RCMP Const. Faz Majid removes an open bottle of beer from a motorist's car during a roadside check in Surrey

RCMP Const. Faz Majid removes an open bottle of beer from a motorist's car during a roadside check in Surrey

Study on impaired driving raises doubts about tough sentences

An internal report by the federal Justice Department raises doubts about the effectiveness of harsher sentences, the linchpin of the Tory government’s tough-on-crime policies.

OTTAWA — An internal report by the federal Justice Department raises doubts about the effectiveness of harsher sentences, the linchpin of the Tory government’s tough-on-crime policies.

The study examined almost 3,300 people convicted of an impaired-driving offence, and found 57 per cent of them offended again at least once, within five years on average.

And the severity of the first sentence had no impact on the behaviour of repeat offenders.

“There was no evidence to suggest that the imposition of a fine or imprisonment had any effect on the likelihood of whether an offender would re-offend or not,” the author concludes.

“This indicates that the severity of the sentence received did not deter offenders in this sample.”

“Reconviction rates for all individuals were similar regardless of the sentence received for the initial impaired driving conviction.”

The research was delivered in July this year, more than three years after the Conservative government passed a tough law that imposed harsher fines and jail sentences, including mandatory minimums, for impaired-driving convictions.

The Canadian Press obtained a copy of the study, “Recidivism Among Impaired Drivers” by Andre Solecki, under the Access to Information Act. The research covers the period from 1977 to 2006.

The study is among dozens of internal reports on the justice system prepared each year by department researchers but never published or made public.

A spokeswoman for the department provided no details about why the research was ordered. But the review follows the passage in 2008 of an omnibus bill, the Tackling Violent Crime Act, which revamped penalties for drunk driving, among other tough-on-crime measures.

The minimum fine for a first impaired-driving offence was raised to $1,000 from $600, for example, and the minimum penalty for a second offence increased to 30 days in jail from 14. The minimum for subsequent offences was hiked to 120 days from 90 days. And for summary convictions, with no jury trial, the maximum jail time shot to 18 months from six.

Conservative crime policies have come under fire from critics who claim the government ignores evidence-based research to seek political gain among Canadians who lack faith in the justice system.

So a Justice Department-ordered study that draws on a statistical analysis of crime and punishment appears at odds with the Conservative’s crime-fighting philosophy, especially considering its apparently contrary findings about harsh sentencing.

But a spokeswoman for Justice Minister Rob Nicholson noted the study looked at only one criminal offence, impaired driving, and cannot necessarily be extrapolated to all crimes. She also cited a 2003 Statistics Canada report that partly credits tougher sentences with a decades-long decline in the number of impaired-driving offences in Canada.

“At any rate, Canadians lose confidence in the justice system when offenders receive sentences which do not reflect the severity of the crime,” Julie Di Mambro said in an email.

“There are a variety of reasons why our government believes in stronger sentences for certain crimes — deterrence is not the sole reason.

“Further, we are taking a balanced approach — sentencing is just one component. We’ve given police and prosecutors new tools to investigate and prosecute impaired driving.”

A spokesman for Mothers Against Drunk Driving, or MADD Canada, said the study’s findings about the large number of reoffending drivers is at odds with other research, which suggests only about 30 per cent are convicted again.

Andrew Murie also noted that some data in the Justice Department report stretch back more than three decades, and that laws around impaired driving have changed dramatically in the meantime.

In any case, MADD has never pressed for tougher sentences, he said in an interview.

“Forget about the penalties — do the things that stop it at the front end, like random breath-testing, that create the appearance that if you drive while drinking, you’re going to be caught. And if you look worldwide, that’s what has worked,” he said.

“We’ve always said we don’t think that extra time in jail is going to work. Give them rehab, give them help for their alcohol problem — that’s going to have much more success.”

Some skeptics of American tough-on-crime policies have raised similar doubts about the efficacy of severe prison sentences, calling instead for more policing to improve the odds criminals will be caught.

