Quebec students take to the courtroom

MONTREAL — First the streets — now the courtrooms.

MONTREAL — First the streets — now the courtrooms.

After demonstrating night after night to protest a controversial law aimed at limiting protests against tuition hikes, students and myriad other groups are carving out another battleground.

Lawyers for student federations and other groups filed two legal motions on Friday against Bill 78, the law adopted May 18 to crack down on the protests.

The first motion seeks to temporarily suspend sections of the law that involve public protest. It will be heard next week in Superior Court.

The second motion is to have Bill 78 declared invalid altogether, although it may take longer to reach a judge.

Bill 78 has been used sparingly by police across the province, but the groups mounting the legal challenge say it severely restricts the fundamental rights of citizens. They call the motions ambitious but necessary.

The government argues the law preserves the rights of students to attend school.

It lays out strict regulations governing demonstrations, ordering assemblies of more than 50 people to give eight hours’ notice for details such as the protest route, the duration and the time at which the demonstration is being held.

Individual organizers and student groups could face huge fines if they don’t comply. The penalties range between $1,000 and 5,000 per individual; $7,000 and $35,000 for a student leader; and between $25,000 and $125,000 for unions or student federations.

One student association said Friday that just one fine would be enough to empty its bank account.

The legislation also provides for fines for anyone who prevents someone from entering an educational institution.

The student groups, labour federations and a wide range of other organizations claim the law is unconstitutional and a violation of basic rights.

“We are doing this because we are genuinely worried that basic important rights such as freedom of association, freedom of expression and the right to hold peaceful demonstrations are being attacked,” student leader Leo Bureau-Blouin told a news conference outside the Montreal courthouse.

He said students are being prudent about their chances.

Besides the student and labour groups, others supporting the legal action include feminists, ecologists, artists and community groups.

“We’re happy we’re not alone in this,” said Martine Desjardins, a student leader who represents university students.

“A lot of citizens in Quebec — not just students — are fighting for their rights to be preserved.”

Another student leader described the motions as the biggest constitutional challenge in the history of Quebec. Those bringing the motion forward say they represent one out of four Quebecers.

“It’s a unanimous answer (from) the civil society of Quebec against this unjust law that is for us is clearly breaking the fundamental rights and freedoms of our country,” said Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois.

Replying on behalf of the government, Transport Minister Pierre Moreau appeared unimpressed with the large number of groups rallying around the cause.

“I’ve pleaded (as a lawyer) long enough to know that what is important is not the number of applicants, it is the quality of arguments,” Moreau said Friday.

“The government took the time to prepare the law quickly. We have jurists and constitutional experts who think the law will stand.”

While the government indicated it would comply with the opinion of the court, Moreau said it’s ironic that student leaders are going to court after chastising their own members who sought injunctions to return to class.

“They’re going to court to declare the law unconstitutional, but when the courts recognize constitutional rights or the right to study, they do not recognize the judgment,” Moreau said.

Veronique Hivon of the Opposition Parti Quebecois said she isn’t surprised by the legal motions.

“It was written in the sky that that law would be challenged,” she said.

“I won’t speculate about their chances of success, but within 24 hours, the Quebec Bar talked about the law being unacceptable and 45 law professors signed a letter to that effect. So certainly, the violations of law are very serious.”

The first of the two motions is expected to be heard next Wednesday and is aimed at obtaining a temporary suspension of the law.

The objective of the second procedure is to have the entire law struck down. If the case can make its way through Quebec courts quickly, it could wind up before the Supreme Court of Canada in short order, Blouin said.

“We hope that we will obtain something but, as you know, the judge will be the one to decide,” said lawyer Giuseppe Sciortino, one of nearly 500 lawyers who have volunteered their time to put the case together.

Bill 78 was introduced as a response to mounting student protests after the Charest government’s insistence it would not back down on a previous announcement it would hike tuition fees by $325 a year over five years, beginning this coming September.

That would have eventually boosted the figure to nearly $3,793 a year in 2017.

The government later offered to spread the total hikes over seven years to $1,778, compensated with cuts to other fees. That would work out to an increase of about $254 a year,

While the proposed hikes would still leave Quebec with some of the lowest rates in the country, the issue has flared into a clash of ideologies. The students have called for a tuition freeze but the government has flatly rejected any idea of that.

Negotiations are expected to resume next week.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Photo from Town of Sylvan Lake Facebook page
Sylvan Lake communities band together on development plan

Sylvan Lake Intermunicipal Development Plan expected to be approved next spring

Tribe restaurant owner Paul Harris, left, consults with manager Brandon Bouchard about how to proceed under pandemic rules that make it hard for eateries to be profitable. (Contributed photo).
New pandemic rules deemed workable for Red Deer retailers

Stricter COVID-19 reduction measures introduced in lead-up to Christmas

Dow Chemicals employees recently volunteered at Habitat for Humanity's Blackfalds project. The federal government announced Wednesday that it is also supporting the affordable housing project. Photo contributed
Habitat for Humanity gets funding for Blackfalds housing project

Habitat for Humanity’s Blackfalds housing project will get some support from the… Continue reading

City of Red Deer Mayor Tara Veer (Advocate file photo).
Veer urges indoor mask wearing immediately

We must protect hospital capacity and each other, says Tara Veer

A
Red Deer Games Foundation adjusts grant program due to COVID-19 pandemic

The Red Deer Games Foundation announced Wednesday that it will allow athletes… Continue reading

In this undated photo issued by the University of Oxford, a volunteer is administered the coronavirus vaccine developed by AstraZeneca and Oxford University, in Oxford, England. Pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca said Monday Nov. 23, 2020, that late-stage trials showed its coronavirus vaccine was up to 90% effective, giving public health officials hope they may soon have access to a vaccine that is cheaper and easier to distribute than some of its rivals. (University of Oxford/John Cairns via AP)
POLL: When a COVID-19 vaccine is available, will you get the shot?

When a COVID-19 vaccine is available, will you get the shot?… Continue reading

The tournament was cancelled because of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. (Image courtesy of WHL)
2020 WHL Cup cancelled

A tournament featuring the top under 16 male hockey prospects in Western… Continue reading

TORONTO, ON - DECEMBER, 7  - Susan Delacourt
Logo headshots of Toronto Star staff shot in Star studio.
December 7, 2015
Opinion: Don’t blame Trump for vaccine wait

Canadians will be getting COVID-19 vaccinations after Americans, Justin Trudeau has admitted,… Continue reading

QMJHL Roundup: Armada down Olympiques to extend win streak to seven games

QMJHL Roundup: Armada down Olympiques to extend win streak to seven games

Nashville SC ends Toronto FC’s season with stunning 1-0 extra time upset

Nashville SC ends Toronto FC’s season with stunning 1-0 extra time upset

Juve, Barça, Chelsea, Sevilla advance in Champions League

Juve, Barça, Chelsea, Sevilla advance in Champions League

Toronto Raptors guard Fred VanVleet (23) brings the ball up court against Atlanta Hawks guard Trae Young (11) during the first half of NBA basketball action in Toronto on January 28, 2020. The Raptors officially annoucned that VanVleet has agreed to a multi-year contract with the team. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Raptors guard Fred VanVleet says contract negotiations were “easy”

Raptors guard Fred VanVleet says contract negotiations were “easy”

Most Read