The Calgary Flames celebrate a goal in the Battle of Alberta Rookie Game at the Centrium in September of 2018. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)

Researcher trying to pin down why hockey fans in Red Deer support Oilers or Flames

In the NHL, things are trending in two very different directions between the Battle of Alberta combatants.

This year, the Calgary Flames are one of the hottest teams in the league, while the Edmonton Oilers are fighting for their playoff lives.

Over the past three decades, the Oilers and Flames have had varying degrees of NHL success.

The Oilers may have more Stanley Cup rings and also the most recent win, while the Flames were cup champs back in 1989 and in the Game 7 of the final as recently 2004 – the Oilers were in Game 7 of the big dance in 2006.

Some of their more recent history runs parallel, yet the bitter divide between the two groups of fans is evident in one place in particular.

Red Deer is one of the only cities in North America to have two professional sports teams in the same league, that happen to be almost exactly the same distance apart. From the Centrium in Red Deer to Calgary’s Saddledome is 144 kilometres, while the journey north to Edmonton’s Rogers Place is 157 kilometres.

That divide is so well known in the sports community and it has long piqued the interest of Blair Cipywnyk, an Edmonton native.

Cipywnyk, a 26-year-old graduate student at Brock University in St. Catharines, Ont., is undertaking the first study of its kind, trying to discover what drives hockey fans in Red Deer in one direction or another.

“The literature says from past studies that a big reason why people choose the team they cheer for, is they just cheer for the team that’s closer. So the big thing is how they choose the team, and how they maintain it,” said Cipywnyk.

“With (Red Deer) in the middle, they are just as close to Oilers fans, as they are to Flames fans. You are just as exposed to the rival fans, as the main fans. We’re wondering how they maintain it. Especially because both teams have similar histories.”

He hopes that his research project will help to better understand the behaviours and feelings of hockey fans.

Growing up in Edmonton, Cipywnyk was naturally an Oilers fan, but his parents also had a place at Sylvan Lake, so he understands both fan perspectives.

In his study so far, he has talked with about half the subjects needed to put together a complete picture of the fan situation in Red Deer. There are some intriguing results so far.

“The biggest surprise to me is that Flames fans don’t really care about the Oilers and Oilers fans don’t really care about the Flames,” he said.

“When the two teams play, it’s a heated rivalry. A lot of people are saying the rivalry has died out because they haven’t had a lot of success (recently). It’s almost like they don’t care about each other until they meet. Which is surprising.”

Although there are similar cases for some cities, like Hamilton, Ont. being relatively near the midpoint of Buffalo and Toronto. No place is quite like Red Deer. There are some studies in New York about how people became Rangers or Islanders fans, or in Chicago, where baseball fans support either the Cubs or White Sox – still none like his.

He also indicated that most often fans pick a team because of geography, which is why the study is so unique. He added that fans also support teams because of their parents and media exposure.

“My study is unique in that Red Deer is exactly halfway. I’ve had people come to me from Ponoka and they’ve wanted to participate,” he said.

“Unfortunately, Ponoka is closer to Edmonton and (they’re) an Oilers fan… for academic reasons, you’re close to Edmonton so it gets rid of the cool novelty. There hasn’t really been another study with the geography like this.”

For any Red Deer residents who are Oilers or Flames fans and wish to participate in the study, contact Blair Cipywnyk at

Email sports tips to Byron Hackett

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter


Edmonton Oilers fans celebrate a goal in the Battle of Alberta Rookie Game at the Centrium in September of 2018. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)

Edmonton Oilers rookie Evan Polei battles with Calgary Flames rookie Josh Healey in front of goalie Mason McDonald during the Battle of Alberta Rookie Game at the Centrium in September of 2018. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)

The Calgary Flames celebrate a goal in the Battle of Alberta Rookie Game at the Centrium in September of 2018. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)

Just Posted

Biathlon women sweep the podium for second time

Biathlon women took top four spots in Thursday’s 10-km race

Red Deer firefighter is recovering, thanks community for support

Firefighters who help together, stick together. Red Deer firefighter medic Ben Barthel… Continue reading

Petroleum producers speak to Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce

Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers brings recommendations

Science fair is around the corner

Central Alberta Rotary Science Fair happens March 29 and 30.

Ponoka host to Bayer Crop Science seed innovations trade show

The company held a trade show with seed crop science industry partners at the ag event centre

Gaudreau snaps goal drought to help Flames double up Islanders 4-2

CALGARY — The drought is over for Johnny Gaudreau. Gaudreau’s first goal… Continue reading

Federal government set to develop code of conduct for sport in Canada

OTTAWA — The federal government is developing a code of conduct for… Continue reading

Jay Baruchel has trained the dragon, now he’s letting go with ‘The Hidden World’

TORONTO — The first time actor Jay Baruchel stepped into a recording… Continue reading

Hockey ref says AC/DC support is giving him motivation in Alzheimer’s fundraiser

Enthusiastic AC/DC fan Steve McNeil says he’s feeling inspired to push even… Continue reading

Gardening: What are you planting in 2019?

What’s new in plants for 2019? Checking catalogues, greenhouses and stores will… Continue reading

Opinion: I spy another energy hypocrite

Talk about biting the hand that feeds you. The mittens provided to… Continue reading

Canada’s bobsleigh team races World Cup on Calgary home track facing closure

CALGARY — Canada’s skeleton and bobsled teams will race a World Cup… Continue reading

Most Read