NEW YORK — One month in, NBC’s generational trade of Jay Leno for Jimmy Fallon at the Tonight show is succeeding beyond the hopes of executives who engineered it.
Fallon’s fast start is clear in television ratings and even more stark in social media metrics. While too early to declare a new king of late-night TV, the transition is a marked change from how badly NBC fumbled the short-lived switch from Leno to Conan O’Brien in 2009.
“As a guy who’s been doing this for 36 years, I don’t allow myself to think about this level of success,” said Ted Harbert, NBC broadcasting chairman.
NBC had hoped for an increase in young viewers and steeled itself to lose some of Leno’s older fans, but Fallon’s reception was a surprise.
When Fallon premiered on Tonight during the Olympics, the franchise hit numbers unseen since Johnny Carson’s last week in 1992.
Things have settled down but Fallon is still comfortably on top.
During the week of March 10-14, Fallon averaged 4.26 million viewers to Jimmy Kimmel’s 2.83 million on ABC and David Letterman’s 2.78 million on CBS, the Nielsen company said.
Fallon has consistently topped the 4.1 million viewers that Leno averaged this season before leaving.
Fallon’s lead over his rivals is more pronounced among viewers aged 18-to-49, the demographic NBC bases its advertising sales upon.
Fallon and NBC embrace the way many early-to-bed consumers experience late-night television these days: by watching clips of a show’s best moments online.
The YouTube clip of Fallon and Will Smith acting out the evolution of hip-hop dancing has been seen more than 12.8 million times.
Fallon’s lip-sync duel with Paul Rudd on songs by Tina Turner, Foreigner and Queen has nearly 9 million views.
Other popular clips show Fallon, singer Idina Menzel and the Roots performing Let it Go with children’s instruments and the sliced-and-diced version of newsmen Brian Williams and Lester Holt on Rapper’s Delight.
Each segment is funny, good-natured and utterly impossible to imagine Fallon’s old-school predecessor doing.
“What I notice in people’s reactions is not just that they like the show and think that it’s funny, but they like the feel-good spirit,” Harbert said.
“There’s a total absence of snarkiness, of cynicism. It’s just there to make you feel good before you go to sleep.”
The anti-show biz style pioneered by Letterman isn’t dead, said Robert Thompson, director of the Bleier Centre for Television and Popular Culture at Syracuse University.
But “it may have run its course to some extent,” he said, and Fallon’s sincerity dilutes the pure snark of Letterman and O’Brien.
“Fallon has been able to change the equation,” he said.
He’s made his mark despite a more crowded competitive landscape, with O’Brien, Jon Stewart, Stephen Colbert, Chelsea Handler and Arsenio Hall also mining late-night laughs.
During his first month, Fallon generated more than 120 million YouTube views, Twitter mentions and Facebook posts, the research firm RelishMIX said.
That’s more than double Kimmel, who had 57 million in the same social media metric. Letterman had 2.3 million.
“That lopsidedness is a huge wake-up call to writers, producers of late-night, network marketing departments and other series in all genres that they must ‘feed the beast’ or die,” said Marc Karzen, RelishMIX spokesman.
Friday night’s routine with Kevin Bacon revisiting some Footloose dance moves quickly caught fire online, and video highlights had been watched 7.3 million times as of early Monday, he said.
Aggressive online exposure was a key part of NBC’s launch strategy, which included timing Fallon’s takeover to coincide with heavy viewer interest in the Winter Olympics, Harbert said. The next step is to find ways to make more money off all that online interest, he said.
Fallon’s rivals haven’t backed down from the competition. Kimmel got attention during the Winter Olympics for filming a stunt that jokingly suggested a wolf was roaming the halls of a dorm for athletes.
With their youthful appeal (Fallon is 39, Kimmel 46), the two men seem primed for a bicoastal rivalry.
Judging by one of television’s most prominent measuring sticks for likability, Fallon’s success shouldn’t be a surprise.
He has a “Q” score of 19 among viewers aged 18 to 34 — which means 19 per cent of people familiar with him consider Fallon one of their favourite personalities, said the company Marketing Evaluations Inc., which polled consumers both before and after the Tonight takeover.
Kimmel’s score was 16 and Letterman’s 11, the company said (an average celebrity “Q” score is 17).
Among young men, Fallon’s score shoots up to 24, said company spokesman Henry Schafer. More people that age know who Fallon is than know Letterman, he said.
For older viewers, the graciousness of Leno, 63, during the transition was crucial, Harbert said.
“He said to the country, ‘It’s OK to watch Jimmy Fallon,”’ he said. “I think if he hadn’t, we wouldn’t have been in this position.”