Bill to increase seat count passes into law

OTTAWA — The country’s fastest growing provinces are getting more MPs, but whether Canadian voters in big cities and suburbs — especially visible minorities — will actually get electoral respect remains an open question.

OTTAWA — The country’s fastest growing provinces are getting more MPs, but whether Canadian voters in big cities and suburbs — especially visible minorities — will actually get electoral respect remains an open question.

Following a lightning-fast study and debate, the Senate passed Bill C-20 on Friday, legislation to redistribute ridings across the country.

The House of Commons will swell to 338 seats from 308 — Ontario will get 15 more seats, Alberta and British Columbia will each receive six more seats, and Quebec three.

The new seats will be in place by the time the next national vote rolls around in 2015.

But several experts who testified at a Senate committee this week said there is more work to do to ensure that the vote of a Canadian living in one riding has an equal weight to the vote of a Canadian living in another riding in the same province.

Once the legislation passes, it will be up to independent provincial electoral boundary commissions to redraw the riding maps.

And those commissioners don’t just sit down and precisely divide up a riding according to the province’s population. They often have to account for geography, and ridings that are unwieldy for a single MP to cover.

The Electoral Boundaries Readjustment Act allows for up to 25 per cent variance above or below the average size of a riding in the province — leading to some potentially large deviations.

Liberal Senator Mobina Jaffer told the chamber Friday that she was worried that problems of inequality between voters would persist if the boundary commissions weren’t restricted in the degree of riding variance they could apply.

“Although I firmly believe that every Canadian’s vote should be weighted equally regardless of where they reside in the country, I do not believe that this bill is the correct remedy to ensure that is the case as we continue to be giving the power of 25 per cent deviation when they see necessary,” Jaffer said during third-reading debate Friday.

Some witnesses who testified at the Senate legal and constitutional affairs committee this week said the allowable variance in the size of a riding should be much, much lower.

“To the extent that we have chosen to over-represent certain Canadians, it is become very apparent that the Canadians who are under-represented are increasingly concentrated in suburban Canada, the GTA (greater Toronto area), visible minorities,” Matthew Mendelsohn, director of the University of Toronto’s Mowat Centre, told the senators.

John Courtney, professor emeritus of political studies at the University of Saskatchewan, suggested the maximum allowable variance in a riding’s size in a province should be 15 per cent — or even as low as one per cent.

“That, I think, would help to capture the new Canadians, the immigrants with which we are all familiar now, in the suburban areas in and around the great metropolitan centre of this country,” Courtney said.

“It would help to ensure a greater social diversity in the House of Commons.”

Another debate that has been shelved for the time being is just how big the Commons should be.

Uppal noted that, physically, the Commons can only accommodate 374 MPs. By the year 2031, there should be approximately 354 MPs, based on population projections.

But several witnesses, and the Liberal party, have suggested putting a cap on that number as soon as possible. The cost of adding 30 new MPs comes to $19.3 million a year. Keeping the number stable would mean rebalancing the ridings more drastically, by reducing the number of MPs in slower growing provinces, for example.

A Liberal proposal put forward in November would have kept the number of MPs at 308, actually eliminating MPs in places like Newfoundland and Labrador, Saskatchewan and Quebec.

Andrew Sancton, a political science professor at the University of Western Ontario, said the argument that more seats need to be added to improve representation by population doesn’t hold water.

He said if Canada really wanted the ideal formula, given the protections given to the Atlantic provinces in the Constitution, it would need 800 MPs.

“We simply have not had a debate about the size of the House of Commons and the arguments for and against,” said Sancton. “We have just been told that in order to have fair representation, we must have more members, which is simply not true.”

But Democratic Reform Minister Tim Uppal told the committee Wednesday that increases to the Commons will be “quite reasonable.”

“What is the option? Take seats away from other provinces? We do not feel that is fair,” Uppal said.

“We feel we must uphold constitutional guarantees that are already in place — long-standing guarantees — for those provinces.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Ice shifted to the shoreline at Sylvan Lake on April 21. (Photo contributed by Andrea Swainson)
Icy shores of Sylvan Lake

A local photographer has captured how the ice has shifted to the… Continue reading

Curtis Labelle (second from left) and his band are planning a cross-Canada tour in 2022. Meanwhile, Labelle is continuing to host his weekly livestreamed talk show, Chattin 88. (Contributed photo).
Red Deer rock pianist takes on a talk show role

Curtis Labelle’s Chattin 88 gets views from around the globe

A boat sits idle on the banks of Villa Victoria Dam, the main water supply for Mexico City residents, on the outskirts of Toluca, Mexico, Thursday, April 22, 2021. The mayor of Mexico City said the drought was the worst in 30 years, and that problem can be seen at the series of reservoirs that bring in water from other states to supply the capital. (AP Photo/Fernando Llano)
FILE - In this Jan. 18, 2020, file photo Caitlyn Jenner speaks at the 4th Women’s March in Los Angeles. Jenner has been an Olympic hero, a reality TV personality and a transgender rights activist. Jenner has been consulting privately with Republican advisers as she considers joining the field of candidates seeking to replace Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom in a likely recall election later this year. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes, File)
Jenner adds celebrity, questions to California governor race

Celebrity activist immediately stands out in a growing field

FILE - In this Thursday, Feb. 14, 2019 file photo, Jeremy Fleming, head of the British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), in London. Western countries risk losing control of technologies that are key to internet security and economic prosperity to nations with competing values like China and Russia if they don’t act to deal with the threat, one of the U.K.’s top spy chiefs warned on Friday, April 23, 2021. “Significant technology leadership is moving East” and causing a conflict of interests and values, Jeremy Fleming, director of government electronic surveillance agency GCHQ, said in a speech. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein, file)
UK spy chief says West faces ‘moment of reckoning’ on tech

China’s Foreign Ministry condemn the remarks

Brooke Henderson, of Canada, watches her tee shot on the 17th hole during the final round of the Tournament of Champions LPGA golf tournament, Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021, in Lake Buena Vista, Fla. (AP Photo/Phelan M. Ebenhack)
Canadian Brooke Henderson vaults into tie for fourth at LPGA Tour event

Henderson is sixth in the world women’s golf rankings

Switzerland’s skip Silvana Tirinzoni makes a call during a women’s curling match against Canada at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Gangneung, South Korea, Sunday, Feb. 18, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Natacha Pisarenko
Previously unbeaten women’s teams suffer setbacks at Grand Slam curling event

Top six women’s and men’s teams qualify for the playoffs.

FILE - Gal Gadot arrives at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party on Sunday, Feb. 9, 2020, in Beverly Hills, Calif. Gadot is using her Hollywood star power to spotlight remarkable women from around the world. The “Wonder Woman” actor is host and executive producer of a new documentary series “National Geographic Presents IMPACT with Gal Gadot,” premiering Monday, April 26. (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, File)
Gal Gadot spotlights women’s stories in new docuseries

First episode follows a young Black figure skating coach in Detroit

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Minister Marco Mendicino listens to speakers during a news conference in Ottawa, Friday October 2, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Retaking language test unfair during COVID-19: applicants to new residency pathway

New program aims to grant 90,000 essential workers and international graduates permanent status

LtE bug
Letter: Questions around city funding for Westerner

The Advocate article on April 21 on page 3 “Council to discuss… Continue reading

Most Read