Court erupts as Crown drops youth murder case

EDMONTON — A double-murder trial collapsed into angry shouts and obscenities Friday when the Crown dropped the charges after a judge ruled that undercover police had coerced a confession from the accused teenager.

EDMONTON — A double-murder trial collapsed into angry shouts and obscenities Friday when the Crown dropped the charges after a judge ruled that undercover police had coerced a confession from the accused teenager.

At least six peace officers rushed into the courtroom as members of the two victims’ families stood up and loudly and repeatedly cursed the teen, his lawyer and the judge.

Queen’s Bench Justice Brian Burrows left during the verbal fusillade without formally adjourning court, leaving lawyers to ask each other: “Are we done?”

The outrage was a chaotic coda to the Crown’s decision to abandon a case that began almost four years ago, when the accused was 14, and ended on the day of his 18th birthday.

“This was a confession-driven case,” prosecutor William Wister told the judge. “The confession’s gone. We close our case.”

The teen was originally charged with two counts of second-degree murder shortly after the killings of Barry Boenke, 68, and his friend Susan Trudel, 50.

The pair were found beaten and shot to death on their rural property east of Edmonton in June 2009.

He was arrested with another teen after they had escaped from a group home and were found driving Boenke’s stolen truck.

The accused confessed to police, but during pretrial hearings a judge ruled the statement inadmissible.

Without that key piece of evidence, the Crown stayed the charges.

No forensic evidence linked the boys to the killings.

Their DNA was not found at the scene and there was no blood or gunshot residue on their clothes.

The gun that killed Boenke and Trudel has not been recovered.

Last May, the Crown reactivated the case against one teen after RCMP targeted both boys in a “Mr. Big” sting in which undercover officers pretended to be members of an organized crime syndicate.

Such stings try to win a subject’s trust with the hope of getting information on a crime as the suspect seeks to win the favour of fake gangsters.

Burrows, in a harshly worded 84-page judgment, ruled the confession obtained by the sting in this case was inadmissible.

“I conclude (the accused’s) statements were coerced,” said the judge, who was hearing the case without a jury.

Burrows pointed out the sting had been run on a 16-year-old boy who had no father, an absent mother and a history of sexual abuse by an uncle.

The teen had been living in a series of group homes, and had been diagnosed with numerous psychological problems, including an attention-deficit disorder and a probable case of fetal alcohol syndrome.

Undercover officers befriended him, gave him money, beer, access to a condo, tickets to a hockey game and a rock concert and a snowboarding trip to the mountains.

The youth had every reason to tell his new friends what he thought they wanted to hear to keep the good times rolling, wrote Burrows.

“Who in their right mind would risk returning to the hell represented by (the accused’s) life away from the Mr. Big operation?” the judge asked.

Burrows concluded that the undercover officers had such a hold over the boy that he was effectively in custody. As a result, his confession violated his constitutional right against self-incrimination.

The judgment, which is subject to a possible appeal, also found the teen had every reason to embellish his story to people he believed were benefactors.

“That (the accused’s) statements were made while he was functionally detained, subject to coercion by inducement, and in a circumstance where he believed that no harm and only good would come to him by confessing, all create a real prospect that his confession to Mr. Big was unreliable.”

Burrows pointed out that everything in the confession could have been drawn from information presented at the original pretrial hearings.

“There is not one detail in (the accused’s) statement that he could not have learned by listening to the evidence as it was presented at the preliminary inquiry,” Burrows wrote.

Defence lawyer Mona Duckett conceded guilt on charges related to the theft of Boenke’s truck and to two break and enters — one at a convenience store and the other at Boenke’s trailer. The youth is to serve 12 months probation for those crimes.

RCMP released a brief statement that said the force was satisfied that it had conducted a thorough investigation and would not be seeking other suspects.

“The RCMP will not be providing further comment due to ongoing legal matters involving the young person in this case and the possibility of an appeal of today’s ruling.

“Please note: calls to RCMP media relations on this matter will not be returned.”

