What happened to competition?

When a government — any government but particularly one located in Alberta — makes a management or investment decision that doesn’t pan out, business rears up like a knight on a white charger to defend the exclusive right of private enterprise to make these decisions.

When a government — any government but particularly one located in Alberta — makes a management or investment decision that doesn’t pan out, business rears up like a knight on a white charger to defend the exclusive right of private enterprise to make these decisions.

When an Alberta municipality makes what looks like a good investment or management decision, business runs to the courts to say it’s not fair that municipalities should offer services that they could provide much more expensively.

When an industry becomes vertically integrated — owns the farms, and factories, the processors, the transportation and the stores — it’s called free enterprise and it’s all for the benefit of the consumer.

When a municipality does the same, it’s called illegal, a playing field that’s not level.

That’s what we got when the Alberta government deregulated its electricity market.

Today, all but one of the province’s power generators — Enmax, owned by the City of Calgary — are privately owned.

Far from increasing competition in the marketplace, Alberta-style deregulation has created an insiders club. Despite whining that population and consumption growth will soon be causing brownouts all over the province, no major generation plants have been proposed for more than a decade. And this with some of the highest consumer electrical costs in Canada.

The distance gap between where most of the power is generated (the northern half of the province) and where the most growth in consumption and export has come (the south), requires that an intrusive high-capacity powerline be forced through private property against landowners’ wishes, and that the consumers pay for the billion-dollar-plus project through a special levy on their power bills.

Alberta’s privately owned coal-fired power plants are a major source of pollution, but only massive tax-paid investment will clean them up.

But when municipally owned Enmax proposed to build a cleaner, state-of-the-art gas-fired plant near Calgary, thereby offering a solution to all these problems at once — and for a lower cost to the consumer — the white knights of business charged off to the courts.

The 800-megawatt Shepard Energy Centre is proposed to supply up to 10 per cent of all provincial consumption, or half the consumption of Calgary. That shows you how large that city’s presence is in the Alberta power market.

But satisfying demand near the region of highest consumption, and avoiding the need for an extremely costly transmission project, will somehow introduce “uncertainty” in the system.

What sort of “uncertainty” are we talking about here? Uncertainty that consumers will continue to be gouged by high power bills?

Several industry experts — including David Gray, former executive director of the province’s Utilities Consumer Advocate — have noted that only Enmax offers a long-term power contract that a sane consumer would consider signing.

Adding another 10 per cent to the province’s power capacity would improve certainty that sky-high peak load power rates would drop like a stone, and we wouldn’t have to worry about long-term contracts at insane rates.

Does the City of Calgary give Enmax special consideration on water rates or on business taxes?

Do oil companies that own wells, refineries, pipelines and service stations do the same for themselves — without passing the savings on to you at the pumps?

The cynicism of the private sector toward public service is one of the hallmarks of the Alberta business and political culture.

They want fairness for everyone but ordinary consumers.

It’s one of the reasons Albertans hate the very idea of power deregulation.

Greg Neiman is an Advocate editor.

Just Posted

Candlelight vigil in Red Deer honours Sri Lanka Easter bombing victims

Dozens showed up to the event at City Hall Thursday night

Several Red Deer businesses’ phone/fax lines taken over by ‘spoofers’

Same ‘prank’ calls were made as happened with RedCliff RCMP

Red Deer apartment project opposed by some neighbours

Two buildings proposed for a site in Normandeau with existing four apartment complexes

Red Deer’s osprey cam celebrities are back

FortisAlberta has webcam set up at nest created as part of avian protection program

Red Deer PCN Women’s Fun Run introduces Community Diaper Dash

Central Albertans will make a dash in diapers to bring lunches to… Continue reading

Cast your votes for the Best of Red Deer

Nominations for the Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are officially… Continue reading

Local Sports: Clayton Pottinger reaching for new heights

There are times in anyone’s life when they make a decision that… Continue reading

Seniors: Smarter living for older adults

One of the major life transitions characteristic of aging is leaving one’s… Continue reading

Opinion: Schools can’t be exempt from scrutiny

This weekend’s meeting of the Alberta School Councils’ Association promises to be… Continue reading

Bishop now the Stars goalie trying to beat Blues in playoffs

Ben Bishop grew up rooting for the St. Louis Blues before being… Continue reading

Nashville gets its chance to step up for NFL draft

NASHVILLE — Broadway in downtown Nashville is as lively a place as… Continue reading

The Cranberries, still in mourning, return for the last time

NEW YORK — Whether or not there would be a final Cranberries’… Continue reading

Dance studio owner in dispute with Burton Cummings fined for noise ticket

MOOSE JAW, Sask. — The owner of a dance fitness studio who… Continue reading

Most Read