Walkout threat proves Ford’s inexperience

The last first ministers conference of Justin Trudeau’s current term in office was the most acrimonious.

The imminence of a federal and an Alberta election certainly contributed to the tensions. But those tensions will outlast next year’s federal and provincial votes.

Not all the lines that divided the premiers on Friday are drawn in the relatively shallow ground of electoral sand.

Whoever is prime minister a year from now will find the same irreconcilable provincial differences on carbon pricing and pipelines.

Some of those differences find Ontario’s Doug Ford and Quebec’s Francois Legault on different sides.

The two Central Canada premiers made simultaneous maiden appearances on the first ministers’ stage on Friday in Montreal.

Here are some early observations as to how they fit in the current federal-provincial dynamics and what their presence at the table may bode for a tumultuous future.

Among the participants at the gathering, Ford brought the least experience in provincial politics and it showed.

By threatening to walk out over agenda differences with the prime minister, he may have hoped to lead a larger boycott of the event.

But he found little support for a walkout among colleagues.

Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister — a fellow Tory — spoke for the others when he said on his way in that he had not come all the way to Montreal to bail out at the first opportunity.

It is not that premiers have not walked out or boycotted first ministers’ conferences in the past. But it was almost always to underline a grievance that had their province up in arms.

After the Meech Lake accord failed in 1990, Quebec stayed away from federal-provincial meetings, including first ministers conferences for the better part of two years.

In 2004, Newfoundland and Labrador premier Danny Williams left the table then presided over by Paul Martin over a quarrel about the equalization formula.

By comparison, Ford lacked a substantial motive — beyond partisan petulance — to justify his threat.

There is a reason why most premiers have not over the years found the walkout option to be attractive and why no Ontario government leader had threatened a boycott in the past.

Day in and day out, the prime minister, by the sheer virtue of his position, commands the national stage. By comparison, it is not often that a premier gets the opportunity to take on the federal government in front of a pan-Canadian audience.

Former Newfoundland and Labrador premier Clyde Wells, who emerged as a key player in the mobilization of public opinion against the Meech Lake constitutional accord in the late eighties, certainly made the most of the national exposure those conferences afforded him.

As she looks to her upcoming re-election campaign, Alberta Premier Rachel Notley is similarly putting her time in the spotlight to maximum use these days.

At these gatherings, Ontario is in a league of its own in terms of the influence it yields on national affairs.

On that basis, Ford’s predecessors rightly felt that it was immensely more productive to throw their weight around at the table than to throw a tantrum for the cameras outside the room. But then they did not amalgamate their role as leader of Canada’s most-populous province with that of federal leader of the opposition.

As he looks to the next three years of his current term in office, Ford may want to ponder the risks of trading Ontario’s historical role as a major provincial anchor and the leadership that used to attend it for that of loose cannon.

There is, after all, a possibility that Trudeau will be around for as long or longer than the time he heads the Ontario government.

Chantal Hebert is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

ATA president ‘demands’ to meet with education minister to discuss re-entry plan

The president of the Alberta Teachers’ Association is “demanding” to meet with… Continue reading

‘School plan is not sufficient for children with diverse needs’: Rally to be held in Red Deer Tuesday

People who are concerned about the province’s return-to-school plan will rally in… Continue reading

‘So sorry,’ says driver guilty of gas-and-dash death

Mitchell Robert Sydlowski was charged with second-degree murder, but the 29-year old pleaded guilty to the lesser offence

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

Raffle will enhance lives of region’s women and girls

The Red Deer and District Community Foundation is hoping central Alberta can… Continue reading

‘Why not us?’: Asylum seekers on COVID-19 front lines demand permanent residency

MONTREAL — Doll Jean Frejus Nguessan Bi says he couldn’t sleep at… Continue reading

More people ill from Salmonella, ate onions from U.S.: Public Health Agency

The Public Health Agency of Canada says 100 more people have become… Continue reading

Ventilator supply starts to increase as Tam warns of possible surge of COVID-19

OTTAWA — Only a small fraction of the 40,000 new ventilators Canada… Continue reading

‘Don’t let this happen to anyone else’: families seek change to border rules

OTTAWA — “Please don’t let this happen to anyone else.” That’s what… Continue reading

New Zealand’s wizard says time spent in Canada in 1952 was ‘a great lesson’

Long before he became The Wizard of New Zealand, Ian Brackenbury Channell… Continue reading

No winning ticket for Friday night’s $20 million Lotto Max jackpot

TORONTO — No winning ticket was sold for the $20 million jackpot… Continue reading

Most Read