Tory entitlement can be stopped

Premier Jim Prentice’s seemingly bland statement of helplessness, “I don’t know if much can be done at this point. This arrangement was put in place by previous governments” is either a lie, or shows an appalling ignorance of the law.

Premier Jim Prentice’s seemingly bland statement of helplessness, “I don’t know if much can be done at this point. This arrangement was put in place by previous governments” is either a lie, or shows an appalling ignorance of the law.

Ten years ago, the Supreme Court of Canada authoritatively resolved the issue of whether there are constitutional limits on the ability of legislature (federal or provincial) to enact retroactive legislation.

The court, in British Columbia versus Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd (2005 SCC 49), held that (except in the area of criminal law) retroactive legislation can overturn settled expectations, even though sometimes perceived as unjust by those affected.

It ruled, clearly and unequivocally, that there is no constitutional impediment to retroactive legislation.

Therefore, there is nothing he can name preventing Prentice from eliminating the obscene windfalls, starting with the $873,00 no doubt eagerly anticipated by Yvonne Fritz, the $627,000 earmarked for Heather Forsyth, of course the half-million headed our own Mary Anne Jablonski’s way, and so on down the line.

Prentice would have us believe these MLAs have “a legal entitlement” — but omits the truth that they will cease to have it the moment he chooses to give the word; to say “enough is enough.” He has at his fingertips the power to retroactively legislate away all these millions in undeserved giveaways.

If he doesn’t, it will be all we ever need to know about the real Jim Prentice, and his real views of the PC “culture of entitlement” he so loudly bewails.

Roderick G. MacGregor

Ponoka

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

107 new cases of COVID-19 in Alberta, 5 additional deaths

More than 1,000 cases in Alberta total

Municipal projects face COVID-triggered delays

Pandemic safety measures expected to impact construction schedules

Red Deer trucker ‘nervous’ on front lines of COVID-19 fight

Patrick O’Connor is just looking for some help for the common man.… Continue reading

Gardening for food during COVID-19

“Gardening is easy, and there’s always Google”

Alberta Health Services provides COVID-19 prevention tips

Alberta Health Services has a number of recommendations for people amid the… Continue reading

Alberta government website has latest COVID-19 statistics

Red Deer Advocate readers can stay up to date on the COVID-19… Continue reading

Former Obama security adviser calls on Canada to show global COVID-19 leadership

Former Obama security adviser calls on Canada to show global COVID-19 leadership

Campaigning in a time of crisis: Tory leadership candidates carry on

Campaigning in a time of crisis: Tory leadership candidates carry on

‘Thirsty, hungry, injured:’ Two women sentenced for abuse of girls in basement

‘Thirsty, hungry, injured:’ Two women sentenced for abuse of girls in basement

Alberta environmentalists oppose possible crane, swan hunting season

Alberta environmentalists oppose possible crane, swan hunting season

‘Always new expenses:’ Lawsuits filed as anniversary of Broncos bus crash nears

‘Always new expenses:’ Lawsuits filed as anniversary of Broncos bus crash nears

Pandemic forcing NBA players to work out with what’s on hand

Pandemic forcing NBA players to work out with what’s on hand

Most Read