Adding more meat inspectors won’t ensure safe products, but consumers can play a role

I was prompted to write this letter in response to articles published in the Red Deer Advocate on April 1 (Meat inspection shortage putting consumers at risk) and April 2 (Canadian Food Inspection Agency defends food safety).

I was prompted to write this letter in response to articles published in the Red Deer Advocate on April 1 (Meat inspection shortage putting consumers at risk) and April 2 (Canadian Food Inspection Agency defends food safety).

The first, from the agriculture union, intimated the possibility of consumer death from unsafe meat produced in uninspected meat processing facilities.

The second, a response from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), was more sensible in documenting the adequacy of current federal inspection practices. Researchers, the meat processing sector and the CFIA have collaborated to develop and evaluate meat processing protocols that utilize critical control points to insure the safety of meat products.

There is a minimum of inspection staff necessary to assure processes are in control and the addition of more inspectors would do nothing to improve the safety of meats.

I would argue that none of the incidents of meat-borne illness occurring in Canada over the last 10 years could have been prevented by increasing the number of inspectors on the processing lines in federally-inspected plants.

Despite the lack of evidence for a direct correlation between the actual number of inspectors and meat safety, when there is an outbreak of meat-associated illness the public panics and the government responds by infusing millions of dollars into recruiting additional inspectors. This, of course, is without effect and incidents of illness due to pathogens in meats continue to occur.

Irrespective of rigorous inspection procedures, by the time raw meats reach the consumer they are liberally contaminated with bacteria. Some of these bacteria are pathogenic (e.g. E. coli O157:H7) and could pose a risk to human health.

Armed with appropriate tools, knowledge and sufficient time, one could isolate pathogens from any raw meat processing facility. We know they are present but the more critical issue is their origin and fate during the meat production continuum.

Most importantly, how do those human pathogens grow to a level that produces illness when meat is consumed? This requires a basic understanding of the behaviour of bacterial pathogens in meat production systems from pasture to plate.

Further to this, one must consider the role of the consumer in the equation. Published data on origins of food-borne illness in Canada have well established that the major cause is mishandling during food service (i.e. restaurants, caterers) and in the home; usually due to improper heating and cooling, and cross contamination.

Thus, to be efficacious in preventing illness due to meat-borne bacteria, monies would be better targeted to improve training for food service employees and educating consumers.

The current practice of increasing the numbers of meat processing inspectors is not cost-effective and consumers must begin taking some responsibility.

Although one might think that consumer education is an impossible task, we can take an example from the poultry processing sector. It is well known that most chickens contain human pathogens (e.g. salmonella) and anyone with a modicum of intelligence takes appropriate measures to prevent cross contamination during food preparation and avoids eating undercooked poultry meat.

Many of these same people seem to have no problem eating raw or undercooked beef and when illness ensues, they readily blame the meat inspectorate.

G. Gordon Greer, PhD

Lacombe

Note: Greer was a research meat microbiologist at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada’s Lacombe Research Centre from 1978 until his retirement in 2006.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Non-profits that are helping people impacted by COVID-19 can apply for relief funding

Red Deer and District FCSS can draw from a provincial pot of $30 million

Bank of Canada cuts key interest rate target while Libs up wage subsidy

OTTAWA — Canada’s central bank made yet another unscheduled rate cut Friday… Continue reading

A message from the Advocate publisher

In good times and bad, The Red Deer Advocate has been here… Continue reading

No Alberta renter will be evicted for non-payment on April 1, promises the premier

No evictions during the entire Alberta public health emergency

WATCH: COVID-19 doesn’t stop Red Deer Public Library from telling stories

Deb Isbister has been reading stories to children for more than 20… Continue reading

Alberta Health Services provides COVID-19 prevention tips

Alberta Health Services has a number of recommendations for people amid the… Continue reading

Alberta government website has latest COVID-19 statistics

Red Deer Advocate readers can stay up to date on the COVID-19… Continue reading

A message from Central Alberta Co-op

The COVID-19 pandemic is a global challenge that’s having a real impact… Continue reading

4 passengers dead aboard cruise ship anchored off Panama

4 passengers dead aboard cruise ship anchored off Panama

Drumheller Institution in Alberta locked down, two inmates tested for COVID-19

Drumheller Institution in Alberta locked down, two inmates tested for COVID-19

Alberta’s premier rejects call to fire health minister over abuse of citizens

Alberta’s premier rejects call to fire health minister over abuse of citizens

Trump boosts virus aid, warns governors to be ‘appreciative’

Trump boosts virus aid, warns governors to be ‘appreciative’

Marc Miller urges First Nations to delay elections during COVID-19 crisis

Marc Miller urges First Nations to delay elections during COVID-19 crisis

Most Read