Why Trump sides with Israel

When U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order affirming Israel’s sovereignty over the Golan Heights, there was an outcry that went far beyond the Arab world.

His action went against the international rule on the “inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by force,” we were told – conquest, in less lawyerly language. Alas, that is just an ideal, not a hard-and-fast international law.

The Golan Heights, which belonged to Syria, were part of Israel’s conquests in the 1967 war. Israel returned most of Egypt’s lost territory (except the Gaza Strip) in the 1979 peace agreement, but continues to occupy the lands it conquered from Jordan and Syria 52 years later.

The only part it has annexed, according to Israeli law, however, is the Golan Heights. As far as Israel is concerned, the issue was closed in 1981, although nobody else in the world accepted the annexation, not even its greatest ally, the United States.

They all went on referring to the “occupied territories,” including the Golan Heights, as defined in UN Security Council Resolution 242. But Israel didn’t care.

The only reason Trump has now recognized the Golan Heights as Israeli territory is to give a little electoral boost to his good buddy, Israel’s Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, who is facing corruption charges that might lose him the election April 9.

It doesn’t change the legal situation as far as everybody else is concerned, nor does it make Israel’s hold on the territory more secure.

What guarantees Israel’s position in the Golan Heights is a crushing superiority in military force, and the same is true of most other occupied territories around the world.

There is text in the United Nations Charter requiring all members to refrain “from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state,” but it’s a pious hope, not a universally enforced law.

When there is a conquest, the victim is expected to take action itself if possible, as Britain did when Argentina invaded the Falkland Islands. It will probably get some legal cover from international law, but it is unlikely to get military aid unless it is in other countries’ interests to give it.

Such interests were engaged in the 1990-91 Gulf War, when Iraq conquered Kuwait. For strategic reasons (i.e. oil), many Arab and western countries volunteered military forces to reverse that conquest – and they got legal cover from the UN too, for what it was worth.

But when it’s a great power doing the invading, like China in Tibet (1950), the Soviet Union in Afghanistan (1979), or the United States in Grenada (1983), Panama (1989) and Iraq (2003), the UN is paralyzed by Security Council vetoes and most other countries lie low. The invaders have no legal cover, but that doesn’t stop them.

When non-great powers invade, like the Indonesian seizure of Timor or the Moroccan annexation of Western Sahara, both in 1975, there will be no outside help for the victim, unless some great power cares about it – or unless the local people can wage a guerilla war long enough to make the conqueror cut its losses and go home. They succeeded in Timor; they failed in Western Sahara.

Trump’s recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights makes the simultaneous American campaign to reverse the Russian annexation of Crimea look hypocritical, but that campaign wasn’t getting any traction anyway.

Everybody in the Arab world already knows that Trump is completely loyal to Israel, if only because that is the best way to get the votes of U.S. evangelical Christians. Nobody expects anything to come from his Middle East peace plan, if it ever sees the light of day.

Gwynne Dyer’s new book is Growing Pains: The Future of Democracy (and Work).

Just Posted

Woman who makes hot lunches once a month for students in need to receive award

Hunger can make people hangry. One Red Deer mom has been busting… Continue reading

Red Deer man continues campaign to build woodland winter shelters for the homeless

Ryan Drummond says Red Deer needs more affordable housing

‘Pick a lane:’ Alberta premier fires back at Bloc Quebecois leader

CALGARY — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says Bloc Quebecois Leader Yves-Francois Blanchet… Continue reading

Opposition calls out Alberta premier’s principal adviser over travel expenses

EDMONTON — Alberta’s Opposition says one of Alberta Premier Jason Kenney’s top… Continue reading

Inmate arrested, one on the loose after escape from Saskatoon psychiatric centre

SASKATOON — Police say they have arrested one of two violent inmates… Continue reading

Petition to ‘bring back Don Cherry’ goes viral after immigrant poppy rant

Cherry was fired from his co-hosting role for the Coach’s Corner segment on Nov. 11.

Your community calendar

Wednesday Pain 101 class — learn to take control of your chronic… Continue reading

POLL: Do you agree with the decision to fire Don Cherry?

Do you agree with the decision to fire Don Cherry for his… Continue reading

MAP: Red Deer Open Houses for Nov. 16-17

Plan your open house viewings with the attached map of listings in… Continue reading

California school shooting suspect in custody

Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva tells KNX radio the suspect in… Continue reading

Opinion: Lady backpacks and manly beer — the folly of gendered goods

As women started counting steps and walking to work wearing running shoes… Continue reading

Canopy Growth reports $374.6M Q2 loss, restructures softgel and oil portfolio

SMITH FALLS, Ont. — Canopy Growth Corp. reported a $374.6-million loss in… Continue reading

Walmart’s online sales are surging heading into holidays

Walmart raised its annual profit expectations after reporting strong third-quarter results helped… Continue reading

California’s wildfire, blackout crisis: Who’s to blame?

The utility that serves more than 5 million electrical customers in one… Continue reading

Most Read