Battle over GuZoo drags on before the courts

An attempt by two animal rights organizations to have a judicial review of the GuZoo’s operating permit has been complicated by the fact the zoo’s operator is now suing the government department that issued the permit.

An attempt by two animal rights organizations to have a judicial review of the GuZoo’s operating permit has been complicated by the fact the zoo’s operator is now suing the government department that issued the permit.

Voice for Animals Humane Society and Zoocheck Canada were attempting through the courts to have the zoo’s permit cancelled.

The two organizations believe GuZoo has repeatedly failed to meet minimum standards as set out in the province’s Zoo Standards.

Lynn Gustafson, the owner of the oft-criticized GuZoo Animal Farm near Three Hills, is now suing the province, alleging its zoo development plan was copied without permission.

That action has thrown a wrench into the animals rights groups’ court proceedings, according to Tove Reece, executive director for Voice for Animals, based in Edmonton.

Reece said they initially had a court date of Feb. 13 for the judicial review. But Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development (ESRD) lawyers indicated they could not be ready for February because of GuZoo’s statement of claim, filed on Nov. 7.

So now the judicial review is slated for Sept. 16, 2015, but GuZoo’s current zoo permit will expire before that, on March 31. Reece said it complicates things a bit, because their court fight is based on GuZoo’s current permit.

“It hinges a little bit on whether the government renews GuZoo’s licence in April. If they do, I think our argument still holds,” Reece said.

However, if GuZoo does not receive a new permit for 2015 (it must apply each year), then it becomes a moot point, said Reece, although it’s possible GuZoo could make some changes and be issued a permit afterwards.

Gustafson did not want to comment on his statement of claim against ESRD.

“It’s better not to say anything,” he said. “I’m not going to comment.”

The claim filed in Drumheller Court of Queen’s Bench starts out by stating: “The GuZoo intends to remain in operation for many years to come.”

As part of the compliance of Alberta Zoo Standards, Gustafson states he submitted a Zoo Development Plan to ESRD in 2013.

Gustafson believes the contents of his plan are strictly confidential “and highly sought after by animal rights terrorist groups.”

When he submitted the plan to ESRD, which ultimately approved them, he said he indicated the plan could not be copied, the statement of claim states.

Gustafson believes that ESRD made five copies of the plan, breaching a trust.

In the claim, he wants $5,500 for every copy for a total of $27,500, made within 20 days of the statement of claim date, and after that, until the $27,500 is paid in full, $1,000 a day in addition.

The lawsuit names the minister of Environment and Sustainable Resource Development and four ESRD employees.

The department’s statement of defence, filed Nov. 26, denies that the plaintiff or GuZoo has ever had copyright in the development plan. “To the contrary, the defendants state that if any copyright exists … then it belongs to Her Majesty the Queen. …”

It denies “that if there was ever any trust relationship … which is expressly denied, then there has not been any breach of the trust relationship in connection with the development plan. …”

It also states that any use or copying of or dealing with the development plan is “solely for the purpose of administration or enforcement of the relevant legislation.”

The statement of defence denies the plaintiff suffered any loss or damage and asks that the claim be dismissed, with costs.

None of the allegations have been proven in court.

barr@bprda.wpengine.com

Just Posted

Police probe deadly shooting that left 3 dead, 12 wounded in Toronto’s Greektown

TORONTO — Three people died in a shooting rampage that took place… Continue reading

Alberta UCP Leader Jason Kenney says hateful comments won’t be tolerated

EDMONTON — Alberta United Conservative Leader Jason Kenney, addressing party friction over… Continue reading

One in seven sexual assault cases in 2017 deemed ‘unfounded’: Statcan

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says some 3,900 sexual assaults reported to police… Continue reading

Child’s play at Westerner Days

Balloons bring out the child in everyone

WATCH: Gazebo groundbreaking in Waskasoo

Fifty per cent of the $100,000 project is funded by a provincial government grant

Fiat Chrysler is shaken without visionary CEO behind wheel

MILAN — Investors sent shares in Fiat Chrysler sliding Monday as they… Continue reading

HMCS St. John’s, Sea King return to Halifax port after overseas mission

HALIFAX — HMCS St. John’s and its 240-member crew pulled into their… Continue reading

Danforth rampage continues a deadly year of gun violence for Toronto

TORONTO — Sunday’s deadly rampage in Toronto marks the latest in a… Continue reading

Iran dismisses Trump’s explosive threat to country’s leader

TEHRAN, Iran — Iranians on Monday shrugged off the possibility that a… Continue reading

Americans in blended families cope with toll of deportation

BOCA DEL R\XCDO, Mexico — It’s almost as if Letty Stegall is… Continue reading

Residents flee forest fire near Greek capital of Athens

ATHENS, Greece — Residents fled their homes Monday as a swift-moving fire… Continue reading

Charming great white shark delights followers with return to waters off N.S.

HALIFAX — Hilton is back. The great white shark who stole the… Continue reading

Police probe deadly shooting that left 3 dead, 12 wounded in Toronto’s Greektown

TORONTO — Three people died in a shooting rampage that took place… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month