Harper fires back at Duffy

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper has mounted his most spirited defence in months on the Senate spending scandal, accusing Sen. Mike Duffy of playing the victim card because he was ordered to refund inappropriate expense claims.

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper has mounted his most spirited defence in months on the Senate spending scandal, accusing Sen. Mike Duffy of playing the victim card because he was ordered to refund inappropriate expense claims.

“Mr. Duffy now says he is a victim because I told him he should repay his expenses,” Harper told a high-octane House of Commons on Wednesday.

“Darn right I told him he should repay his expenses.”

With his Conservative caucus enthusiastically hooting and banging their desks, Harper took the offensive in the daily question period, repeatedly rising to his feet to respond with vigour, if not always clarity.

His performance — which lasted all of 19 minutes, including opposition questions — served as an antidote for Duffy’s toxic accusations levelled the previous afternoon in the Senate chamber.

Duffy claimed all his expenses were cleared by the Prime Minister’s Office and Senate leadership, but that he was thrown under the bus when news reports began undermining party popularity.

It was a scenario largely reiterated Wednesday by Sen. Pamela Wallin, another apostate Tory.

“’It’s not about what you did,”’ Duffy quoted Harper telling him. “’It’s about the perception of what you did that’s been created in the media. The rules are inexplicable to our base.”’

Harper denied making any such statement Wednesday. Instead, he dished up a bumper-sticker-simple response for the Conservative party base that has the benefit of being true, as far as it goes.

Yes, Harper agreed, he did order Duffy to repay the expense claims. As for the rest of the saga, the prime minister artfully managed to take none of the responsibility but all of the credit.

Did he threaten Duffy with reprisals if he wouldn’t go along with the scheme to repay his expenses?

No, said Harper.

“However, when inappropriate expense claims are made I expect corrective action to be taken,” Harper added, to roars of approval from his MPs.

“If it is not taken, a person who does not take corrective action could not expect to continue to sit as a member of the Conservative party.”

Did he order the Senate to expel, without pay, Duffy and former Conservatives Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau?

That was a Senate decision, said the prime minister, before adding that he wanted to “be unequivocal for the record: I fully support that motion. I do not believe that, under the circumstances, these individuals should be on the public payroll.”

Would he testify under oath?

“I have been crystal clear about this,” Harper responded, before sliding off onto another subject.

Was his lawyer involved in the repayment negotiations?

Harper dissembled.

Why was Duffy called to the Prime Minister’s Office two days before the Feb. 13 meeting where Harper told him to repay his expenses?

“I think the allegation here is that Mr. Duffy and I were in Ottawa on the same day,” quipped Harper, who by now was having fun batting away the opposition questions.

The prime minister even managed to impugn Duffy’s credibility, saying that “when Mr. Duffy went on national television (last March) to say that he had repaid his own expenses by taking out a loan against his assets, that is exactly what he should have done.”

It was only weeks later that CTV revealed Harper’s chief of staff, Nigel Wright, had in fact paid Duffy’s bill.

The prime minister has steadfastly maintained he knew nothing of Wright’s $90,000 cheque, and did so again Wednesday.

It won’t satisfy his harshest critics, but Harper has mollified a Conservative caucus that has seemed mortified by the Senate expense scandal. MPs emerged from Wednesday morning’s caucus meeting all singing variations on the same tune, the same message Harper and his MPs will no doubt take to the Conservative party policy convention in less than two weeks in Calgary.

A far more complicated story was being told down the hall from the Commons in the Senate chamber on Wednesday.

Wallin, like Duffy before her, ripped into a Conservative motion to expel her without pay in the absence of police charges or even evidence of wrongdoing.

The issue is no longer expenses but instead “political expediency” and “abuse of power,” said Wallin.

She accused the Conservative Senate leadership of “taking direction from the PMO” in a process that is “designed to appease the party faithful before a Conservative party convention at the end of the month.”

Just Posted

Central Alberta Archers Association: Proposed safe drug consumption service location puts youth at risk

Turning Point proposes second location for a permanent safe consumption service in Red Deer

Man dead following altercation at gas station on Sunchild First Nation

Rocky Mountain RCMP say victim succumbed to injuries in hospital

UCP member apologizes for ‘unintentionally’ comparing pride flag to swastikas

A member of Alberta’s United Conservative Party is apologizing for making what… Continue reading

Crowd watches as backhoe rips into mangled plane after Halifax runway overrun

HALIFAX — Crews have begun tearing into the mangled Boeing 747 cargo… Continue reading

Grim search for more fire victims, 31 dead across California

PARADISE, Calif. — The death toll from the wildfire that incinerated Paradise… Continue reading

Updated: Red Deer RCMP introduce downtown policing unit

A four-member downtown Red Deer RCMP unit hit the beat on Thursday… Continue reading

Comic book genius Stan Lee, Spider-Man creator, dies at 95

LOS ANGELES — Stan Lee, the creative dynamo who revolutionized the comic… Continue reading

Canada intelligence officials have heard audio of Khashoggi murder, Trudeau says

PARIS — Justin Trudeau says Canadian intelligence officials have listened to a… Continue reading

Canada hoping to solve U.S. tariff dispute by G20 meetings at month’s end: PM

WASHINGTON — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he’s hopeful that Canada can… Continue reading

Bishops will delay votes on steps to combat sex abuse crisis

BALTIMORE — In an abrupt change of plans, the president of the… Continue reading

Man at centre of Nobel body scandal tests rape conviction

STOCKHOLM — The man at the centre of the scandal at the… Continue reading

Chinese premier urges guard of free trade on Singapore visit

SINGAPORE — Chinese Premier Li Keqiang stressed the need for free trade… Continue reading

50 countries vow to fight cybercrime – US and Russia don’t

PARIS — Fifty nations and over 150 tech companies pledged Monday to… Continue reading

More women in poor countries use contraception, says report

KIGALI, Rwanda — More women and girls in poor countries are using… Continue reading

Most Read