Quick end to debate on pension bill

The Conservative government’s move Tuesday to curtail debate on legislation creating a new pooled pension plan illustrated some of the potentially scalding political perils of retirement reform.

OTTAWA — The Conservative government’s move Tuesday to curtail debate on legislation creating a new pooled pension plan illustrated some of the potentially scalding political perils of retirement reform.

There is nothing very controversial about the Harper government’s December 2010 promise to add a relatively low-cost, private pension option that can be used by employers and workers to set up retirement savings plans.

While opposition parties have dismissed “Pooled Registered Pension Plans” as missing the mark or redundant, the critiques have been relatively mild.

The proposal offers an additional way for Canadians to save for retirement, which few can condemn.

“This is really just another group RRSP,” NDP critic Irene Mathyssen complained Tuesday in the House of Commons. “It has none of the benefits of the Canada Pension Plan.”

But as parliamentarians returned from a six-week break, debate on the legislation has provided opposition MPs a venue to tee off on a far more contentious notion — tinkering with Old Age Security.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper let the pension genie out of the bottle last week with a speech in Davos, Switzerland, where he made the case that OAS, in its present form, is unsustainable in the longer term.

His government has been playing defence ever since, stoutly insisting that current “seniors will not lose a penny” — but leaving future pension provisions in a cloud of ambiguity.

The lack of clarity has allowed the pension issue to dominate the first two question periods of the winter sitting of parliament, with the prospect of many more to come.

“Seniors are worried about their future, but they are also worried about the future of their children and their grandchildren,” interim NDP Leader Nicole Turmel lamented Tuesday.

“Our seniors have worked hard to give a better life for future generations.”

Harper was left to reiterate that no immediate benefit changes are coming, while enigmatically affirming that “younger generations expect us to ensure the system is viable for them.”

Into this morass, the government brought forward for debate Bill C-25, the innocuous pooled pension bill.

But the manoeuvre simply allowed the opposition to keep the kettle boiling and maintain the whole pension issue in the public eye.

Liberal Leader Bob Rae, ostensibly addressing pooled pensions, barely touched the legislation itself in his address to the Commons earlier this week.

“The Conservative Party was opposed to the original Canada Pension Plan,” he charged, digging back 85 years for fodder.

“The leader of the Conservative Party, in his then job as the president of the National Citizens Coalition, was opposed to the improvements in the Canada Pension Plan (in the 1990s) that led to its sustainability — for which he took credit at Davos in his speech last week.”

By Tuesday morning, the Conservatives had heard enough. The majority voted to limit debate on second reading of Bill C-25 to two more days.

“That they’re willing to delay and obstruct that and not allow it to go forward to a vote is really surprising to me,” said Peter Van Loan, the government House leader.

But after only a single day of parliamentary debate, there had been no evidence of obstruction, only opposition MPs doing what they’re paid to do.

The Harper government has limited debate on legislation 13 times since it won its majority last May according to the NDP.

While debate was curtailed on a number of previous Conservative bills because they were highly contentious or time sensitive, the pooled registered pension is not.

“Probably they are worried about the seniors’ reaction to this,” Turmel said when asked about why “time allocation” was invoked so quickly.

“Already, we have seen reaction from their own voters on this issue about pension.”

Harper having raised pension reforms himself out of the blue last week, the issue appears to be a topic his Conservative government no longer wants to discuss.

Just Posted

2019 Winter Games will transform Red Deer: Olympic organizer

Team leader behind 2010 Vancouver Winter Olympics provides inspirational pep talk

Red Deer RCMP make series of arrests as part of Project Pinpoint

Seven separate incidents lead police to repeat offenders

Red Deer city council gets the ball rolling on new fees for tax assessment summaries

Changes to provincial legislation has spurred a rise in requests

Red Deer County backs Canadian Finals Rodeo

Council approved $50,000 for the event’s inaugural event in Red Deer

Red Deer County receives third budget award

Award from the Government Finance Officers Association

WATCH: Red Deer students take part in annual run

Dawe/St. Pat’s Run reaches 40th anniversary

Smile Cookie fundraiser campaign for Reading College kicks off

Fundraising campaign runs Sept. 12-18 for program that helps children improve their reading

‘Nightmare that won’t end’: Storm evacuees can’t return yet

WILMINGTON, N.C. — Hundreds of people waited in long lines for water… Continue reading

New bridge collapses into river in rural Saskatchewan hours after opening

HYAS, Sask. — A rural politician in eastern Saskatchewan says he’s at… Continue reading

Halifax researchers tag great white shark in Atlantic Canada for first time

HALIFAX — For the first time in Atlantic Canadian waters, scientists have… Continue reading

Liberal riding association president blindsided by MP’s defection

OTTAWA — The president of an Ontario Liberal riding association says he… Continue reading

Pope gives bishops more decision-making options

VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis decreed on Tuesday that ordinary Catholics should… Continue reading

Hurricane rating system fails to account for deadly rain

TRENTON, N.C. — When meteorologists downgraded Hurricane Florence from a powerful Category… Continue reading

Glad company: Trailer for Disney’s ‘Mary Poppins Returns’

LOS ANGELES — A beloved nanny is preparing to take to the… Continue reading

Most Read