Who’s really blocking PM in Quebec?

In a just-published book titled Open & Shut: Why America Has Barack Obama and Canada Has Stephen Harper, columnist John Ibbitson of The Globe and Mail has a suggestion for the many Canadians who, like him, dream of a day when the House of Commons will be free of the Bloc Quebecois.

In a just-published book titled Open & Shut: Why America Has Barack Obama and Canada Has Stephen Harper, columnist John Ibbitson of The Globe and Mail has a suggestion for the many Canadians who, like him, dream of a day when the House of Commons will be free of the Bloc Quebecois.

If Canada replaced the monarchy with the Constitution in the oath of allegiance MPs must swear prior to taking their seats in Parliament, he argues that future bloquistes might well fade into the night – quietly or otherwise – rather than pledge to uphold a document no Quebec government has agreed to sign.

There is at least one major hitch with his proposal and it is that it is perfectly possible to swear to uphold the Constitution while pursuing Quebec sovereignty.

Nowhere in the Constitution does it state that the Canadian federation is indivisible. On the contrary, in answer to a federal reference on Quebec secession a decade ago, the Supreme Court concluded that Quebec could constitutionally pursue secession from Canada, as long as it met certain conditions. (A key one would be the winning of a clear mandate from Quebecers to engage in negotiations.)

Quebec’s estrangement from the Constitution is also overrated.

There is not a single disposition of the current language regime of the province that is at odds with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. And among the few post-patriation amendments to the Constitution, one of the most significant – dealing with religious education – was negotiated by current PQ Leader Pauline Marois on Lucien Bouchard’s watch and adopted in the Commons with the support of the Bloc.

Ibbitson is part of a group of observers who feel the Bloc has perverted the federal system. These days, their ranks are swelling.

It may seem odd that the debate over the existence of the federal sovereignist party is resurfacing some 20 years after its advent but then, the Bloc’s full impact on the makeup of Parliament was blunted by the division of the Conservative movement for at least half of that time.

If the Progressive Conservative and Reform parties had not split the conservative vote for the duration of the Jean Chretien era, the former prime minister would almost certainly not have enjoyed a decade of majority governments.

It is no accident that Canada entered an open-ended cycle of minority rule the moment the right reunited. And the fact is that, for as long as the Bloc dominates Quebec, it will be hard to break out of that cycle.

These days, despair over the capacity of the federalist parties to beat back the Bloc has prompted a search for a shortcut to return Parliament to majority rule.

Ever since Quebec, through the Bloc, killed hopes for a Conservative majority last fall, that search has become nowhere more intense than on the right of the ideological spectrum.

But leaving aside Ibbitson’s contention that Canada could only operate effectively if it managed to disenfranchise a significant number of its citizens, it should be noted that, in their quest for a Bloc-free Parliament, conservative commentators are very much on a fool’s errand.

The sovereignist party is primarily a repository for progressive votes. It takes more votes away from the NDP and the Liberals than from the Conservatives. In its absence, the Liberals would be immensely more likely to reassert their dominance of the province than a Conservative party that has excised its progressive label.

When all is said and done, the biggest obstacle standing in the way of the Harper Conservatives and their dream of a governing majority is not the Bloc but rather Quebec itself, along with its stubborn progressive streak.

Chantal Hebert writes for The Toronto Star Syndicate.

Just Posted

Lee seeks UCP nomination in Red Deer

Eyes Red Deer-North constituency

Updated Red Deer smoke free bylaw to ban smoking cannabis in public

Smoke Free Bylaw returns to Red Deer city council Sept. 4

Red Deer city council considers new business licence bylaw

All businesses operating in the City of Red Deer will require a… Continue reading

Saskatchewan farmer’s death triggers emotional harvest of love and respect

MILESTONE, Sask. — Volunteers have rallied to harvest the large wheat crop… Continue reading

Councillors want to represent Red Deer at AUMA

City council approves endorsement

WATCH: Medicine River Wildlife Centre opens new playground

The grand opening of the playground was Saturday morning

Animal crackers break out of their cages

After more than a century behind bars, the beasts on boxes of… Continue reading

Alligator kills woman trying to protect her dog at resort

HILTON HEAD ISLAND, S.C. — A woman who often walked her dog… Continue reading

Patients redirected as water leak shuts down Edmonton hospital’s emergency room

EDMONTON — Ambulances are being redirected to other hospitals after a water… Continue reading

Parks Canada moves second bison bull that wandered out of Banff National Park

BANFF — Parks Canada says a second bison bull that wandered out… Continue reading

Lottery for parent sponsorship to be replaced, more applications to be accepted

OTTAWA — The Trudeau government is scrapping an unpopular lottery system for… Continue reading

Air Canada-led consortium signs deal to buy Aeroplan program from Aimia

TORONTO — A consortium led by Air Canada has reached a deal… Continue reading

Scheer going to India to ‘repair’ relationship after ‘disastrous’ Trudeau trip

OTTAWA — Six months after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s foreign policy prowess… Continue reading

Police chiefs want new data-sharing treaty with U.S. as privacy questions linger

OTTAWA — Canada’s police chiefs are pressing the Trudeau government to sign… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month