Just Posted

Firefighters and emergency services workers helped celebrate Barry Young’s 85th birthday at Timberstone Mews on May 29. (Photo by Sean McIntosh/Advocate staff)
Firefighters in central Alberta make birthdays special

A fire truck arriving outside your house is not normally good news.… Continue reading

The Government of Alberta identified 115 new COVID-19 cases Sunday, bringing the provincial total to 3,089.
(Black Press file photo)
Red Deer drops to 71 active cases of COVID-19

Province adds 127 new cases of the virus

Crimson Villas, a seniors housing facility in Red Deer has finally opened its doors. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Red Deer senior housing facility opens its doors

Crimson Villas, named after Red Deer’s official flower, has officially bloomed. The… Continue reading

The Town of Ponoka, who has typically leased the main stampede grounds to the Ponoka Stampede and Exhibition Association, is transferring the land to the association. (Photo by Emily Jaycox/Ponoka News)
AB Gov’t to provide more grants for live event organizers

Live events will be getting a boost from the provincial government over… Continue reading

Alberta government committed $7 million last year for an integrated shelter service to help Red Deer's homeless population. (Photo by Advocate staff)
City of Red Deer finds only one viable location for emergency shelter

City of Red Deer administration is recommending the Cannery Row Emergency Shelter… Continue reading

A large number of supporters were out Saturday at a rally intended to bring awareness about including Hinduism in the grade 2 portion of the K-6 draft curriculum. As it stands now, Hinduism won’t be taught until grade 6 in the proposed draft curriculum. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Video: Rally to support adding Hinduism to draft curriculum draws crowd in Red Deer

The Hindu community in Red Deer came out in droves on Saturday… Continue reading

This undated file photo provided by Ernie Carswell & Partners shows the home featured in the opening and closing scenes of The Brady Bunch in Los Angeles. Do you know the occupation of Mike Brady, the father in this show about a blended family? (Anthony Barcelo/Ernie Carswell & Partners via AP, File)
QUIZ: A celebration of dad on Father’s Day

How much do you know about famous fathers?

Germany's Robin Gosens, left, celebrates Germany's Mats Hummels after scoring his side's fourth goal during the Euro 2020 soccer championship group F match between Portugal and Germany at the football arena stadium in Munich, Saturday, June 19, 2021. (Matthias Hangst/Pool Photo via AP)
Germany clicks at Euro 2020 with 4-2 win over Portugal

MUNICH (AP) — Germany finally clicked into gear at the European Championship,… Continue reading

Fans cheer on their team during the pre-game warmup of Game 3 of the NHL Stanley Cup semifinal with the Montreal Canadiens facing the Vegas Golden Knights, in Montreal, Friday, June 18, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
COVID-19 concerns give way to Habs Fever in Quebec as Montreal continues playoff run

MONTREAL — The sun hadn’t yet risen in Montreal on Friday morning… Continue reading

Coronavirus cases are on the rise from India to South Africa and Mexico, in a May 19, 2020 story. (Photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS)
As Brazil tops 500,000 deaths, protests against president

RIO DE JANEIRO (AP) — Anti-government protesters took to the streets in… Continue reading

A black bear cub forages for food along a salmon stream below a bear viewing spot for tourists in the Mendenhall Glacier Recreation Area in Juneau, Alaska.  (File photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Bandit responsible for vehicle break-ins is a black bear

THORNTON, N.H. (AP) — Surveillance video helped police get to the bottom… Continue reading

FILE - In this April 25, 2019 file photo, Editor Rick Hutzell, center, gives a speech to his staff including Chase Cook, Nicki Catterlin, Rachael Pacella, Selene San Felice and Danielle Ohl at the Capital Gazette in Annapolis, Md. The editor of the Capital Gazette, which won a special Pulitzer Prize citation for its coverage and courage in the face of a massacre in its newsroom, is leaving the Maryland newspaper. Hutzell, who worked at the Annapolis paper for more than three decades, authored a farewell column that was published on the paper's website Saturday, June 19, 2021. (Ulysses Muoz/The Baltimore Sun via AP)
Editor of paper that endured newsroom shooting says goodbye

ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — The editor of the Capital Gazette, which won… Continue reading

Britain's Queen Elizabeth II look on, during day five of of the Royal Ascot horserace meeting, at Ascot Racecourse, in Ascot, England, Saturday June 19, 2021. (David Davies/PA via AP)
Queen beams as she returns to Ascot after COVID-19 hiatus

LONDON (AP) — Queen Elizabeth II was smiling broadly as she attended… Continue reading

Barbara Violo, pharmacist and owner of The Junction Chemist Pharmacy, draws up a dose behind vials of both Pfizer-BioNTech and Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccines on the counter, in Toronto, Friday, June 18, 2021. An independent vaccine tracker website founded by a University of Saskatchewan student says just over 20 per cent of eligible Canadians — those 12 years old and above — are now fully vaccinated. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
At least 20 per cent of eligible Canadians fully vaccinated, data suggests

TORONTO — Canada has hit two of the vaccination targets government officials… Continue reading

Most Read