Wildrose’s well-worn path

The increasingly damaged body of Alberta politics is perilously close to becoming completely dismembered.

The increasingly damaged body of Alberta politics is perilously close to becoming completely dismembered.

Danielle Smith and the Wildrose Alliance seem intent on ensuring that happens, and equally intent on being the ones who get to put the pieces together again.

Wildrose has created a new tide of politics in Alberta: an aggressive, uncompromising and truculent approach to upending the status quo; and a confident, even brash, belief in both their ideas and their ability to create a better future.

Step one is to put the ruling Progressive Conservatives under fire at every opportunity. Wildrose doesn’t waste a great deal of time on other opponents at the centre or the left of the political spectrum.

A fulsome barrage of criticism of the Tory way is delivered by the Wildrose weekly and sometimes daily. Smith and the Wildrose are fiercely aggressive in their condemnation of the Tories. In introducing an alternate budget last week, Smith referred to “spending-addicted governments.”

This week, at a gathering that drew disaffected Tories and big-dollar businessmen in Edmonton, she declared “the PC culture is unreformable. We don’t just need a new premier, we need a new government.” The irony — that the crowd included ex-Tory cabinet ministers like Lyle Oberg and Ernie Isley, former Tory supporters and even Ralph Klein’s father Phil — should be lost on no one.

Step two is to offer up a portfolio of ideas for reform, from health care to social program deliverance to the size of government.

And Smith has plenty of ideas.

On health care, she suggests a system that puts the dollars into the hands of patients and creates a competitive delivery structure. Wildrose maintains that such a system will improve and quicken service, and cut costs. To outsiders, it sounds like privatization, driven by profit. In fact, it looks a lot like a balloon that Ralph Klein tried unsuccessfully to float while he was premier.

She talks glowingly about the Big Society movement of new United Kingdom Prime Minister David Cameron, which proposes that government download social programs to communities.

“Rather than put all our faith in central planners in a remote government bureaucracy to sort out all these problems, maybe each of us in our own communities should be looking at ways we can lend a land to help,” Smith told the Edmonton audience this week.

That’s a notion the Conservatives have been pursuing for a decade or more, as funding for social programs disappeared, along with the bureaucratic supports for those programs. The outcome — communities and non-profits under increasing duress and the finite local donation pool drying up — is neither acceptable now nor worthy of future pursuit.

Smith talks about wasteful big government and the need to streamline bureaucracy and spending. It’s a good notion, but it requires a deft touch and continued monitoring. The Klein years featured aggressive cutting of government services without a clear vision of the end game, other than to save money. That doesn’t serve Albertans, who want value for their taxes, not tax cuts (we remain the least taxed of all provinces).

She talks about setting us up for the future by curtailing spending now. But sometimes cutting spending — Wildrose proposes to cut the planned $6.6-billion budget for schools, roads and hospitals in the next year by one-third — means we are unprepared for future growth. We’ve just emerged from a period, driven by Klein’s silly notions of fiscal responsibility, that crippled our ability to handle future growth.

Do Albertans truly want Smith and Wildrose to come to our rescue, and will what they offer be a significant upgrade on the current governance offered by the Progressive Conservatives?

Probably not, based on the Klein-like vision that Smith is offering at the moment.

Certainly we need new leadership, a fresh vision and renewed vigour in government. Premier Ed Stelmach’s ruling party is tired and uninspired.

But what have we gained if a rebuilt Alberta looks eerily like the one we just left behind?

John Stewart is the Advocate’s managing editor.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Pleasant start to autumn

Above average temperature for the week

Horgan meets Lt.-Gov. amid B.C. election speculation

VICTORIA — B.C. Premier John Horgan is meeting with Lt.-Gov. Janet Austin… Continue reading

An attempted murder charge against an O’Chiese man was dropped by a Red Deer court

Quentin Stawberry pleaded guilty to two other, lesser charges

Five students at University of Alberta residence test positive for COVID-19

The university is shutting down in-person varsity athletics for the next two weeks

QUIZ: A celebration of apples

September is the start of the apple harvest

Pandemic means premiers are no longer in limelight

The ‘resistance’ isn’t exactly futile, but it isn’t Trudeau’s biggest problem any more

Reg Warkentin: Our schools deserve top marks

The education and development of our kids is the most important asset our province has

Chase Claypool sets Canadian NFL record with 84-yard touchdown reception

Longest touch down from scrimmage in league history by a Canadian-born player

Shapovalov loses to Schwartzman in Italian Open semifinals

Schwartzman will play world No. 1 Novak Djokovic

Quirky Canadian comedy ‘Schitt’s Creek’ takes Emmys by storm with comedy sweep

First time Canadian show wins Emmy for best comedy series

Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world in the coming week

The 2020 Global Business Forum in Banff, Alta., will be held as a special hybrid event

New tools, ideas needed to speed up housing strategy funding, CMHC president says

Slow turnaround time on some of its national housing strategy programs

Most Read