MacKay defends Nadon appointment

Justice Minister Peter MacKay is defending the federal government’s troubled appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court of Canada even though it has left the high court short-handed for a major constitutional hearing.

OTTAWA — Justice Minister Peter MacKay is defending the federal government’s troubled appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court of Canada even though it has left the high court short-handed for a major constitutional hearing.

MacKay said Tuesday he still strongly supports Nadon’s appointment, even though the squabble about his eligibility means the high court will be short a judge when it hears the federal government’s crucial Senate reference case next week.

The government has asked the Supreme Court to give its opinion on how to achieve change in the upper chamber, an opinion that might not come for another year.

In the meantime, Nadon — a semi-retired Federal Court judge — remains in limbo, quarantined from his judicial colleagues after Prime Minister Stephen Harper appointed him last month to fill one of the three Quebec seats on the nine-member Supreme Court.

A Toronto lawyer has challenged the appointment, arguing the Ottawa-based Nadon does not meet the bench and residency requirements for a Quebec representative on the high court.

“We feel that the appointment that we’ve made is within the parameters of the Judges Act. We feel very strongly,” MacKay said.

The minister said he defers to Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin to decide when cases are heard, and who hears them. “That is an administrative matter with respect to the timing of the hearing of certain cases.”

A legal expert blasted the government for not being accountable for the Nadon snafu.

“What we haven’t heard since he was appointed was an explanation from the minister of justice as to why he was chosen,” said University of Ottawa law professor Adam Dodek.

The Harper government’s decision to have Supreme Court nominees testify before a House of Commons committee has shifted questions regarding the transparency and accountability of judicial appointments from the prime minister to the nominee, he said.

“These hearings were supposed to be about accountability for the exercise of power and they’ve had completely the opposite effect. They’ve taken the minister of justice and the prime minister off the hook,” he said.

“The system that has been put in Dodek said eight justices can still do an adequate job in the Senate case because the Supreme Court will be striving for a unanimous decision so that its reference will have more weight.

Only eight judges heard the last reference on the fate of the Senate, in 1979, when then-prime minister Pierre Trudeau turned to the high court for an opinion on whether he could overhaul the upper chamber, he added.

The judges said by an 8-0 margin that the government needed provincial consent to make fundamental changes to the Senate.

Quebec’s National Assembly passed a unanimous motion last week that called for the Supreme Court to have a full bench, including three Quebec judges, when it hears cases that are important for the province, including the Senate reference.

Last weekend, Prime Minister Stephen Harper blamed the “courts” for standing in the way of Senate reform, an apparent reference to the recent Quebec appeal court opinion.

It said the federal government had no right to create Senate elections and set term limits without seeking provincial approval.

Just Posted

Gasoline Alley Harley Davidson hosts 7th annual Toy Run

Bikers jumped on their motorcycles this weekend to help make Christmas better… Continue reading

Innisfail RCMP locate drugs during traffic stop

A Rocky Mountain House man is facing charges after Innisfail RCMP located… Continue reading

Expert says acquittal of Alberta parents in boy’s death unlikely to set precedent

CALGARY — A law professor says the acquittal of an Alberta couple… Continue reading

Take Back the Night rally marches through downtown Red Deer

Dozens marched through the city’s downtown chanting, “Red Deer unite, take back… Continue reading

Houston area sees relief, rescues after Imelda leaves 4 dead

HOUSTON — Emergency workers used boats Friday to rescue about 60 residents… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Tuesday Bower Place Community Association Seniors Card and Coffee party at 1:30… Continue reading

Missing hiker found safe after spending night on North Vancouver mountain

VANCOUVER — Rescue crews have found a missing female hiker safe after… Continue reading

Trudeau was only one in dark makeup at 2001 party but nobody took offence: attendee

VANCOUVER — A man who attended an “Arabian Nights” gala held by… Continue reading

McKenna defends Canada’s climate credibility amid Trudeau controversy

OTTAWA — Liberal cabinet minister Catherine McKenna says Canada still has credibility… Continue reading

Blue Jays rookie Bo Bichette trying to “be smart” with head injury

NEW YORK — Blue Jays rookie shortstop Bo Bichette says he’s feeling… Continue reading

Climate activists step up protests in Britain and France

PARIS — Environmental activists in Britain and France stepped up campaigns Saturday… Continue reading

Man from Winnipeg who was hiking alone found dead in Banff National Park

LAKE LOUISE, Alta. — A hiker has been found dead in Banff… Continue reading

Singh campaigns in Toronto, May in Winnipeg, as Liberal and Tory leaders pause

OTTAWA — Jagmeet Singh and Elizabeth May are continuing on the campaign… Continue reading

Most Read