We don’t need race-based schools

Believe it or not, a City of Winnipeg committee is proposing the creation of a separate school division exclusively for native children.

Believe it or not, a City of Winnipeg committee is proposing the creation of a separate school division exclusively for native children.

The idea is part of an attempt to combat the city’s growing violent crime problem (a number of aboriginal gangs are active in the Manitoba capital).

The strategy proposes the creation of a separate, publicly funded First Nations school division, not unlike the one created 16 years ago for French-speaking Manitobans.

“Why should aboriginal people be denied the same thing?” asked Damon Johnston, president of the Aboriginal Council of Winnipeg. “It can only rest in racism.”

Isn’t it odd that critics of a proposal to ghettoize First Nations students, separate from other races, would be called racists?

If we’ve learned anything from our American neighbours, it should be that “separate but equal” is a concept that doesn’t work.

Just as the United States eventually realized it was a mistake to put all the white kids from a community in one school, and all the black kids in another, this Winnipeg-based scheme will hopefully eventually be recognized as utter folly.

Has Winnipeg not learned anything from Canada’s residential school scandal?

It wasn’t very long ago that Prime Minister Stephen Harper apologized for that debacle, which damaged countless aboriginals and cost taxpayers a fortune in payments to former students.

If we are ever to have a harmonious society, then surely the best way to foster that is to bring children of all races and creeds together in schools.

Canadian students should not be separated on the basis of race, as they were for years under South Africa’s apartheid system.

Admittedly, in most parts of Canada, students are already divided into public and Catholic school divisions.

Children probably never should have been divided by religion, but that is a historical fact for which there now appears to be no practical remedy.

Since we already have two school systems in most of the country, let’s not make the situation worse by adding others.

If we do decide to go down this road as a society, then maybe we’ll eventually have separate schools for whites, Orientals, blacks, etc.

Think that couldn’t happen?

Remember, just two years ago, Toronto’s public school board decided to create an Afrocentric school: a school for black kids.

Manitoba’s Aboriginal and Northern Affairs Minister Eric Robinson says he has already experienced a segregated school system: residential schools.

As for Winnipeg’s crime, Ron Evans, Grand Chief of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, blames the residential school program, among other factors.

So are segregated schools the problem or the solution?

Clearly, they are not the solution.

Fortunately, even if the proposed race-based school division is approved by the City of Winnipeg, it can’t get off the ground without the endorsement of provincial and federal governments.

And after the residential school fiasco of the past, they likely won’t support something so ridiculous.

Remember, fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

Lee Giles is an Advocate editor.

Just Posted

Councillors want to represent Red Deer at AUMA

City council approves endorsement

Cannabis smoke raises health concerns

Smoke Free Bylaw returns to Red Deer city council Sept. 4

Avid Penhold climber Catlin Hannah’s death a reminder of the dangers of scrambling

Hannah never returned from his Mount Smuts attempt on Aug. 12.

Children, elderly at risk as smoke from distant fires hangs over parts of B.C.

VANCOUVER — Thick smoke blanketing British Columbia communities far from any flames… Continue reading

WATCH: Medicine River Wildlife Centre opens new playground

The grand opening of the playground was Saturday morning

Police chiefs want new data-sharing treaty with U.S. as privacy questions linger

OTTAWA — Canada’s police chiefs are pressing the Trudeau government to sign… Continue reading

Pope on sex abuse: “We showed no care for the little ones”

VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis issued a letter to Catholics around the… Continue reading

Ottawa announces $189M to extend employment insurance for seasonal workers

ESCUMINAC, N.B. — Ottawa has announced $189 million for an employment insurance… Continue reading

Trudeau formally announces he’ll run again in next year’s election

MONTREAL — Justin Trudeau will run again in the 2019 federal election.… Continue reading

Smoke from B.C. wildfires prompts air quality advisories across Western Canada

VANCOUVER — More smoky, hazy air is expected to blanket much of… Continue reading

Anti-pipeline protesters released days before weeklong jail sentences end

MAPLE RIDGE, B.C. — Several pipeline protesters were released from a British… Continue reading

All eyes on Andrew Scheer as Conservative convention set for Halifax

OTTAWA — After a week of internal caucus squabbles, Conservative Leader Andrew… Continue reading

Trump says his White House counsel not a ‘RAT’ like Nixon’s

BRIDGEWATER, N.J. — President Donald Trump insisted Sunday that his White House… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month