushing human rights legislation into the realm of free speech, including in schools, government shows itself intent on controlling expressions of thought. Such a government also leaves itself open to influence by special interest groups.

Alberta’s human rights legislation — first passed in 1971 and revised in 1996 — prohibits discrimination in three areas: employment, public services and housing. It allows the commission to examine complaints based on, among other things, race, income, age and religion.

And Culture Minister Lindsay Blackett has introduced legislation (Bill 44) to include sexual orientation as cause for a rights complaint.

If it was as simple as that, and the examination of complaints was as prompt and transparent as possible, the Alberta Human Rights Commission could represent a useful tool in the evolution of social behaviour.

But free speech has become the purview of the Alberta commission — the Red Deer Advocate was embroiled in one such case, by publishing a letter to the editor. Far better that such complaints are dealt with through existing hate law. The court system has the clarity and the rigour to hear these issues in a far more efficient manner, and the power to deal with them upon judgment.

And now Blackett’s Bill 44, the Human Rights, Citizenship and Multiculturalism Amendment Act, proposes that the rights commission be allowed to examine how, and what, Alberta students are taught.

The amendment would give parents the right to take complaints to the commission about classroom material — or discussion — they find offensive or objectionable. The reforms would allow parents to remove children from a class that explicitly examines “human sexuality, religion and sexual orientation.”

The amendment is flawed on several fronts:

• Public school is intended to provide a broad-based education for a broad-based student body. Censoring content, either by removing students in the face of content or by stifling that content, flies in the face of true education.

It would be far better if the parents concerned, for example, about material on evolution place their children in private Christian schools (where public funding is available).

• Discussion is a natural part of quality education; students need to raise and consider ideas from all directions. Tailoring classroom discussion to avoid potentially contentious topics is both restrictive and insulting to teachers and students questing for knowledge.

• If sexual orientation is to become cause for a human rights complaint under the amendment, and parents are allowed to remove their children from classroom discussions about sexual orientation, are they flying in the face of the legislation? What if their children are gay?

Human rights protection should be fundamental. So too should be the right to examine ideas in their fullness. A society can’t progress and blossom without faithfulness to both ideals.

Human rights legislation shouldn’t restrict either ideal.

John Stewart is the Advocate’s managing editor.

Just Posted

Scares and chills await at haunted house in Red Deer

Zed Haunted House helps raise money for Boys and Girls Club of Red Deer District

PHOTO: Renewable Energy Fair at Red Deer College

The Renewable Energy Fair and Workshops event was held at Red Deer… Continue reading

PHOTOS: Red Deer College Queens host third annual Pink in the Rink game

Queens raised $12,035 for the Central Alberta Cancer Centre.

PHOTOS: The Mustard Seed CEO speaks at Seeds of Hope Gala in Red Deer

The first-ever Seeds of Hope Gala was held at the Red Deer… Continue reading

Person airlifted to hospital after collision near Innisfail

One person was airlifted to hospital after a serious collision west of… Continue reading

WATCH: Make-A-Wish grants Star Wars loving teen’s wish

The Make-A-Wish Foundation granted Anakin Suerink’s wish in Red Deer Saturday afternoon

Turkey to reveal details of probe into Khashoggi’s killing

ISTANBUL — In a sign of growing pressure on Saudi Arabia, Turkey… Continue reading

Utah truck driver is jailed without bond after crash kills 6

HEBER, Utah — A man suspected of driving under the influence remained… Continue reading

A ragged, growing army of migrants resumes march toward US

TAPACHULA, Mexico — A ragged army of Honduran migrants streamed through southern… Continue reading

Postal workers to begin strikes in 4 Canadian cities Monday if deal not reached

OTTAWA — The union representing 50,000 Canada Post employees says it will… Continue reading

Migrant caravan swells to 5,000, resumes advance toward US

CIUDAD HIDALGO, Mexico — Despite Mexican efforts to stop them at the… Continue reading

“I don’t feel real”: Mental stress mounting after Michael

PANAMA CITY, Fla. — Amy Cross has a hard time explaining the… Continue reading

Toronto residents set to vote Monday on the next four years of civic leaders

Toronto’s municipal election campaign, marked by unprecedented provincial interference, ends Monday when… Continue reading

Former PQ minister Lise Payette remembered as role model for female politicians

MONTREAL — Members from across Quebec’s political spectrum gathered at a downtown… Continue reading

Most Read