Doing the math on city staff costs

I appreciate CUPE Local 417 president Brian Stevens response to my recent letter to the editor outlining my public pension concerns. Hopefully, I can briefly flesh out the figures disputed by Stevens.

I appreciate CUPE Local 417 president Brian Stevens response to my recent letter to the editor outlining my public pension concerns. Hopefully, I can briefly flesh out the figures disputed by Stevens.

By the numbers (rounded down): There are 145,000 employees covered under the LAP plan. The current unfunded liability is $5 billion, or $34,500 per plan member. With 1,400 City of Red Deer employees, that’s $48.3 million. As the pension shortfall has grown since 2012, it’s a safe bet that the city’s share is thus close enough to $50 million to call it that. Like it or not, that is debt and it does not appear on the city’s financial statements.

With 40 per cent of the city’s $305-million operating budget being payroll, that gives us a figure of $87,142 in payroll costs per employee. Without a median figure, and in the absence of how much of that $87,142 is in the form of pension allowances and other benefits, I gave the benefit of the doubt and assumed that the real figure is likely somewhat lower.

When one considers that this figure is substantially higher than the average earnings of those employed in the private, for-profit sector of the economy, that gives cause for concern.

If the average is high because we have a large number of managers, then we have a problem. If the average is high because pay and benefits are considerably higher across the board than what the private sector pays, then we have another problem.

Mr. Stevens makes two points that need to be addressed. He points out, correctly as per the LAPP website, that the average CUPE member retiring on an LAPP pension will receive approximately $15,000 per year.

Again, by the numbers: A 10-year city employee, retiring at 65, would receive $15,000 per year if they earned $75,000 per year, which is below the average payroll cost. A 25-year employee earning $45,000 per year, well below the average, would receive $22,500 per year from their city pension alone, guaranteed for life, and irrespective of any other personal savings.

Again, the concern is that these payouts are backstopped by the personal earnings and savings of those who do not have such protections from market realities, and that the pension amounts are wholly unrealistic compared to real world earnings and savings of those who have been obligated to pay for all of this largesse.

Mr. Stevens also professes the belief that having a well-paid civic workforce helps to drive up the pay and benefits of those who work in the private sector. Unfortunately, he can’t be more wrong. The necessary high taxes that are levied to support the extraordinary wages and benefits paid to public sector workers reduce private sector profits, re-investment, industry growth, and job and income growth. Without all of these things, there are no taxes.

Our pension tax bomb can be defused without raiding the pockets of the taxpaying public, and it can be accomplished without asking those who have yet to retire from the public sector to sacrifice a dime of what they have invested.

The question is, does our city government have the political will to do so?

Bill Greenwood

Red Deer

Just Posted

Eager-beaver cannabis entrepreneurs already waiting outside Red Deer City Hall

Appications will be accepted on a first-come basis starting on Tuesday

Like father like son: Red Deer area Dreeshen family dedicates life to public service

There are three jobs that could be considered the Dreeshen family business:… Continue reading

Restaurant owner concerned about Gasoline Alley road changes

Nearly 20 trucks were lined up on the service road in front… Continue reading

Preliminary hearings set for two men charged in weapons and drugs bust

A Red Deer man and Sylvan Lake man are facing 80 charges

Eight dogs found in Innisfail hotel room were kept in cages

Eight dogs, kept in cages in a small hotel room in Innisfail… Continue reading

WATCH: Hypnotizing show at Westerner Days

Hynotist and mentalist Joshua Seth performs three times a day at Westerner Days

PHOTOS: River Town Saints rock Red Deer

River Town Saints play Westerner Days Friday in Red Deer

PHOTOS: Dogs, horses and more animals at Westerner Days

Westerner Park’s pavilions were filled with animals during Westerner Days

Red Deer residents can’t get enough mini-doughnuts

Mini-doughnuts were the biggest draw to Westerner Days according to a Red… Continue reading

Four-car crash, including RCMP vehicle, on Highway 2

Two sheriff vehicles were also involved in the collision

Divers hunt for 4 after Missouri duck boat sinks, killing 13

BRANSON, Mo. — Divers are searching Friday for four people still missing… Continue reading

WATCH: Red Deer’s noxious weeds are a goat’s dietary delight

Piper Creek Community Garden gets chemical-free weed control

‘Amazing Race Canada’ competitors face B.C. challenge

They drove Corvettes, mastered falconry basics, and ate blueberry pie in the Cowichan Valley

From hot to not? The Baloney Meter weighs in on Scheer’s economy claims

OTTAWA — “Justin Trudeau inherited a booming economy, but he’s squandering it.… Continue reading

Most Read

Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month