Resolute plane crash result of human, technical mistakes: transportation board

It took just 2 1/2 minutes for a combination of human and technical mistakes to turn a passenger and supply flight into a remote Arctic community from routine to calamitous.

It took just 2 1/2 minutes for a combination of human and technical mistakes to turn a passenger and supply flight into a remote Arctic community from routine to calamitous.

A Transportation Safety Board report into the crash of First Air Flight 6560 blames an undetected autopilot change, a faulty compass reading and disagreement between the pilots about whether to abort the landing.

“This accident was the product of a complex series of events, all of them lining up together,” lead investigator Brian MacDonald said Tuesday as the report was released. “But what ultimately tied all these things together was that as the flight progressed each pilot developed a different understanding of the situation and they were unable to reconcile that difference.”

The crash at the Resolute airport Aug. 20, 2011, killed eight passengers and four crew members. Three passengers miraculously survived.

In cool, technical language the board’s report provides a second-by-second breakdown of what probably happened in the cockpit as the pilots crashed the Boeing 737 into a hillside more than a kilometre from the runway.

Problems began because on-board compasses were incorrectly adjusted by 17 degrees. That error was compounded when the captain turned into the final approach and unwittingly changed the operational mode of the plane’s autopilot. Busy with the landing checklist, in weather obscured by cloud, mist and light rain, neither he nor the co-pilot picked up the change.

“This incongruency would have negatively affected the pilots’ situational awareness and increased their workload as they attempted to understand and resolve this ambiguity,” the report says.

Within seconds after that final turn, the co-pilot realized the plane was off course and repeatedly told the pilot, reminding him about the large hill to the right of the runway. The pilot replied that the autopilot was working fine.

Puzzled as to why the plane’s navigational instruments weren’t lining up with ground-based systems, the co-pilot asked the pilot if they’d done something wrong. Five seconds later, he suggested they pull up and go around for another approach.

The pilot, fully focused on landing the plane and on figuring out why his instruments were giving confusing readings, refused.

“It is likely that the captain did not fully comprehend information that indicated that his original plan was no longer viable,” says the report.

Less than 10 seconds after first suggesting they pull up, the co-pilot asked again, pointing out that the plane wasn’t configured for a landing so close to the landing strip. The report suggests the pilot is likely to have understood the remark as a request to prepared the plane for landing.

Cockpit communication had broken down.

“The captain’s mental model was likely that the approach and landing could be salvaged, and the (co-pilot’s) mental model was almost certainly that there was significant risk to the safety of flight and that a go-around was required. These divergent mental models compromised the pilots’ ability to communicate and work together.”

Four seconds after his second request to pull up, the co-pilot asked the pilot to bank to the left. Their navigational confusion was evident when the co-pilot confused the shoreline of a small lake with the seashore.

Just under a minute after that, the co-pilot called the pilot by his first name and said: “I don’t like this.”

Almost immediately after, global-positioning systems on the plane began to ring alarms. About 160 seconds after making the final turn, the pilot tried to pull up and go around.

“There was insufficient altitude and time to execute the manoeuvre and avoid collision with terrain.”

The plane smashed into the hill and broke into three main pieces. Debris was strewn around the tundra.

Resolute residents and soldiers from a military exercise that happened to be underway nearby rushed to the scene to try to pull survivors from the flaming wreckage.

Several lawsuits have been filed over the disaster. The suits cast partial blame on the Canadian Forces, which had taken control over the small airport on the day of the crash.

The transportation board said the military’s presence was not a contributing factor in the crash.

The military had established a temporary air traffic control tower to guide in all planes. The airport was normally an uncontrolled airspace and pilots navigated themselves onto the runway.

The suits claim the military did not have enough people on duty to handle the air traffic and those working the tower were not briefed or properly trained to navigate civilian planes.

None of the allegations has been proven in court. Statements of defence were not immediately available.

The chartered plane was on a regular run from Yellowknife to Resolute. There were scientists on the plane along with staff heading back to work at a local inn and the inn owner’s two young granddaughters. There was also a load of food.

Two geologists, Nicole Williamson and Robin Wyllie, and one of the children on board, seven-year old Gabrielle Pelky, made it out of the wreckage with broken bones. Gabrielle’s six-year-old sister, Cheyenne Eckalook, was among the dead.

