Lawyer argues Calgary woman didn’t hit Stelmach with pie, so charge is wrong

CALGARY — A political activist can’t be convicted of assaulting Premier Ed Stelmach’s guard with a pie because her intended target was the premier himself, her lawyer argued Wednesday.

CALGARY — A political activist can’t be convicted of assaulting Premier Ed Stelmach’s guard with a pie because her intended target was the premier himself, her lawyer argued Wednesday.

Defence counsel Mark Takada said Lily Phan should never have been charged with attacking Sheriff Hady Hammoud with pie filling because he wasn’t her mark.

“She’s guilty of an attempted assault on Mr. Stelmach, that’s the appropriate resolution, the appropriate charge in this case,” Takada told provincial court Judge Bill Cummings.

“You charge them with the appropriate charge,” said Takada, arguing for an acquittal against his client.

“It … does not make sense to convict a person of something they did not intend to do.”

But acting chief Crown prosecutor Lloyd Robertson said Phan should be found guilty of all five charges she faces in an incident at the premier’s Stampede breakfast in 2007.

Phan is accused of assaulting a peace officer, common assault, assault to resist arrest, mischief and causing a disturbance.

She was arrested July 9, 2007, after lunging at Stelmach with a fistful of chocolate cream filling as the premier flipped pancakes at his annual Stampede party. He was untouched by the creamy filling.

Robertson told Cummings the concept of transferred intent — in which you are guilty of assaulting one person if you intended to assault another — is well-established law.

He also said Phan was guilty of causing a disturbance by screaming as she was being taken down after her lunge at the premier, and of mischief for disrupting the breakfast.

But Takada said his client simply yelled, “it’s a pie, not a bomb” to avoid being roughed up during her arrest.

Cummings will hand down a verdict on June 26.

Just Posted

Councillors want to represent Red Deer at AUMA

City council approves endorsement

Cannabis smoke raises health concerns

Smoke Free Bylaw returns to Red Deer city council Sept. 4

Avid Penhold climber Catlin Hannah’s death a reminder of the dangers of scrambling

Hannah never returned from his Mount Smuts attempt on Aug. 12.

Children, elderly at risk as smoke from distant fires hangs over parts of B.C.

VANCOUVER — Thick smoke blanketing British Columbia communities far from any flames… Continue reading

WATCH: Medicine River Wildlife Centre opens new playground

The grand opening of the playground was Saturday morning

Police chiefs want new data-sharing treaty with U.S. as privacy questions linger

OTTAWA — Canada’s police chiefs are pressing the Trudeau government to sign… Continue reading

Pope on sex abuse: “We showed no care for the little ones”

VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis issued a letter to Catholics around the… Continue reading

Ottawa announces $189M to extend employment insurance for seasonal workers

ESCUMINAC, N.B. — Ottawa has announced $189 million for an employment insurance… Continue reading

Trudeau formally announces he’ll run again in next year’s election

MONTREAL — Justin Trudeau will run again in the 2019 federal election.… Continue reading

Smoke from B.C. wildfires prompts air quality advisories across Western Canada

VANCOUVER — More smoky, hazy air is expected to blanket much of… Continue reading

Anti-pipeline protesters released days before weeklong jail sentences end

MAPLE RIDGE, B.C. — Several pipeline protesters were released from a British… Continue reading

All eyes on Andrew Scheer as Conservative convention set for Halifax

OTTAWA — After a week of internal caucus squabbles, Conservative Leader Andrew… Continue reading

Trump says his White House counsel not a ‘RAT’ like Nixon’s

BRIDGEWATER, N.J. — President Donald Trump insisted Sunday that his White House… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month