Bureaucrats fire back at watchdog over costing of stealth fighter

The bureaucracy fired back Tuesday at Canada’s budget watchdog over his suggestion the government kept two sets of books on the multibillion-dollar purchase of new stealth-fighter jets.

OTTAWA — The bureaucracy fired back Tuesday at Canada’s budget watchdog over his suggestion the government kept two sets of books on the multibillion-dollar purchase of new stealth-fighter jets.

Parliamentary budget officer Kevin Page said in a weekend radio interview that it seemed as if one set of books inside the Department of National Defence contained a higher cost estimate for the F-35 fighters while another, lower number was presented to the public.

“You do get the sense there were different books being kept,” Page told CBC Radio’s The House on Saturday.

But a senior Defence official told a parliamentary committee his department kept only one set of books, and provided the full cost of the F-35 purchase to cabinet.

“There was one book,” said deputy minister Robert Fonberg.

“There was a column on the left-hand side that went to cabinet for decision-making purposes. And the government decided to communicate exactly the same way they’d communicated since 2004 on the acquisition.”

The Conservative government froze spending on the defence program last month after the auditor general produced a withering report accusing National Defence of keeping Parliament in the dark about the program’s spiralling problems.

Michael Ferguson’s report said the public estimate of $14.7 billion does not include the expected $10 billion operational costs, such as the salaries, fuel and other commodities used to keep the aircraft flying.

A parliamentary committee is now studying that report.

In July 2010, the Conservative government signalled its intention to buy the F-35 Lightning II, insisting it was the only fighter aircraft that meets the needs of the air force.

Officials from the departments of Defence, Industry, Public Works and the Treasury Board appeared at the House of Commons public accounts committee Tuesday morning to defend the costing of the F-35 purchase.

“I think it’s been very clear that this is not a standard procurement. There is uncertainty in terms of total value. We’ve done our best to try to provide projections to the government of what the maximum value of the opportunities might be,” said Simon Kennedy, senior associate deputy minister at Industry Canada.

“Could we have perhaps given a better breakdown and provided more detailed information? We’ll certainly take that to heart.”

The choice has been a political lightning rod ever since with opposition parties, the parliamentary budget officer and now the auditor general questioning the price tag and the method for selection.

But another senior official said Page’s initial estimate was off the mark.

“If you have got the acquisition cost wrong, you’re going to wind up with an estimate that is far, far off the mark,” said Kevin Lindsey, an assistant deputy minister at National Defence.

“If you get the initial acquisition cost way wrong, your total estimated cost is going to be far off the mark.”

The committee is expected to hear again from Page on how he arrived at his estimate.

Just Posted

Red Deer record store celebrates its last Record Store Day

The Soundhouse, a guitar and record shop in downtown Red Deer, closes its doors next Saturday

WATCH: On 4—20 Day in Red Deer, marijuana users say legal weed a long time coming

Not wanting to wait for the federal government to legalize recreational marijuana,… Continue reading

Former Central Alberta MLA appealing fine for not protecting a list of 20,000 electors

List included names and addresses of voters in Rimbey-Rocky Mountain House-Sundre

Proposed Alberta legislation would protect consumers

Alberta Utilities Commission would be given power to penalize natural gas and electricity providers

Red Deer beginning two major construction projects

Ross Street’s 1935-era water main to be replaced and 67th Street roundabout landscaped

WATCH: Central Alberta bouldering competition

Central Alberta climbers looked to prove they’re the best at a competition… Continue reading

WATCH: Red Deer RCMP and Emergency Services play for Humboldt

Red Deer police officers and firefighters laced up their skates to raise… Continue reading

WATCH: Flooding closes portion of Red Deer’s 43 Street

A portion of 43 Street in Red Deer was closed Saturday morning… Continue reading

After air accidents, survivors grapple with flying again

Hundreds of hands grappling with oxygen masks. Flight attendants warning passengers to… Continue reading

Queen Elizabeth to attend pop concert for 92nd birthday

LONDON — Queen Elizabeth is marking her 92nd birthday with a Saturday… Continue reading

‘Such a great person:’ Funeral being held for assistant coach with Broncos

STRASBOURG, Sask. — Mark Cross was a ferocious competitor when he played… Continue reading

UPDATE: Missing Innisfail woman located

A 54-year-old Innisfail woman, who had not been seen since Wednesday, has… Continue reading

Hellebuyck makes 30 saves, Jets beat Wild in Game 5 to advance to Round 2

WINNIPEG — Bryan Little’s teammates were happy they could deliver something special… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month