Pilot Blair Rutherford, 48, from Leduc, Alta.; co-pilot David Hare, 35, from Yellowknife; and flight attendants Anne Marie Chassie, 22, and Ute Merritt, both from Yellowknife, also died.

Martin Bergmann, 55, the Winnipeg-based director of Canada’s Polar Continental Shelf Project was also killed, along with hotel workers Randolph Reid, 56, of Sault Ste. Marie, Ont.; Michael Rideout, 65, of Mount Pearl, N.L.; Chesley Tibbo, 49, of Harbour Mille, N.L; Raymond Pitre, 39, of Bathurst, N.B.; Steven Girouard, 38, and his fiancee Lise Lamoureux, 23, also of Bathurst, N.B.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

File photo
Gov’t of Alberta identifies estimated 300 new COVID-19 cases Sunday

Online COVID-19 dashboard unavailable as upgrades being completed

The Central Alberta Freestyle Ski Club is hoping to win $50,000 through the Mackenzie Investments Top Peak contest. (Contributed photo)
Central Alberta ski club trying to win $50K in online contest

A central Alberta ski club has entered a contest where it can… Continue reading

Ben King scores for the Red Deer Rebels during the third period of a Western Hockey League game against the Calgary Hitmen at the Westerner Park Centrium Saturday. (Photo by Rob Wallator/Red Deer Rebels)
Rebels complete comeback to pick up first win of season

Rebels 3 Hitmen 2 (OT) The Red Deer Rebels were able to… Continue reading

A health-care worker prepares a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine at a UHN COVID-19 vaccine clinic in Toronto on Thursday, January 7, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Red Deer dips below 300 active COVID-19 cases

The number of active COVID-19 cases in Red Deer continued to drop… Continue reading

Mount Pearl Senior High in Mount Pearl, N.L., remains closed on Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The provincial health authority says there were 185 cases at 22 schools, including 145 infections among staff and students of one high school in Mount Pearl that was an early epicentre of the outbreak. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Daly
In Newfoundland and Labrador, three ingredients made for explosive COVID-19 outbreak

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — With her classes, three part-time jobs and a… Continue reading

A passenger places a tag on luggage at the departure terminal at Toronto Pearson Airport, in Mississauga, Ont., Friday, May 24, 2019. The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic has prompted many recent immigrants to leave Canada and return to their countries of origin, where they have more social and familial connections. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
COVID-19 pandemic prompts recent newcomers to leave Canada for their home countries

OTTAWA — The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic… Continue reading

Rail cars wait for pickup in Winnipeg, Sunday, March 23, 2014. The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian oil and gas on trains destined for the United States — a country experts fear is ill-equipped for the potential consequences. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
As debate rages over cross-border pipelines, U.S. analysts brace for more oil by rail

WASHINGTON — The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian… Continue reading

Pictures and notes in from friends and classmates make up a memorial in support and memory of Aubrey Berry, 4, and her sister Chloe, 6, during a vigil held at Willows Beach in Oak Bay, B.C., on December 30, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Mother of slain daughters supports recent changes to Canada’s Divorce Act

VICTORIA — Legal experts and a mother whose ex-partner was convicted of… Continue reading

Radio and television personality Dick Smyth is shown in an undated handout photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO
Dick Smyth, Canadian maestro of news radio commentary, dies at 86

TORONTO — Radio and television personality Dick Smyth, whose booming commentary filled… Continue reading

Walter Gretzky father of hockey hall-of-famer Wayne Gretzky waves to fans as the Buffalo Sabres play against the Toronto Maple Leafs during third period NHL hockey action in Toronto on Tuesday, January 17, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Funeral for Walter Gretzky to be held Saturday in home town of Brantford, Ont.

The funeral for hockey legend Wayne Gretzky’s father Walter will take place… Continue reading

A sign for the Canadian Security Intelligence Service building is shown in Ottawa on May 14, 2013. A newly released audit report shows that difficulties with the judicial warrant process at Canada's spy agency — an issue that made headlines last summer — stretch back at least nine years. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Spy warrant shortcomings stretch back almost a decade, newly released audit shows

OTTAWA — A newly released audit report shows that difficulties with the… Continue reading

In this file photo, a lotto Max ticket is shown in Toronto on Monday Feb. 26, 2018. (By THE CANADIAN PRESS)
No winning ticket for Friday night’s Lotto Max jackpot

TORONTO — No winning ticket was sold for the estimated $29 million… Continue reading

Most Read