“If people mostly get away with (crime) but occasionally get creamed, they’re going to keep doing it,” Mark Kleiman, a professor of public policy at UCLA, has said.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Red Deer College (Contributed photo)
RDC tuitions to go up 7%

Tuition increase the maximum allowed under provincial rules

This unicorn was stolen from the small community of Delia, northeast of Drumheller on Friday and was recovered, with its bronze horn broken off, on Saturday. RCMP are looking for information on the suspects.
(Photo from RCMP)
Unicorn statue stolen from Delia recovered

Statue found with horn broken off in field about 15 km from Delia

(Advocate file photo)
Lacombe man whose manslaughter sentence was rejected by judge has new lawyer

Judge rejected proposed seven-year sentence for manslaughter in connection with 2019 homicide

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau holds a news conference at Rideau cottage in Ottawa, on Friday, March 13, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand
Liberals to release federal budget with eye on managing crisis, post-pandemic growth

OTTAWA — The federal government will this afternoon unveil its spending plans… Continue reading

Patches are seen on the arm and shoulder of a corrections officer in the segregation unit at the Fraser Valley Institution for Women during a media tour, in Abbotsford, B.C., on Thursday, Oct. 26, 2017. Correctional Service Canada says three inmates at Fraser Valley Institution recently tested positive for COVID-19. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Drumheller Institution inmate dies in custody

Inmate’s April 15 death under investigation

A vial of the Medicago vaccine sits on a surface. CARe Clinic, located in Red Deer, has been selected to participate in the third phase of vaccine study. (Photo courtesy www.medicago.com)
Red Deer clinical research centre participating in plant-based COVID-19 vaccine trial

A Red Deer research centre has been selected to participate in the… Continue reading

Education Minister Adriana LaGrange was in Red Deer on Friday to provide an update on the province's COVID-19 response in schools.
Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
LaGrange: Feedback needed to refine curriculum

As the Minister of Education my role has been guided by a… Continue reading

In this Feb. 24, 2020, photo, the Olympics rings are reflected on the window of a hotel restaurant as a server with a mask sets up a table, in the Odaiba section of Tokyo. The vaccine rollout in Japan has been very slow with less than 1% vaccinated. This of course is spilling over to concerns about the postponed Tokyo Olympics that open in just over three months.(AP Photo/Jae C. Hong, File)
Will Japanese Olympians be vaccinated ahead of the public?

TOKYO — The vaccine rollout in Japan has been very slow with… Continue reading

PSG's Kylian Mbappe, right, greets Bayern's Lucas Hernandez at the end of the Champions League, second leg, quarterfinal soccer match between Paris Saint Germain and Bayern Munich at the Parc des Princes stadium, in Paris, France, Tuesday, April 13, 2021. (AP Photo/Francois Mori)
PSG, Bayern the big names missing from Super League plan

DÜSSELDORF, Germany — The plan for the new Super League soccer competition… Continue reading

In this image released by Paramount Pictures, Marion Cotillard, left, and Brad Pitt appear in a scene from "Allied." (Daniel Smith/Paramount Pictures via AP)
Leo Carax’s ‘Annette’ to open Cannes Film Festival

Leo Carax’s “Annette,” starring Marion Cotillard and Adam Driver, will open the… Continue reading

From left, Producer Doug Mitchell, actor Chris Hemsworth and director George Miller attend at a press conference to announce the new "Mad Max" film at Fox Studios Australia in Sydney, Monday, April 19, 2021. (Mick Tsikas/AAP Image via AP)
‘Mad Max’ prequel shot in Outback to be released in 2023

SYDNEY, Australia — A prequel to the “Mad Max” movie franchise starring… Continue reading

In this Feb. 1, 2021 file photo, emissions from a coal-fired power plant are silhouetted against the setting sun in Independence, Mo. President Joe Biden faces a vexing task as he convenes a virtual climate summit on Thursday. He is expected to present a nonbinding but symbolic goal to reduce greenhouse gas emissions that will have a tangible impact not only on climate change efforts in the U.S. but throughout the world. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
Biden pressed on emissions goal as climate summit nears

WASHINGTON — When President Joe Biden convenes a virtual climate summit on… Continue reading

Women wearing masks wait near an advertisement ahead of the Auto Shanghai 2021 show in Shanghai on Sunday, April 18, 2021. Automakers from around the world are showcasing their latest products this week in the world's biggest market for auto vehicles. (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan)
VW, Ford unveil SUVs at China auto show under virus controls

SHANGHAI — Volkswagen, Ford and Chinese brands unveiled new SUVs for China… Continue reading

Investigators from the Vancouver Police Department were in Chilliwack Saturday, collecting evidence connected to a double homicide. (file photo)
Police investigate shooting death of man outside downtown Vancouver restaurant

Vancouver police say one man was killed in what they believe was… Continue reading

Most Read