Canadian Taxpayers defend Debt Clock figures

Re: Some debt is essential, by Greg Neiman, July 23, in the Advocate: You’ve got to hand it to Greg Neiman, who managed to argue (presumably) with a straight face that Alberta’s plunge back into debt was not only necessary, but also “essential.”

Re: Some debt is essential, by Greg Neiman, July 23, in the Advocate:

You’ve got to hand it to Greg Neiman, who managed to argue (presumably) with a straight face that Alberta’s plunge back into debt was not only necessary, but also “essential.”

His commentary made some incredible leaps of economic and fiscal faith that require a thorough debunking.

Neiman’s first factual foul-up was in casting doubt on numbers showing that Alberta’s debt will reach $21 billion by 2016-17 because the CTF can’t predict these things. Those are not the Canadian Taxpayers Federation’s (CTF) numbers. They are in fact the governments’ own numbers.

He also states that the CTF’s numbers that show that Albertans will soon be paying $1.4 billion a year in annual interest payments are “hard to swallow,” because his back of the napkin math doesn’t match. They are again the government’s numbers from their own budget documents.

One of the most extraordinary claims by Neiman’s was that “were it not for the debt, there would be precious little spent at all on roads, bridges, schools and hospitals,” and that “Fildebrandt says we should not have them at all.”

The facts just doesn’t support this claim.

Neiman forgets that the Alberta government has a $47-billion budget and while the government has changed their budget reporting to show that the borrowing is only for capital projects, they could have just as easily shown that it was to pay for the education system.

Although had they done that, surely even Neiman wouldn’t have as easily swallowed that claim.

Yet, taking Neiman and the government’s argument that more debt equals more capital at face value, let’s check that claim with data from Statistics Canada.

If we rank all of the provinces based on the proportion of their budgets devoted to debt interest payments and rank them again based the proportion of their budgets devoted to capital spending, you might be surprised by the results.

Provinces that spend between 1.2 per cent and 5.5 per cent of their budgets on interest payments, devote on average 10.9 per cent of their budgets to capital projects. This group includes Alberta, British Columbia and Saskatchewan.

Provinces that spend between 5.7 per cent and eight per cent on debt interest costs, spend on average 10.8 per cent of their budgets on capital spending. This group includes Manitoba, New Brunswick and P.E.I.

Provinces that spend between 8.4 per cent and 11.1 per cent on interest, spend an average of 10.9 per cent of their budgets on capital. This group includes Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland and Labrador.

In summary, lower debt provinces: 10.9 per cent. Middle of the pack provinces: 10.8 per cent. Higher debt provinces: 10.9 per cent.

There is variation within each grouping, but the overall trend is clear: more debt does not equal more capital spending.

A short-term infusion of debt financing may give a slight bump to capital spending in the short term, but it makes little difference long term, as growing interest payments will require governments to scale back their plans.

This may be a viable option if Alberta was experiencing a Klondike-style gold rush that was only expected to continue for the next few years. But it’s not. Alberta will continue to grow for the foreseeable future and must continue to build infrastructure the whole time.

The Alberta government’s plan however is not to borrow for just a few years and then let off the gas. It’s a permanent funding mechanism built into its fiscal framework.

As for the CTF apparently wanting nothing spent on capital, Neiman clearly didn’t read our 68-page budget submission, nor talk to anyone associated with the CTF.

The CTF’s proposal is to control spending, primarily on the non-capital side of budget.

That means eliminating corporate welfare subsidies, no more untendered contracts for politically connected businesses, and reducing government employee costs.

And lastly for Neiman’s wish the CTF had been calling for increased savings over the years, a Google search would have cleared that up for him.

The CTF has been pushing for a long-term savings plan in Alberta for close to 14 years.

Had the government adopted our plan even five years ago, the Alberta Debt Clock would still be in retirement.

Derek Fildebrandt

Alberta Director

Canadian Taxpayers Federation

Just Posted

Quebec man arrested in slaying of Alberta woman 16 years ago

AIRDRIE, Alta. — A Quebec man has been arrested in the slaying… Continue reading

Construction underway at Medicine River Wildlife Centre in Red Deer

The new building is twice the size of the old one

Fish for free

No license is required to ice fish on Family Day weekend

Music industry struggles to shake ugly legacy of sex, drugs and rock ‘n’ roll

TORONTO — Allegations of sexual misconduct swirling around pop-rockers Hedley have put… Continue reading

WATCH: Red Deer rings in the Chinese New Year

A couple hundred fill Festival Holiday to ring in the Year of the Dog

WATCH Replay Red Deer Feb. 18: Your weekly news highlights

Watch news from Red Deer and Central Alberta

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

#Metoo movement causing confusion in many men, fear of missteps with women: experts

Being painted by the same sweeping brush as those alleged to have mistreated women has angered men

Virtue and Moir break their own world record

Virtue and Moir break short dance record to sit first in ice dance at Olympics

Calgary man dies in Mexico following sudden illness

Troy Black was with his wife, Lindsay, in Puerto Vallarta when he began vomiting blood on Thursday

Life or death main decision for school shooting suspect

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — The evidence against the Florida school shooting suspect… Continue reading

Man who stole millions from Seabird Island band sentenced to 4.5 years jail

Stephen MacKinnon sentenced in Chilliwack court for stealing $2.3 million over eight years

Vancouver artist’s cartoon of Florida school shooting resonates

Cartoon shows football coach, one of the victims, meeting others killed in school shootings

B.C. man brings dog to court as ‘best witness’

Man is defending himself on charges of uttering threats, possessing weapon for dangerous purposes

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month