Lisa Kaye-Stanisky (left) and Gina Seaton flank their half-brother Floyd in his home on the north site of Michener Centre. Floyd is epilectic and has spent 56 of his 61 years living at Michener Centre. His sisters fear that forcing him out of his longtime home would hasten his death.

Lisa Kaye-Stanisky (left) and Gina Seaton flank their half-brother Floyd in his home on the north site of Michener Centre. Floyd is epilectic and has spent 56 of his 61 years living at Michener Centre. His sisters fear that forcing him out of his longtime home would hasten his death.

Michener: The Closing Doors — Part 10 — Courts struggle to deal with the developmentally disabled

When the group advocating for the continued existence of Michener Centre goes to court in November hoping to get an injunction against the government’s plans, it will hardly be the first time a judge is asked to consider if Michener is the right place to house disabled individuals.

When the group advocating for the continued existence of Michener Centre goes to court in November hoping to get an injunction against the government’s plans, it will hardly be the first time a judge is asked to consider if Michener is the right place to house disabled individuals. Over the years, residents have gone to court to try to get out of Michener, people have been forced into Michener, and judges have lamented the fact they could not put ex-Michener residents who had fallen afoul of the law back into the facility.

Of the thousands of people who have moved out of Michener Centre over the decades, most have transitioned well into life in group homes or in independent living situations. But, in the early 1990s particularly, when a series of ex-residents ended up in the courts, judges struggled with what to do with them.

In 1991 alone, the cases of four repeat offenders left local courts in a bind as to how best to deter future wrongdoing and protect the public from the assaults and sexual assaults the one-time Michener residents were carrying out. Without the option of sending those convicted back to Michener though, in each case the judges reluctantly imposed prison sentences, which left advocates fearing the handicapped would be easy victims within prison walls.

The Michener parents’ organization at the time argued that the cases showed that the institution had a purpose — to house those who could not function properly in the community. Mark Keohane, then an early-career Edmonton lawyer, suggested that wholesale changes were needed to address the “blatant inequities” in the justice system that saw those with mental handicaps treated like regular adults in the courts rather than with regard to their actual functional level.

He said both handicapped victims and offenders should have special provisions under the law similar to children because they may have the same mental capacities. His own sister Susan has lived most of her life at the centre and though she has been sexually assaulted in the past, no charges were laid because police could not prove that she did not consent.

While that change has not occurred, in 2012 the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that mentally handicapped individuals are able to give truthful and reliable testimony, even if they have limited mental capacities. The court challenge came about after the accused in a sexual assault case successfully argued that the testimony of the mentally handicapped complainant should be dismissed because she could not swear an oath or communicate effectively.

Notwithstanding societal progress in the treatment of the developmentally disabled, Keohane says that the process of deinstitutionalization leaves scores of mentally ill and handicapped individuals vulnerable to abuse and more likely to abuse others. Various studies have found that over 80 per cent of intellectually disabled individuals will experience some form of sexual abuse during their lifetimes.

“I don’t know what happens to these people. I think I see them when I’m walking to the courthouse, they’re pushing shopping carts full of cans and they’re sexually assaulted from time to time and terrible things happen to them,” says Keohane.

In 2006, then B.C. premier Gordon Campbell called mass deinstitutionalization a “failed experiment,” linking the closure of large facilities to an increase in the numbers of homeless people on the streets and in jails in his province. Campbell’s comments had more to do with the closing of mental hospitals than places like Michener Centre, though, and Alberta Association for Community Living CEO Bruce Uditsky says the two processes should not be compared.

“The mental health system has never had the community-based support systems we’ve created largely because the community living movement is family driven. Its roots lie in families wanting their sons and daughters to be able to grow up at home, able to stay in their communities, to be able to go to school and to have the supports necessary to do that,” he says.

But Dr. Robert Lampard, former Michener medical director, notes that approximately half of all centre residents are dually diagnosed with developmental disabilities and treatable mental illnesses. Dealing with such residents requires tolerant, knowledgeable staff who are able to quickly judge whether to treat related behaviours medically or in another fashion, he said.

mfish@bprda.wpengine.com

Coming Thursday: The cost of Michener Centre compared to community care.

