Border guards accused of molesting women

Three Canadian women have launched legal action alleging they were molested by female U.S. border guards while attempting to cross the border near Windsor, Ont.

TORONTO — Three Canadian women have launched legal action alleging they were molested by female U.S. border guards while attempting to cross the border near Windsor, Ont.

In court documents filed in the U.S., Leslie Ingratta of Windsor alleges two customs and border protection officers took her to a holding cell for questioning when she attempted to cross the Detroit-Windsor tunnel on Jan. 30, 2011 for a shopping trip to the states.

The lawsuit alleges officials questioned Ingratta repeatedly and accused her of lying about her reasons to travel before ordering her to face a wall. With her arms and legs spread, the officials conducted a search that included putting their hands under her bra and fondling her breasts, as well as grabbing her buttocks and rubbing her genitals, the suit alleges.

She was then taken back to the waiting room, crying and shaking, and told she was “clear to enter the United States.”

“By this point, plaintiff was too traumatized to continue on her trip and returned to Canada,” court documents read.

In a second, joint lawsuit two women from Windsor and Milton, Ont. — both frequent travellers to the country and holders of Nexus cards and Visas — claim they were strip-searched in an inappropriate manner while travelling together across the Ambassador Bridge on March 5, 2010 to attend a concert.

They allege the guards put their fingers into their anuses and vaginas, and fondled each of their bare breasts “in a prolonged, deliberate manner.”

One of the women was eight months pregnant at the time.

All the searches, the documents allege, were conducted without any reasonable suspicion that that type of search was warranted.

None of the allegations have been tested in court.

“It is proper under some circumstances for a security pat-down to be performed, or even a limited personal search if there’s reasonable suspicion that a person is concealing contraband on his or her body,” said Thomas Wienner, a Rochester, Mich.-based lawyer, who represents all three women.

“But there is a big difference between that and what amounts to sexual groping, which is what happened with each of the women involved in these cases.

“These women were sexually molested at the border and there’s just no excuse for that.”

Given that a similar lawsuit had been previously filed by fourth woman, Wienner said he believes there could be more victims.

The current lawsuits are separate and more victims won’t result in a class action, however, because the circumstances from each case are such that class-action treatment isn’t appropriate, he added.

Wienner also said it’s not yet known if the same guards were involved in all the incidents, since their identities will not be known until their files are disclosed as part of the lawsuit.

The cases will be heard in a federal court in Michigan even though all the complainants are Canadian.

“If you have voluntary contacts with the U.S., including crossing at the border, then the law in the U.S. is clear that you are entitled to be protected by the fourth amendment to our constitution which prohibits unreasonable searches,” Wienner said.

In both cases, the women are seeking punitive damages as well as compensatory damages for the mental anguish and emotional distress suffered in an amount to be determined at trial, as well a reimbursement for their legal fees.

Just Posted

The Latest: UK leader congratulates royals on birth of son

LONDON — The Latest on the royal baby birth: 1:50 p.m. British… Continue reading

Key events in the life of William, Kate and their family

LONDON — The Duchess of Cambridge gave birth Monday to a baby… Continue reading

Broncos families surprised obituaries are on website selling services

Some families of Humboldt Broncos bus crash victims are surprised to learn… Continue reading

‘It’s limitless:’ Paralyzed toddler moves from homemade wheelchair to treadmill

EDMONTON — Evelyn Moore sings the alphabet song as her tiny running… Continue reading

Shania Twain apologizes for saying she would have voted for Donald Trump

Shania Twain is apologizing after telling a British newspaper that she would… Continue reading

Replay Red Deer April 22, 2018

Watch weekly news highlights from Red Deer and Central Alberta

Crosby, Penguins keep 3rd straight championship in sight

PHILADELPHIA — Sidney Crosby tormented the Flyers just as he has from… Continue reading

29-year-old chef dies after collapsing at London Marathon

London Marathon organizers say a 29-year-old man died after collapsing near the… Continue reading

Greece beats budget target as it looks to post-bailout era

ATHENS, Greece — Greece has beaten its budget targets for a third… Continue reading

Etiquette and protocol highlights for royal wedding guests

NEW YORK — Grab those nude stockings, ladies. You’ll be at a… Continue reading

Federal environment minister defends BP Canada’s plans to drill in N.S.

HALIFAX — Federal Environment and Climate Change Minister Catherine McKenna is defending… Continue reading

Facebook’s privacy changes look different for Europeans and Americans

All 2.2 billion people who use Facebook will soon see changes to… Continue reading

Vermont wants to turn tourists into workers

Vermont has forest trails, yoga retreats, breweries galore – and a labor… Continue reading

Trump leading on North Korea, says envoy to Canada as G7 ministers meet

TORONTO — Donald Trump’s envoy to Canada says her president is leading… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month