This controversial horizontal drilling method into a shale bed utilizes lots of nasty chemicals.

The good, the bad of natural gas

Part of the difference is that Obama’s source (the Potential Gas Committee) had included “probable”, “possible” and “speculative” resources in their report. But as Nelder notes, “By the same logic, you can claim to be a multibillionaire, including all your probable, possible, and speculative resources.”

“We have a supply of natural gas that can last America nearly 100 years.” — Barack Obama

“We might have a 100-year supply of gas, or we might have an 11-year supply.” — Chris Nelder, energy analyst.

Part of the difference is that Obama’s source (the Potential Gas Committee) had included “probable”, “possible” and “speculative” resources in their report. But as Nelder notes, “By the same logic, you can claim to be a multibillionaire, including all your probable, possible, and speculative resources.”

Obama’s fantasy world is mostly based on the recent boom in shale gas production in various areas of the U.S. This controversial method, which utilizes horizontal drilling and lots of nasty chemicals, has helped to stave off the decline of conventional gas production in America.

So much so, that total natural gas production is now up 16 per cent from what it was in 2005.

However, some of the main formations (such as the Barnett Shale in Texas and the Haynesville Shale in Louisiana) have already started to decline after just a few short years.

The current rock-bottom price of natural gas would seem to support the contention that North America is sitting on a gold mine.

However, there are at least two mitigating factors.

One is that we have just come through a very mild winter (the third warmest for Canada and the fourth warmest for the U.S.), so not nearly as much natural gas was used for heating.

The second factor relates to drilling leases south of the border.

Companies down there are not showing any profit when they produce natural gas priced at the current US$2 per thousand cubic feet.

In fact, many producers need $4 or $6 or $8 gas prices to eke out a decent profit. But in order to retain their leases, they have to maintain active production.

Thus, there is the further downward pressure on prices.

Thankfully, our provincial governments north of the border don’t stipulate these kind of archaic rules.

Companies operating here can at least refer to the laws of supply and demand when they decide whether or not to put natural gas on the market.

There is another important difference when it comes to shale gas production in Canada versus the U.S.

The fall in production over a well’s first year is much flatter north of the border. Whereas the first year decline rates in the U.S. can be as high as 80 per cent or 90 per cent, it is closer to 50 per cent in the Montney and Horn River formations in B.C. That makes for much better economics.

But if our shale gas resources have inherently better economics, we can’t be so sure about the environmental effects.

There are the potential hazards associated with the toxic fracking fluids (which I’ve talked about in other columns).

And it is now starting to come to light that shale gas may not be much cleaner than dirty old coal.

The burning of shale gas is much cleaner than the burning of coal.

However, the danger occurs when so-called “fugitive emissions” of unburnt gas escape into the atmosphere. The fracking fluid absorbs methane (the main constituent of natural gas, and also a greenhouse gas that is 25 times more effective than CO2), which is then potentially released when the fluid is brought back to the surface.

The technology exists to recover the fugitive methane, but it remains to be seen whether it is economically feasible . . . especially with natural gas prices at $2.

T. Boone Pickens, the Texas billionaire has promoted the idea of switching over America’s fleet of heavy trucks and commercial vehicles to natural gas.

However, given all of the problems mentioned above, it seems that his vision has no more validity than President Obama’s science fiction scenario.

Evan Bedford is a local environmentalist. Direct comments, questions and suggestions to Visit the Energy and Ecology website at

Just Posted

Alberta government to partially backstop new $2 billion dollar bitumen upgrader

CALGARY — The Alberta government is providing a $440 million loan guarantee… Continue reading

Local artists are in the running for Alberta Country Music Awards, held Sunday in Red Deer

Tickets are available to the ceremony at the Sheraton hotel

RCMP seeking suspect in school bus collision and car jacking

Two children suffered minor injuries in collision on Tuesday near Springbrook around 8 a.m.

Smaller, more affordable, lots wanted in Red Deer’s Evergreen neighbourhood

Council approves first reading of requested lot-size changes

Political shifts, sales slump cast shadow over gun industry

When gunmakers and dealers gather this week in Las Vegas for the… Continue reading

New Canada Food Guide nixes portion sizes, promotes plant-based proteins

Guide no longer lists milk and dairy products as a distinct food group

B.C. animators land Oscar nominations

‘Animal Behaviour’ by Vancouver’s David Fine and Alison Snowden among several Canadians on the short list

Canadian talent abound on newly revamped Vancouver Whitecaps squad

VANCOUVER — The Vancouver Whitecaps may need to stock up on maple… Continue reading

China demands US drop Huawei extradition request with Canada

China detained two Canadians on Dec. 10 in an apparent attempt to pressure Canada to release Meng

Rugby Canada Hall of Fame a family affair for hard-nosed forward Hans de Goede

Hans de Goede, a hard-nosed lock forward who captained Canada at the… Continue reading

5 burning questions ahead of the Oscar nominations

NEW YORK — The Oscars still don’t have a host, but on… Continue reading

‘Bao,’ ‘Animal Behaviour,’ ‘Weekends’ among Canadian Oscar nominees

LOS ANGELES — Several Canadians have landed Oscar nominations. The category for… Continue reading

Hollywood announces 2019 Oscar nominations

Netflix has scored its first best picture nomination, something the streaming giant has dearly sought

Opinion: Faith in immigration must be preserved

Canada has a deserved reputation for extending its arms to newcomers, but… Continue reading

Most Read