Lawyer calls for review of ‘rigid’ baby death law

A young woman faces at least 10 years in prison after a judge refused Tuesday to set aside a jury’s verdict of second-degree murder for killing her newborn baby.

A young woman faces at least 10 years in prison after a judge refused Tuesday to set aside a jury’s verdict of second-degree murder for killing her newborn baby.

And while the Crown made no apologies for prosecuting Katrina Effert on that charge, both lawyers suggested current murder laws may be too rigid in such cases.

“Is it time for a review? My personal opinion is that it is,” said prosecutor John LaLuk after an emotional morning in court in which Queen’s Bench Justice Joanne Veit’s words were nearly inaudible over the sobs of Effert’s parents.

Effert was convicted Saturday by jurors who accepted the Crown’s argument that she knew what she was doing when she gave birth in her parents’ basement in Wetaskiwin, south of Edmonton, strangled the baby with her underwear and then threw the tiny corpse over a fence into the neighbour’s yard.

It was the second time a jury had found Effert guilty of second-degree murder. Her original conviction was thrown out by the Alberta Court of Appeal because of how the original trial judge charged the jury.

Effert’s lawyer, Peter Royal, called the most-recent verdict “perverse,” pointing out that the jury had ignored all expert medical testimony that suggested Effert’s mind was disturbed as a result of the birth.

He asked Veit to declare a mistrial.

“The application from the defence has a great deal of merit and substance,” Veit said in court.

But she added that overturning the verdict of a jury in a case she had just presided over would leave her open to charges that she was incapable of viewing the case objectively.

The best place to fix an unjust verdict is in Appeal Court, she said.

And an appeal is coming, said Royal.

Co-prosecutor Rob Robbenhaar said he had no doubt that Effert acted with intent. However, the inflexibility of sentencing for second-degree murder points to the need for reform.

“Parliament should introduce a diminished responsibility manslaughter,” he said.

Robbenhaar has a point, said Steven Penney, a University of Alberta law professor.

“If you could have a more flexible sentencing regime, you probably wouldn’t have a need for infanticide,” he said.

Just Posted

Alberta hiring more paramedics and buying new ambulances, none for Red Deer

Red Deer Mayor Tara Veer is not concerned the provincial government didn’t… Continue reading

‘My nightmare began again’: Close call as bus carrying Humboldt crash survivor rear-ended

CALGARY — A terrifying ordeal for Humboldt Broncos survivor Ryan Straschnitzki this… Continue reading

Halifax airport operations normalize after Boeing 747 runway overshoot

HALIFAX — The Halifax Stanfield International Airport has resumed normal operations a… Continue reading

Bentley family left without a home grateful for community support

Central Albertans are coming together to support a Bentley family left homeless… Continue reading

Red Deer RCMP ready for new mandatory alcohol screening law

Red Deer RCMP are ready to enforce a new law intended to… Continue reading

WATCH: Red Deer and District Kennel Club Dog Show at Westerner Park

The Red Deer and District Kennel Club is holding a dog show… Continue reading

Pence aide out of running to be Trump’s next chief of staff

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s top pick to replace chief of staff… Continue reading

Swath of South faces wintry mess: Snow, sleet, freezing rain

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — A massive storm brought snow, sleet, and freezing rain… Continue reading

‘I killed my best friend’: Opioids’ fatal grip on mayor, pal

MOUNT CARBON, Pa. — Janel Firestone found her son — the 24-year-old,… Continue reading

Brothers, 20, face second-degree murder charge in death of teen: police

MISSISSAUGA, Ont. — Police west of Toronto say two brothers have been… Continue reading

A young mayor, his friend, and a fatal attraction to opioids

MOUNT CARBON, Pa. — Janel Firestone found her son — the 24-year-old,… Continue reading

GM fights to retain key tax credit amid plant closing plans

WASHINGTON — General Motors is fighting to retain a valuable tax credit… Continue reading

TTC union asks provincial government to step in on transition to Presto

TORONTO — The union representing transit workers in Canada’s most populous city… Continue reading

Small pot growers find roadblocks on path to microcultivation licences

Yan Boissonneault’s daughter was turning blue. Without warning, his baby had stopped… Continue reading

Most Read