Wells: What if MPs want a free voice, like Senators?

Wells: What if MPs want a free voice, like Senators?

The latest nine seem a worthy bunch

Justin Trudeau named nine new senators on Thursday. It’s said he’ll name 12 more within days. Live in Ontario or Quebec? Check the mail. You may already be a winner!

This is especially likely if you’re one of 2,700 people who applied for a seat in Parliament’s plush red upper chamber.

This is the first time applications have been accepted. Well, the first time there’s been a formal process. It’s not as though Canadians in decades past were strictly forbidden from asking for a seat in the great beyond. It’s just that their method used to be looser and more improvised, often over an umpteenth round of libations at the National Press Club or in a corner booth at Hy’s.

The latest nine seem a worthy bunch. Party bagmen and famous broadcasters are conspicuously under-represented among their number.

One new senator, Winnipeg psychiatrist Harvey Chochinov, is particularly hard to square with the notion that a Liberal-designed process will pick conspicuously Liberal senators. His previous government appointment, to a panel examining options for physician-assisted dying, came from Stephen Harper’s Conservative government. Chochinov had argued earlier that the legislated ban on assisted suicide should remain in place.

The background of these senators is less important than their number, because they bring the Senate closer to the day when senators with no formal allegiance to a party will form a plurality in the red chamber. Already this non-aligned faction is feeling its oats.

Senator André Pratte, who was a newspaper editorialist before Trudeau appointed him a few months ago, welcomed the newcomers by sending out a news release to complain that the non-aligned bloc has only half as many seats on Senate committees as its numbers would indicate. Time to change the rules, Pratte said.

Indeed there will be many changes to the rules. Divorced from allegiance to party whips, the newly frisky Senate could cause all sorts of trouble, indefinitely stalling legislation by sending bills back to the Commons heavily amended. The Commons can, of course, ignore the amendments and send back the version MPs passed first. But what if the Senate sends the bill back down, amended again?

Now, up to a point, this is precisely what Trudeau had in mind when he booted Senate Liberals from the party’s national caucus nearly three years ago, and again when he campaigned on a promise to appoint new senators at arm’s length. Let ‘em judge bills by their own lights, he said. Caucus discipline isn’t the world’s only virtue.

But even some of the new senators think there should be reasonable limits on their exercise of their independence.

They came up with a decent compromise in June when they considered the Trudeau government’s assisted-dying legislation. Many senators thought the bill, as sent up from the Commons, restricted access to assisted dying too narrowly. They sent it down with amendments.

But when the Commons passed the bill again without the amendments, Senator Peter Harder, the Trudeau appointee who acts as the government’s representative in the Senate, called on his colleagues to approve it this time, to “accept the message passed by the House of Commons.” And enough of them did that the bill passed that way.

Let’s be clear here: here was a triumph of the party line, handed down by Prime Minister’s Office and obeyed in these days by nearly 100 per cent of MPs nearly 100 per cent of the time, over the right of senators to think independently.

And that’s the way it should be. Prime ministers and their caucuses are elected and can be unelected. Even when they’re annoying they should win these confrontations.

The Senate would do well to codify the rule it improvised for the assisted-dying bill: Senators can send a bill back with amendments once, but not twice, or at least not forever. MPs may even choose to accept the odd Senate amendment, but it must be their choice.

But if that becomes the rule, strange things may start happening.

An upper chamber where members could be thoughtful, entrepreneurial, free from groupthink but responsible in their exercise of modest power, would present a tempting contrast to the whipped and disciplined life most MPs live during office hours in Ottawa.

Surely the Senate can’t have all the fun forever before MPs start to want some of what their colleagues down the hall enjoy.

The Senate’s new-found independence may turn out to be contagious.

Paul Wells is a national affairs writer.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Premier Jason Kenney announced $200 million more money that will benefit seniors living in continuing care on Wednesday. (photography by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta premier skeptical about federal government vaccine predictions

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau suggests all Canadians could be vaccinated by fall

The number of positive cases of COVID-19 has been climbing up since Jan. 20 at Red Deer's Olymel meat processing plant. (File photo by Advocate Staff)
Some Olymel workers return for training, plant reopening date not set

Union calls for delay of opening as workers fear for safety

Artist Lorne Runham's COVID Bubbles abstract work (shown here as a detail) can be viewed in an online art show on the Red Deer Arts Council's website until April 18. (Contributed image).
Art created in Red Deer in the time of COVID can be viewed in new online show

The show by members of the Red Deer Arts Council runs until April 18

Activists against open-pit coal mining in the Rocky Mountains hung a protest banner outside Alberta Environment Minister Jason Nixon’s Rocky Mountain House constituency office. Exploratory coal leases in the Nordegg area were recently granted by Nixon’s UCP government, and many local residents say they feel betrayed, as they had been promised eco-tourism opportunities by Clearwater County. (Contributed photo).
Anti-coal mining activists post banner on Environment Minister’s Rocky constituency office

Activists call for clean water protection, ban on strip mining

Justice Anne Molloy, from top left, John Rinaldi, Dr. Scott Woodside and accused Alek Minassian are shown during a murder trial conducted via Zoom videoconference in this courtroom sketch on December 11, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Alexandra Newbould
Verdict expected today in Toronto van attack trial

Alek Minassian admitted to planning and carrying out the attack on April 23, 2018

UCP MLA for Lacombe-Ponoka Ron Orr. (File photo)
MLA Ron Orr: Benchmarks were achieved but goalposts were moved

Orr responds to concerns, calls on province to fully open Step 2

The call is out in Rimbey to sign on with a group that is all about building connections

‘Already, we are building a network where we can rely on each other and help each other out’

Commissioner Roger Goodell talks about the Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year award during the NFL Honors ceremony as part of Super Bowl 55 Friday, Feb. 5, 2021, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel)
Annual NFL women’s forum enhancing career opportunities

When Sam Rapoport envisioned conducting virtually the NFL’s fifth annual Women’s Career… Continue reading

Seiko Hashimoto, president of the Tokyo 2020 Organizing Committee of the Olympic and Paralympic Games (Tokyo 2020), speaks during a news conference with Toshiro Muto, left, CEO of Tokyo 2020, after a council meeting in Tokyo on Wednesday, March 3, 2021. (Kimimasa Mayama/Pool Photo via AP)
Fans from abroad unlikely for postponed Tokyo Olympics

Olympics scheduled to open on July 23

FILE - Singer Jhene Aiko poses for a portrait on Dec. 7, 2020, in Los Angeles. Aiko will host the 63rd GRAMMY Awards on March 14. (Photo by Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP)
Jhene Aiko to host Grammy Award premiere ceremony

63rd annual Grammy ceremony set for March 14

Minister of Canadian Heritage Steven Guilbeault holds a press conference in Ottawa on November 3, 2020. The Heritage Department is committing $40 million to a “COVID-safe events fund” designed to encourage arts and cultural plans to move forward in the pandemic. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Heritage minister unveils COVID-19 events fund for arts and cultural sector

Financial support tops out at $100,000 per eligible applicant

Opinion: Crisis in long-term care must include data-driven change

More than 19,000 people in Canada have died from COVID-19 – more… Continue reading

The Dawe family home in the Michener Hill subdivision in Red Deer. This house was designed and built by Robert G. Dawe, a local engineer, in 1911 and has remained in the family ever since. (Contributed photo)
Michael Dawe: 65 years of Red Deer history

As a major milestone birthday looms, I thought that it might be… Continue reading

Most Read