Man may walk through constitutional breach

A police officer breached the constitutional rights of a man who was allegedly caught with crack cocaine and a loaded handgun when she did not allow him to contact a lawyer soon enough, a local judge ruled Tuesday.

A police officer breached the constitutional rights of a man who was allegedly caught with crack cocaine and a loaded handgun when she did not allow him to contact a lawyer soon enough, a local judge ruled Tuesday.

Red Deer Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Monica Bast decided that the rights of Samir Mohamed, 22, were violated when RCMP Const. Sabrina Caterini detained the man without immediately advising him of his right to call a lawyer.

Mohamed was stopped by Caterini on Feb. 11, 2009, after the officer noticed him making an illegal U-turn in Sylvan Lake.

When Mohamed lowered his window, Caterini noticed a “very strong skunky odour” that she said she recognized from previous investigations as the smell of fresh marijuana.

Caterini also noticed that Mohamed was acting unusual by not making eye contact, answering her questions without attempting other conversation, and sweating profusely.

She asked him to step out of the vehicle.

Bast concluded it was “reasonable” for Mohamed to conclude he was being detained at this point. “He was detained when he was asked to step out of the car,” said Bast, who added the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in the Constitution requires that a person who is detained by police be advised of the right to contact a lawyer.

This did not happen until much later, after Mohamed had allegedly handed over some marijuana in his possession to Caterini and the officer had searched his jacket and a tote bag on the passenger seat of the car, allegedly finding about $35,000 worth of crack cocaine and a loaded handgun.

Defence lawyer Shawn Beaver argued the marijuana evidence that led to the other searches would never have been handed over by Mohamed if he had been able to seek legal counsel when he was asked to step out of the vehicle.

Beaver contended that this evidence should, therefore, not be allowed to be entered into the trial, which will be presided over by judge alone.

But Crown prosecutor Dave Inglis said Caterini was “cordial and decent” and did not threaten or coerce Mohamed into handing over the marijuana.

Inglis stressed that telling someone of their right to legal counsel does not mean the police investigation stops until the lawyer appears. “She can complete the investigation . . . inevitably (Caterini) would have discovered the drugs in the coat and the drugs and the gun in the (tote) bag in the car.”

Bast is expected to make a decision today about which evidence to allow.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

ALERT’s Internet Child Exploitation (ICE) Unit
Two central Albertans charged with child porn

ALERT’s Internet Child Exploitation unit arrests 24 suspects

Pharmacist Barbara Violo arranges all the empty vials of the Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccines that she has provided to customers at the Junction Chemist which is a independent pharmacy during the COVID-19 pandemic in Toronto, on Monday, April 19, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
A CN rail worker stands on an idle locomotive as protesters opposed to the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion block rail lines, in Burnaby, B.C., on Friday, November 27, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
CN makes rival bid to CP Rail’s offer to buy U.S. railway Kansas City Southern

Offer tops proposal made last month by Canadian Pacific Railway

The Rogers Logo is photographed on a Toronto office on Monday, September 30, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Tijana Martin
Rogers says wireless service fully restored after daylong nationwide outage

Wireless interruption had deep economic implications

President Joe Biden meets with members of congress to discuss his jobs plan in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, Monday, April 19, 2021. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)
Feds weighing how to respond after verdict in Chauvin trial

The verdict, and the aftermath, will be a test for Biden

A vial of the Medicago vaccine sits on a surface. CARe Clinic, located in Red Deer, has been selected to participate in the third phase of vaccine study. (Photo courtesy
Red Deer clinical research centre participating in plant-based COVID-19 vaccine trial

A Red Deer research centre has been selected to participate in the… Continue reading

The controversial Super League is materializing after Madrid and 11 other clubs announced its creation on Sunday. (File photo by BLACK PRESS)
Super League a ‘longtime dream’ for Madrid president Pérez

League created because coronavirus pandemic left clubs in a dire financial situation

San Jose Sharks centre Patrick Marleau (12) skates during the third period of an NHL hockey game against the Minnesota Wild, in San Jose, Calif., Monday, March 29, 2021. Marleau is skating in his 1,757th game. Only one other player in NHL history has hit that mark. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Tony Avelar
Patrick Marleau set to break Gordie Howe’s record for most NHL games played

Marleau was set to suit up for the 1,768th time Monday

FILE - In this Saturday April 17, 2021 file photo, Britain’s Queen Elizabeth II follows the coffin in a car as it makes it’s way past the Round Tower during the funeral of Britain’s Prince Philip inside Windsor Castle in Windsor, England. Now that the Royal Family has said farewell to Prince Philip, attention will turn to Queen Elizabeth II’s 95th birthday on Wednesday, April 21 and, in coming months, the celebrations marking her 70 years on the throne. This combination of events is reminding the United Kingdom that the reign of the queen, the only monarch most of her subjects have ever known, is finite. (Leon Neal/Pool via AP, file)
Queen enters ‘twilight’ of reign after farewell to Philip

Charles’ increased role began gradually

This combination photo shows Oscar nominees for best actress, from left, Viola Davis in “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom,” Andra Day in “The United States vs Billie Holiday,” Vanessa Kirby in “Pieces of a Woman,” Frances McDormand in “Nomadland and Carey Mulligan in Promising Young Woman.” (Netflix, from left, Hulu, Netflix, Searchlight Pictures, Focus Features via AP)
Oscar predictions: Can anything beat ‘Nomadland’?

Best actress race is perhaps the biggest wild card

Letter: Restrictions have nothing to do with religion

Many have framed the closure of GraceLife Church near Edmonton by Alberta… Continue reading

LtE bug
Letter: Thanking volunteers in Red Deer

National Volunteer Week is April 18 to 24. At the Canadian Cancer… Continue reading

Letter to the editor
Letter: Good on MLAs for speaking out

This is a letter in regard to MLAs not standing united behind… Continue reading

Treena Mielke
Family: Happiness can be found in many ways

I’ve heard it said that necessity is the mother of invention. I… Continue reading

Most Read