Lawyer argues Calgary woman didn’t hit Stelmach with pie, so charge is wrong

A political activist can’t be convicted of assaulting Premier Ed Stelmach’s guard with a pie because her intended target was the premier himself, her lawyer argued Wednesday.

CALGARY — A political activist can’t be convicted of assaulting Premier Ed Stelmach’s guard with a pie because her intended target was the premier himself, her lawyer argued Wednesday.

Defence counsel Mark Takada said Lily Phan should never have been charged with attacking Sheriff Hady Hammoud with pie filling because he wasn’t her mark.

“She’s guilty of an attempted assault on Mr. Stelmach, that’s the appropriate resolution, the appropriate charge in this case,” Takada told provincial court Judge Bill Cummings.

“You charge them with the appropriate charge,” said Takada, arguing for an acquittal against his client.

“It . . . does not make sense to convict a person of something they did not intend to do.”

But acting chief Crown prosecutor Lloyd Robertson said Phan should be found guilty of all five charges she faces in an incident at the premier’s Stampede breakfast in 2007.

Phan is accused of assaulting a peace officer, common assault, assault to resist arrest, mischief and causing a disturbance.

She was arrested July 9, 2007, after lunging at Stelmach with a fistful of chocolate cream filling as the premier flipped pancakes at his annual Stampede party. He was untouched by the creamy filling.

Robertson told Cummings the concept of transferred intent — in which you are guilty of assaulting one person if you intended to assault another — is well-established law.

He also said Phan was guilty of causing a disturbance by screaming as she was being taken down after her lunge at the premier, and of mischief for disrupting the breakfast.

But Takada said his client simply yelled, “it’s a pie, not a bomb” to avoid being roughed up during her arrest.

Cummings will hand down a verdict on June 26.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

COVID-19 tests urged for all teachers and school staff

121 new cases Wednesday, active cases up to 1,040

Three people drown at Crescent Falls

Three people have drowned at Crescent Falls, near Nordegg. Just after 8… Continue reading

Walk-in clinic where Red Deer physician was attacked remembers Reynolds

Dr. Walter Reynolds moved to Red Deer from Manitoba in 2006

Fraudulent online fundraiser for family of Red Deer doctor who died removed

An online fundraiser appeared Monday night for the family of Red Deer… Continue reading

UCP MLAs participating in a different kind of race

MLAs from the United Conservative Party will race each other this week.… Continue reading

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

Michael Dawe: Indecision almost prevented creation of downtown oasis

One of the crown jewels of Red Deer is City Hall Park,… Continue reading

Clippers beat Nuggets to wrap up No. 2 seed in West

Clippers beat Nuggets to wrap up No. 2 seed in West

Castroneves gets refresher course in quest for 4th Indy win

Castroneves gets refresher course in quest for 4th Indy win

Simon Fraser University drops the ‘Clan’ as sports team name

Simon Fraser University drops the ‘Clan’ as sports team name

Bailey helps Islanders rally to beat Capitals 4-2 in Game 1

Bailey helps Islanders rally to beat Capitals 4-2 in Game 1

Avalanche score 3 third-period goals to beat Coyotes 3-0

Avalanche score 3 third-period goals to beat Coyotes 3-0

Raptors rally past Sixers to give Griffin a coaching win

Raptors rally past Sixers to give Griffin a coaching win

Most Read