Just Posted

Alberta has made a more detailed framework for those looking to acquire an exemption to the mandatory indoor mask bylaw. (AP Photo/Eric Gay, File)
Alberta changes requirements for mask exemptions

Masks wearing has been recommended for almost a year and provincially mandated… Continue reading

Alberta’a chief medical officer of health Dr. Deena Hinshaw said Thursday that there are more than 328,000 vaccine appointments booked over the next seven days. (Photo by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta surpasses 2 million doses administered of COVID-19 vaccine

Red Deer down to 835 active cases of COVID-19

RCMP file photo (Photo by Jeff Stokoe/Advocate staff)
RCMP investigating shooting near Maskwacis

Maskwacis and Wetaskiwin RCMP are seeking public assistance after a shooting has… Continue reading

Rode
Smith among impressive group of RDC soccer Queens recruits

There have been a number of cases where younger girls have developed… Continue reading

Red Deer Public Schools is projecting a $4-million budget deficit for 2021-22 school year. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)
Red Deer Public Schools prepares $124-million budget

$1 million COVID recovery plan to assist students

Bo’s Bar and Grill owner Brennen Wowk said the hospitality industry is looking for more clarity from the province around what conditions must be met to allow for restaurants reopening. (Advocate file photo)
Frustated restaurant owners want to know government’s reopening plan

Restaurant owners feel they are in lockdown limbo

Vancouver Canucks' Nils Hoglander, right, is checked by Calgary Flames goalie Jacob Markstrom during third-period NHL hockey action in Calgary, Thursday, May 13, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Lindholm, Tkachuk lead Calgary Flames in 4-1 win over Vancouver Canucks

Lindholm, Tkachuk lead Calgary Flames in 4-1 win over Vancouver Canucks

Chicago Bulls guard Zach LaVine, right, drives to the basket against Toronto Raptors center Khem Birch, left, and guard Jalen Harris during the first half of an NBA basketball game in Chicago, Thursday, May 13, 2021. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)
LaVine, Markkanen lead Bulls past Raptors, 114-102

LaVine, Markkanen lead Bulls past Raptors, 114-102

NFL schedules get off to strong starts with Week 1 twinbills

NFL schedules get off to strong starts with Week 1 twinbills

The Saddledome, home of the Calgary Flames, is shown in Calgary, Thursday, March 12, 2020. The final three games of Canada's Secret Cup women's hockey tournament will be played in Calgary's NHL arena.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Secret Cup women’s tournament final games to be held in Calgary’s Saddledome

Secret Cup women’s tournament final games to be held in Calgary’s Saddledome

FILE - In this Thursday, July 18, 2019 file photo, Ron Francis talks to reporters in Seattle after he was introduced as the first general manager for Seattle's yet-to-be-named NHL hockey expansion team. Four years since George McPhee was a “puppet master” of the NHL leading up to the Vegas expansion draft, general managers approached this trade deadline with Seattle’s upcoming addition to the league in mind. While Kraken GM Ron Francis prepares – and maybe made a handshake deal or two already like McPhee did – Seattle was on his colleagues’ minds.(AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Kraken still plan to hire coach before expansion draft

Kraken still plan to hire coach before expansion draft

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney attends a news conference in Calgary on Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2020. Simmering internal discontent in his United Conservative caucus has boiled over into an open challenge to his leadership. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Todd Korol
Two Alberta UCP members kicked out of caucus after challenging Kenney’s leadership

Two Alberta UCP members kicked out of caucus after challenging Kenney’s leadership

Toronto Blue Jays' Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (13) celebrates in the outfield at the end of a baseball game against the Atlanta Braves Thursday, May 13, 2021, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/Ben Margot)
Bichette, Blue Jays rally again to beat Braves 8-4

Bichette, Blue Jays rally again to beat Braves 8-4

FILE - Jordan Spieth waits his turn to putt during the third round of the Valero Texas Open golf tournament in San Antonio, in this Saturday, April 3, 2021, file photo. Spieth will try to complete the career Grand Slam next week at the PGA Championship. (AP Photo/Michael Thomas, File)
Momentum for McIlroy, few others going into PGA Championship

Momentum for McIlroy, few others going into PGA Championship

Most Read