Could Myles Garrett face criminal charges?

There have been a lot of what some fans might consider downright criminal things on the field at FirstEnergy Stadium in recent years.

Take the perfectly awful 0-16 season, for example.

But the melee that ensued Thursday night between Browns defender Myles Garrett and Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph that ended with fists and a helmet flying might be the first to rise to the level of ending up before a judge.

No criminal charges have been filed yet over the fight at the end of the game that resulted in Garrett ripping the helmet off Rudolph’s head then hitting him in the noggin with it. A league source confirmed to the Beacon Journal on Friday night that Rudolph does not plan to file charges against Garrett.

But there are a chorus of NFL pundits who are not only calling for Garrett’s long-term suspension but also for criminal assault charges.

Former NFL player and Monday Night Football announcer Booger McFarland said Friday via Twitter that Garrett violated a “code” among the NFL fraternity.

“We compete against one another until the edge of destruction within the rules (and) afterwards we take our helmets off, shake hands (and) wish each other well,” he tweeted. “We NEVER intentionally try to hurt each other.

“He committed a crime and should be charged.”

ESPN’s national NFL writer Kevin Seifert agrees.

“Myles Garrett committed the closest thing we’ve seen to an on-field crime in the NFL’s modern era,” Seifert tweeted after the game. “It was a singularly violent act and should be punished accordingly.”

But if history dictates —at least with the NFL —Garrett will face a likely long suspension and hefty fine but no criminal charges. On Friday, the NFL suspended him indefinitely.

No NFL player has ever been charged for something that happened within the boundaries of the field.

The last ugly incident to challenge this notion came in 2006 when Tennessee Titan Albert Haynesworth became angry after a play and stomped his cleats on the face of Dallas Cowboys Andre Gurode.

Gurode required 30 stitches and says he still suffers headaches and blurred vision.

Haynesworth was given a record five-game suspension that could be eclipsed by Garrett should he be out for the remainder of the six regular games left in this season.

When the extracurricular game-related activity ventures outside of the lines, things get a bit more tricky legally.

Five NBA players —including Ron Artest, Stephen Jackson, Jermaine O’Neal, David Harrison and Anthony Johnson —were charged with assault in 2004 for their roles in the infamous “Malice at the Palace” when a scuffle ensued in the stands with Detroit fans.

Baseball player Jose Offerman was charged with assault in 2007 after seriously injuring another player by hitting him in the head with a bat during a fight in an Independent Atlantic League game.

And you don’t have to look far for another instance where a player was charged criminally for a fight inside of the lines.

Former University of Akron basketball player Khadim Gueye, who has since left the school and Akron, was charged with assault after injuring a teammate in a fight during a practice in December 2018.

Cleveland Police have not filed any charges.

Akron attorney Mike Callahan, who is a former county prosecutor, judge and now a defense attorney, said appearance aside —he sees nothing criminal in Garrett’s actions.

“Football is a violent sport,” he said. “It is what it is.”

He points out that NFL has its own rules and regulations that govern player behavior. He said Garrett’s action are best handled internally by the league since the fight was player against player inside the confines of the game and all the parties walked away relatively unscathed.

“If he is charged, I would be more than happy to represent him,” Callahan said. “People simply lose their tempers in the middle of something like that.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Central Alberta woman receives North American award for leading Red Deer Regional Health Foundation

Manon Therriault at the Red Deer Regional Health Foundation has always embraced… Continue reading

Families displaced after Red Deer fire Sunday

A structure fire displaced two families in north Red Deer Sunday morning.… Continue reading

End of CERB means uncertainty for some, new system for others

In its place is employment insurance, which the government says the majority of people will go on

The latest numbers on COVID-19 in Canada for Sept. 27

The latest numbers of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Canada as of 4:00… Continue reading

WE Charity controversy prompts examination of group’s overseas footprint

On Sept. 9, WE Charity said it would wind down its Canadian operations

QUIZ: Do you know what’s on TV?

Fall is normally the time when new television shows are released

Nearly 1M who died of COVID-19 also illuminated treatment

The nearly 1 million people around the world who have lost their… Continue reading

Toronto health officer closes 3 restaurants as result of COVID contact tracing

Toronto’s top public health official has ordered the closure of three downtown… Continue reading

Canadian ski resorts wrestle with pandemic-vs.-profit dilemma as COVID-19 persists

CALGARY — Canadian ski resort operators planning for a season that begins… Continue reading

Tenille Townes, Dean Brody and Brett Kissel top nominees at tonight’s CCMA Awards

OTTAWA — Tenille Townes could be lined up for some major wins… Continue reading

Horgan, Wilkinson trade barbs over MSP premiums, health care at campaign stops

TERRACE, B.C. — Health care in the era of COVID-19 took centre… Continue reading

Watchdog to investigate fatal Winnipeg crash that sent two kids to hospital

Winnipeg police say a woman has died and five others — including… Continue reading

The ‘relentless underdog’: Green Leader Sonia Furstenau ready for uphill battle

Green Leader Sonia Furstenau was driving Monday when she turned on the… Continue reading

Mi’kmaq power, inside and beyond Ottawa, stronger than in past fishery battles

HALIFAX — When Jaime Battiste was in his early 20s, cable news… Continue reading

Most Read