Surgeons need complete training; issue is lack of beds, operating room time

In a recent letter to the editor, Don Munro asserts that some health-care problems could easily be cured by training surgeons in the same way as trades people are.

In a recent letter to the editor, Don Munro asserts that some health-care problems could easily be cured by training surgeons in the same way as trades people are.

Whereas obviously there are many good ideas that could be implemented to improve surgical training, I don’t see how converting surgery to a trade would be beneficial. Only 20 per cent of a surgeon’s work week is actually doing surgery, so how do you train someone for the non-surgical clinical work that is involved?

Doctors all over the world have medical training first to not only learn the basics of medicine, but also for them to determine what interests and aptitudes they may have, whether it be family medicine, cardiology, neurology or even surgery.

The real issue isn’t an insufficient number of surgeons today in Canada. Actually, there are now a significant number of orthopedic surgeons in Canada who can’t find a job.

There is a huge demand for this specialty, but there are not enough clinical resources of beds, operating room time and equipment to support them. Unfortunately, one of the ways the health-care system can control health-care expenditures is to not supply the infrastructure required to support the needed number of surgeons.

So no, making surgery a trade and cranking out undertrained surgeons would not solve anything. It would only add to the numbers of unemployed and underemployed surgeons already in this country.

I think there are many good and innovative ideas that could improve access to surgical care in Canada and at the same time respect the Canada Health Act. Lowering surgical standards of training isn’t one of them.

Lance Bredo

Red Deer Count

Just Posted

One of the last buildings needed for Red Deer’s 2019 Winter Games is being completed

RDC residence is on schedule, despite ‘tight’ time-frame, says RDC official

New youth detox facility under construction in Red Deer

Expanded Protection of Children Abusing Drugs program

Woman who posed as animal control officer sentenced in Red Deer court

B.C. woman sentenced to 90 days in prison after targeting and harassing Innisfail dog owner

Two one-of-a-kind Christmas art markets held in Red Deer this weekend

Members of pottery, art clubs and other area artists show their works

Lowry has strong words for Raptors’ lack of communication after loss

TORONTO — Raptors coach Nick Nurse might not have had a good… Continue reading

S. Korea’s ‘Garlic Girls’ accuse coaches of derailing team

SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of — The Garlic Girls, South Korea’s hugely popular… Continue reading

Trump administration defends its case against CNN’s Acosta

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s administration is trying to fend off a… Continue reading

Long hidden, Marie Antoinette’s jewels go up for auction

GENEVA — Diamond and pearl earrings, pearl necklaces, a giant pearl pendant… Continue reading

A No-Go: Athletes and officials weigh in after Calgary votes ‘no’ to 2026 bid

TORONTO — Rotating Olympic hosts? A single go-to destination every four years?… Continue reading

Predators may have NHL’s best goalie combo on, off ice

NASHVILLE — Pekka Rinne is off to an even better start than… Continue reading

Canadian Premier League buys Ontario’s League 1, looks to develop talent there

TORONTO — The Canadian Premier League has bought Ontario’s League 1 and… Continue reading

Most Read