Why a tax on carbon won’t solve climate change

Why a tax on carbon won’t solve climate change

In Canada, the climate change debate has focused on Ottawa’s attempts to impose carbon taxes.

Proponents of these taxes, such as the federal Liberal government, say that only a price on carbon can adequately reduce the greenhouse gas emissions responsible for global warming.

Opponents counter that carbon taxes can never work.

But in a new book, Simon Fraser University economist Mark Jaccard says both sides are wrong. In theory, he says carbon pricing should work. In practice, however, it doesn’t — for the simple reason that in the real world of politics. it is too difficult to deliver.

“The carbon tax is, from an economic efficiency perspective, the perfect policy,” he writes, “which is why a lot of people, especially economists, keep saying we must price carbon emissions.

“But this statement is factually incorrect. In the real world of politics and policy, the selection of (emission-reducing) policies involves a trade-off between cost-effectiveness and the likelihood of implementation. Single-mindedly pursue carbon pricing and we could end up with nothing.”

The reason, Jaccard says, is that both sides of the climate debate are caught up in myths. The myths of those who deny climate change are well-known — that global warming is unrelated to human behaviour, that scientists who warn of the dangers posed by such warming are part of a vast conspiracy of radical environmentalists.

But those who believe, like Jaccard, that climate change does pose a global risk, often have their own myths as well.

One is that energy efficiency is profitable — that the cost of energy-efficient appliances and buildings will be more than compensated for by, say, reduced hydro bills.

Unfortunately, Jaccard says, the evidence shows this is rarely true.

Another myth, he writes, is that individuals can continue to indulge in energy intensive behaviour without harming the world, as long as they buy enough so-called offsets to reach a state of carbon neutrality. Once again, he says, the evidence shows that many of these offsets do nothing to reduce carbon emissions.

A third myth is the belief that renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind power, are already cheaper than fossil fuels. They are not, he writes, which is why developing countries remain so determined to use carbon-rich fuels like coal.

The problem with these kinds of myths, he writes, is that they foster the view that market forces alone can solve the climate change crisis. They thus let politicians off the hook.

But it is Jaccard’s account of the 2009 British Columbia election campaign that is most telling. That was the election fought just after Liberal Premier Gordon Campbell had brought in a revenue-neutral carbon tax.

To economist Jaccard, the tax was a no-brainer: it would discourage carbon-intensive behaviour without reducing economic growth. But to his surprise, Campbell’s political opponents — led by the provincial New Democrats — managed to convince many voters that this was nothing but a tax grab.

The anti-carbon tax campaign, Jaccard writes, was characterized by blatant lies and mistruths. But people bought it anyway.

In the end, he argues, Campbell was saved only by the global recession. Thinking that Campbell could handle the economic crisis better than his NDP opponents, British Columbians overcame their distaste for the carbon tax and voted him back into office.

For Jaccard, the 2009 B.C. election campaign served as a brutal reminder of the political difficulty in selling any kind of carbon tax, no matter how virtuous, to voters. He argues that regulation of emissions, while ultimately more costly than carbon pricing, would be politically more successful.

Given that some economists calculate that the federal carbon tax would have to rise from $20 a tonne now to $210 a tonne by 2030 in order for Canada to meet its emission reduction targets — a hike that would result in gasoline prices increasing by 40 cents a litre — Jaccard may be right.

Thomas Walkom is a columnist for Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

City of Red Deer says its roundabouts have sharply reduced the number of injury collisions at a pair of busy intersections. Alberta Transportation wants to incorporate five roundabouts into plans to twin Highway 11 from Sylvan Lake to Rocky Mountain House. Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
Highway 11 roundabouts will increase safety based on Red Deer’s experience

Injury collisions sharply reduced at roundabout intersections in city

As of Friday, Alberta has under 10,000 active COVID-19 cases. (Image courtesy CDC)
One new COVID-19 death in Red Deer, Alberta under 10,000 active cases

Alberta reported an additional 643 COVID-19 cases Friday. The province now has… Continue reading

About 110 students from Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools participated in March for Life rally in Edmonton May 9. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Red Deer high school has COVID-19 case

St. Joseph High School in Red Deer confirmed a positive COVID-19 case… Continue reading

Lacombe High School logo.
Two more COVID-19 cases at Lacombe Composite High School

Lacombe Composite High School confirmed two more positive COVID-19 cases at the… Continue reading

World Juniors’ referee Mike Langin makes a called during the Canada vs. Slovakia at the 2021 World Junior Championship at Rogers Place in Edmonton, Dec. 27, 2020. (Photo by Matthew Murnaghan/Hockey Canada)
Former Sylvan Lake man lives his dream at World Junior Championships

Mike Langin was one the 25 Canadian officials who worked during the tournament

Former Alberta Premier Rachel Notley shakes hands with Joel Ward, former Red Deer College President and CEO, as Notley announces that the college is on the path to grant degrees. Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan says university status is not a necessary condition for offering degrees. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Future of Red Deer University increasingly uncertain

MLA’s college update says RDC more like SAIT and NAIT than a university

There are two confirmed COVID-19 cases at Red Deer College. Photo by Mamta Lulla/Advocate staff
Central Albertans were promised a university

Central Albertans were promised a university

Miami Heat guard Duncan Robinson (55) passes the ball around Toronto Raptors guard Fred VanVleet (23) during the second half of an NBA basketball game Friday, Jan. 22, 2021, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)
Powell, Raptors regroup after blowing lead, beat Heat 101-81

Powell, Raptors regroup after blowing lead, beat Heat 101-81

Tavares scores winner on power play, Leafs beat Oilers 4-2

Tavares scores winner on power play, Leafs beat Oilers 4-2

David Shoemaker, chief executive officer of the Canadian Olympic Committee, speaks during the Olympic Partnership kick off event at the Sobey's office in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, October 7, 2019. Shoemaker says the IOC remains committed to staging the Summer Games in Tokyo this summer.THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Tijana Martin
Canada’s Olympic athletes try to tune out reports six months from Games

Canada’s Olympic athletes try to tune out reports six months from Games

Toronto FC captain Michael Bradley lifts the Voyageurs Cup after beating Vancouver Whitecaps 5-2 to win the Canadian Championship Final in Toronto on Wednesday, August 15, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
Forge FC-Toronto FC Canadian Championship final to be played before April 6

Forge FC-Toronto FC Canadian Championship final to be played before April 6

Canada's Penny Oleksiak reacts after her heat of the women's 50m butterfly at the World Swimming Championships in Gwangju, South Korea, Friday, July 26, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Lee Jin-man
Penny Oleksiak, Kylie Masse among six swimmers named early to Canadian Olympic team

Penny Oleksiak, Kylie Masse among six swimmers named early to Canadian Olympic team

Ontario skip Glenn Howard watches a rock as they play Newfoundland and Labrador in draw 15 action at the Tim Hortons Brier curling championship at Mile One Centre in St. John's on Thursday, March 9, 2017. Curling Canada has decided to use the national ranking system as its selection criteria for the final wild-card berths at the Scotties Tournament of Hearts and Tim Hortons Brier.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Canadian rankings to be used to determine final wild-card spots at Scotties and Brier

Canadian rankings to be used to determine final wild-card spots at Scotties and Brier

A digital Intensive care unit room at Cortellucci Vaughan Hospital in Vaughan, Ont., on Monday, Jan. 18, 2021. Hospitalizations due to COVID-19 are down slightly in Ontario and Quebec. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Justin Trudeau mulls mandatory hotel quarantine for returning travellers

Justin Trudeau mulls mandatory hotel quarantine for returning travellers

Most Read