Major retailers victorious against Quebec’s French signs law

MONTREAL — A judge has ruled that major retailers do not have to modify their commercial trademark English names into French, as the province’s language watchdog had hoped.

MONTREAL — A judge has ruled that major retailers do not have to modify their commercial trademark English names into French, as the province’s language watchdog had hoped.

A Quebec Superior Court justice ruled Wednesday that businesses that have storefront signs with their trademark name in a language other than French do not contravene the French Language Charter.

Several multinationals took the province to court after they were told by the language watchdog to change their names or risk running afoul of the rules governing the language of business in the province.

The Office quebecois de la langue francaise wanted the companies to change their signs to either give themselves a generic French name or add a slogan or explanation that reflected what they sold.

But the judge hearing the case ruled in favour of the major retailers — a list that included Best Buy, Costco, Gap, Old Navy, Guess, Wal-Mart, Toys “R” Us and Curves.

“Public signage by the plaintiffs of their trademarks uniquely in a language other than French, when there is no French version of the trademark, does not violate the Charter of the French Language or the laws respecting the language of commerce and business,” Justice Michel Yergeau wrote.

The companies operate a combined 215 outlets in the province. They had argued they complied with the language laws as they stand. They suggested the watchdog was offering a different interpretation of the laws, which had not been formally changed in years.

In 2012, the retailers sought the court’s opinion as to whether the government had the right to make such a demand.

While the language law states the name of a business must be in French, it generally hasn’t applied to trademark names.

The judge said it’s not up to the courts to modify language rules that have remained unchanged for two decades.

Yergeau wrote that while trademarks fall under federal jurisdiction, it’s up to the Quebec legislature to “take the lead” if it considers the French language is suffering because of English trademarks.

“The choice is a political function and not one of the judiciary,” Yergeau wrote.

The watchdog had suggested that a store like Wal-Mart, a household name on the retail scene in Quebec with no French equivalent, could change its signage to “Le Magasin Wal-Mart.”

Some companies have changed their business names here.

For example, Kentucky Fried Chicken is known in Quebec as Poulet Frit Kentucky, so KFC is commonly known here as PFK. Starbucks is known as Cafe Starbucks Coffee. And after a series of firebombings in the early 2000s, Second Cup coffee shops added the words “Les cafes” to their signs.

Yergeau wrote that nothing prevents firms from adopting a French name of their own volition.

“Many (companies) do already on a voluntary basis, while at the same time contributing to the preservation of the French language in Quebec,” the judge wrote.

The issue is part of a broader battle as the provincial government constantly seeks to ensure the preservation and development of French in the province — the only place in North America where the majority speak it.

The watchdog embarked on an awareness campaign in late 2011, calling the situation involving the big stores worrisome.

They suggested coming up with a sort of descriptive slogan or line in French or using a French/English sign, with the French component being more predominant.

As the tension mounted, a French language rights group called on a boycott of the retailers in question.

Legal action was triggered after the watchdog sent letters obliging retailers to change their signs, followed by legal letters that threatened to revoke government “francization certificates” and dole out hefty fines.

Those certificates, renewed every three years, mean companies are in compliance with language rules and can benefit from certain government grants. All of the plaintiffs had received their certificates previously, with no concerns raised about their storefront signage.

In his ruling, Yergeau also said the watchdog may not suspend, revoke or refuse to renew certificates or attempt to impose any other sanction stemming from the trademarks.

Language watchdog Jean-Pierre Le Blanc said it’ll be up to the attorney general’s office to decide whether to challenge the ruling.

The government has 30 days to decide whether to appeal the decision.

Just Posted

Count shows slight decrease in Red Deer’s homeless

In two years, the number of homeless in Red Deer has decreased… Continue reading

Remains of all eight Bruce McArthur victims now identified: Toronto police

Toronto police say they’ve now recovered and identified the remains of all… Continue reading

Manslaughter case in court

Manslaughter charge was laid more than a year after alleged victim died in Red Deer

Ottawa announces $26M for noise reduction research to help right whales

HALIFAX — Ottawa has announced $26.6 million in funding for research to… Continue reading

Get your guilty pleasures: Westerner Days food

Traditional sugary treats were served up by the plate, bowl and bucket… Continue reading

WATCH: Cirque ZUMA ZUMA puts on a show at Westerner Days

ZUMA ZUMA performs three times a day during Westerner Days

Divers hunt for 4 after Missouri duck boat sinks, killing 13

BRANSON, Mo. — Divers are searching Friday for four people still missing… Continue reading

WATCH: Red Deer’s noxious weeds are a goat’s dietary delight

Piper Creek Community Garden gets chemical-free weed control

‘Amazing Race Canada’ competitors face B.C. challenge

They drove Corvettes, mastered falconry basics, and ate blueberry pie in the Cowichan Valley

From hot to not? The Baloney Meter weighs in on Scheer’s economy claims

OTTAWA — “Justin Trudeau inherited a booming economy, but he’s squandering it.… Continue reading

Scathing suicide inquiry finds gaps, shortcomings at Royal Military College

OTTAWA — Members of a board of inquiry into three suicides at… Continue reading

Premiers strike deal to allow increased flow of beer, alcohol across borders

ST. ANDREWS, N.B. — Canada’s premiers are set to wrap up their… Continue reading

Trump ready to hit all Chinese imports with tariffs

President Donald Trump has indicated that he’s willing to hit every product… Continue reading

Canada’s annual inflation rises 2.5% thanks to boost from higher energy prices

OTTAWA — The country’s annual inflation rate rose 2.5 per cent in… Continue reading

Most Read

Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month