Sen. Patrick Brazeau

Sen. Patrick Brazeau

Tory move to suspend senators sparks fierce debate

A Conservative proposal to suspend three senators without pay and benefits is sparking a passionate debate inside the upper chamber over the powers and independence of Parliament and just how to far go in exercising them.

OTTAWA — A Conservative proposal to suspend three senators without pay and benefits is sparking a passionate debate inside the upper chamber over the powers and independence of Parliament and just how to far go in exercising them.

On a strictly political level, the idea of suspending former Tories Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau for their inappropriate expense claims might seem logical.

Canadians are upset with the Senate spending scandal, and MPs in particular are looking to appease voters.

But the Senate is a unique, sometimes unpredictable place — chocked with lawyers and the independent-minded who aren’t always guided by the vagaries of electoral politics. That sense of sovereignty is part of the upper chamber’s raison d’etre.

The debate is expected be fierce this week in the chamber when the motions are formally introduced, and could theoretically include interventions by Brazeau, Wallin and Duffy themselves. Wallin’s lawyer has already said he is looking at all options available to fight the move.

Independent Senator Anne Cools said she is deeply concerned that the Senate, with all of its constitutional powers, is getting into the area of unwarranted persecution.

“It’s a very serious matter because the Senate is being asked to go into judicial mode to make a judgment,” said Cools, who once sat as a Conservative and as a Liberal senator.

“It’s an extremely disturbing thing, and it’s a large and momentous action that is being asked for and I think that the public should understand that.”

At least three Liberal senators and one Conservative have publicly expressed opposition to the suspensions, going up against their own party leadership.

Central to the debate is the privilege of Parliament to make its own rules, a tenet of our Westminster-style system.

In 2009 and 2010, the British House of Lords suspended five peers — two for offering to change laws for money, and three over inappropriate expenses. But it was the first such suspensions in more than 300 years.

In Canada, only one other senator as been suspended without pay — absentee Liberal member Andrew Thompson in 1998. In that case, Thompson hadn’t actually broken a specific Senate rule because he hadn’t yet missed two consecutive sittings. Still, his colleagues found him contempt in the midst of intense public scrutiny of the upper chamber. He resigned shortly afterward, collecting his pension.

Political scientist and parliamentary expert Ned Franks said he suspects a legal challenge of a suspension would fail, based on the powers of the Senate.

But he said he can’t be sure, because such issues haven’t been tested in court in recent years.

“By and large these provisions are used very rarely, and any government is cautious in using them because they set a precedent and you don’t want it to be easy for a majority in either House to remove a member they don’t like, just because they don’t like them,” said Franks, a professor emeritus at Queen’s University.

Liberal Senator George Baker told reporters last week he was concerned by creating such a precedent with the case before them.

“The Senate is above all rules in that they can set their own parameters for rules…what I’m saying is it’s unfair to do that, it’s very unfair and it’s only right that some senators would express the other opinion however unpopular it is to try and persuade the majority to go the other way,” Baker said.

The former law clerk of the House of Commons, Rob Walsh, took to Twitter to outline why he feels the Senate could suspend the trio, but not without pay. He said the pay is guaranteed by statute, the Parliament of Canada Act, “to ensure protection from political intimidation/control.”

“Cons. motion politically driven to win public favour for Cons Govt when Senate may be partly responsible for wrongdoing,” he tweeted.

“If motion is passed & implemented, no court action taken or any effective dissent voiced, it could become a precedent.”

Wallin’s lawyer Terrence O’Sullivan told The Canadian Press that a suspension would break the Senate’s own rules.

He notes that in the case of senator charged with a criminal offence, which Wallin has not been, the Senate specifically emphasizes the presumption of innocence — as does the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

“You cannot possibly interpret the section to mean that the presumption of innocence applies only when you’re charged…,” O’Sullivan said.

He added: “It’s a fundamental affront to Canadian democracy, it is backroom politics at its most transparent worst and its designed to create the impression of a clean slate for the Tory convention in Calgary next week.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Ben King scores for the Red Deer Rebels during the third period of a Western Hockey League game against the Calgary Hitmen at the Westerner Park Centrium Saturday. (Photo by Rob Wallator/Red Deer Rebels)
Rebels complete comeback to pick up first win of season

Rebels 3 Hitmen 2 (OT) The Red Deer Rebels were able to… Continue reading

A health-care worker prepares a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine at a UHN COVID-19 vaccine clinic in Toronto on Thursday, January 7, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Red Deer dips below 300 active COVID-19 cases

The number of active COVID-19 cases in Red Deer continued to drop… Continue reading

Lyn Radford, 2019 Canada Winter Games board chair, was named 2020 Sport Event Volunteer of the Year at the Prestige Awards. (File photo by Advocate staff)
WATCH: Lyn Radford wins award for volunteer efforts

The board chair of the 2019 Canada Winter Games in Red Deer… Continue reading

Mount Pearl Senior High in Mount Pearl, N.L., remains closed on Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The provincial health authority says there were 185 cases at 22 schools, including 145 infections among staff and students of one high school in Mount Pearl that was an early epicentre of the outbreak. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Daly
In Newfoundland and Labrador, three ingredients made for explosive COVID-19 outbreak

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — With her classes, three part-time jobs and a… Continue reading

A passenger places a tag on luggage at the departure terminal at Toronto Pearson Airport, in Mississauga, Ont., Friday, May 24, 2019. The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic has prompted many recent immigrants to leave Canada and return to their countries of origin, where they have more social and familial connections. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
COVID-19 pandemic prompts recent newcomers to leave Canada for their home countries

OTTAWA — The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic… Continue reading

Rail cars wait for pickup in Winnipeg, Sunday, March 23, 2014. The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian oil and gas on trains destined for the United States — a country experts fear is ill-equipped for the potential consequences. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
As debate rages over cross-border pipelines, U.S. analysts brace for more oil by rail

WASHINGTON — The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian… Continue reading

Pictures and notes in from friends and classmates make up a memorial in support and memory of Aubrey Berry, 4, and her sister Chloe, 6, during a vigil held at Willows Beach in Oak Bay, B.C., on December 30, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Mother of slain daughters supports recent changes to Canada’s Divorce Act

VICTORIA — Legal experts and a mother whose ex-partner was convicted of… Continue reading

Radio and television personality Dick Smyth is shown in an undated handout photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO
Dick Smyth, Canadian maestro of news radio commentary, dies at 86

TORONTO — Radio and television personality Dick Smyth, whose booming commentary filled… Continue reading

Walter Gretzky father of hockey hall-of-famer Wayne Gretzky waves to fans as the Buffalo Sabres play against the Toronto Maple Leafs during third period NHL hockey action in Toronto on Tuesday, January 17, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Funeral for Walter Gretzky to be held Saturday in home town of Brantford, Ont.

The funeral for hockey legend Wayne Gretzky’s father Walter will take place… Continue reading

A sign for the Canadian Security Intelligence Service building is shown in Ottawa on May 14, 2013. A newly released audit report shows that difficulties with the judicial warrant process at Canada's spy agency — an issue that made headlines last summer — stretch back at least nine years. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Spy warrant shortcomings stretch back almost a decade, newly released audit shows

OTTAWA — A newly released audit report shows that difficulties with the… Continue reading

In this file photo, a lotto Max ticket is shown in Toronto on Monday Feb. 26, 2018. (By THE CANADIAN PRESS)
No winning ticket for Friday night’s Lotto Max jackpot

TORONTO — No winning ticket was sold for the estimated $29 million… Continue reading

Most Read