Vaccination exemptions raise risk

Most kids enter elementary school with the shots they need to protect them from childhood disease.

Most kids enter elementary school with the shots they need to protect them from childhood disease.

But two reports issued in August show why public health officials worry that school systems may be allowing too many exceptions to vaccine requirements.

And those exemptions — for medical, religious or philosophical reasons — may put some kids’ collective immunity at risk.

Roughly vive percent of students entering kindergarten were exempt from at least one required vaccine last year, but individual states excused up to seven percent of the youngsters from shots, the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported last month.

All American states allow exemptions for medical reasons such as allergies or immune system problems.

All but two — Mississippi and West Virginia — allow them on religious or philosophical grounds, such as refusing intrusive medical care.

There have been some efforts to tighten exemption requirements.

Washington state last year imposed a new rule that parents have to meet with a health-care provider before being granted a philosophical exemption.

The proportion of kindergarteners with exemptions dropped from 6 percent to 4.5 percent from the year before

A similar change has been proposed in California in a bill introduced by an assemblyman who is a pediatrician.

According to the CDC report, nine states had exemption rates of 4 percent or higher, led by Alaska at 7 percent, while 10 states had exemption rates of under 1 percent, led by Mississippi at 0.01 percent.

But nationwide, the CDC says, about 95 percent of kids starting elementary school last year had received at least a couple of doses of vaccines against most childhood diseases like measles, mumps, diphtheria and pertussis.

Of more than 4.1 million incoming kindergarteners nationwide, more than 89,000 were exempted from vaccinations.

Relatively few exemptions — 11,000 to 13,000 a year — were for medical concerns. CDC officials note that exemptions tend to cluster in certain communities, leaving those children more vulnerable to outbreaks.

A new, separate analysis of medical exemptions — done by scientists at Emory University in Atlanta and published online Aug. 30 by

The Journal of Infectious Diseases — also shows major differences in standards for excusing kindergarteners from state to state. The analysis covers seven years, from 2004 through 2011.

States that had the easiest standards for granting medical exemptions approved nearly half-again as many exemptions as states with the toughest requirements.

Researchers rated the exemptions based on six administrative requirements: a written doctor’s statement of need; a separate medical exemption form; approval from the health department; certification that the exempting physician can practice in the state; annual approval and notarization of exemption forms.

Each requirement was given a one-point score, and states that had zero or one of the requirements were ranked “easy” — 30 fit that category.

Seventeen states were rated 2, or “medium.” Three states were rated 3 or above, and categorized as “difficult.”

Medical exemptions were granted permanently — throughout the child’s school years — in seven states and temporarily only in five, with the rest allowing some combination. Experts say medical exemptions should be periodically revisited because children and vaccines change over time.

Saad Omer, senior author of the Emory study, said it appears that some parents and physicians are more likely to seek medical exemption from vaccines in jurisdictions where they are easy to obtain, even though almost all states also allow parents to seek philosophical or religious exemptions, too.

Contact Scripps health and science writer Lee Bowman at BowmanL@shns.com.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The Red Deer RCMP has filed another set of charges after an alleged assault at an anti-racism rally on Sept. 20. (File photo by Advocate Staff)
More assault charges filed after Sept. 20 anti-racism rally in Red Deer

Trevor Lyle Roy faces a second set of charges stemming from the event

Your weather forecast for Thursday, August 1st, 2019. (Pixabay)
Expect a slightly windy day in Red Deer Tuesday

Expect a slightly windy day in Red Deer. Although as of noon… Continue reading

“We need to keep our hospitalization rate low. We need to keep our ICU beds open, and we need to keep people healthy and our case numbers low," says Karen Mann, Red Deer’s emergency management co-ordinator. (File photo by Advocate staff).
City says it is monitoring COVID around the clock

Following guidance from Alberta’s medical officer of health

Alberta Union of Provincial Employees were back on the job Tuesday after a provincewide wildcat strike on Monday. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Red Deer hospital workers back on the job

Red Deer hospital was one of 45 sites with picket lines

Alice Kolisnyk, deputy director of the Red Deer Food Bank, says the agency expects an increase in demand as the COVID-19 pandemic continues. Every new subscription to the Red Deer Advocate includes a $50 donation to the food bank. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Support the food bank with a subscription to the Red Deer Advocate

The community’s most vulnerable members are always in need of a hand,… Continue reading

Cases in Ponoka (East Ponoka County) as of Oct. 27. (alberta.ca)
Diagnosed cases of COVID-19 at three Ponoka businesses

Town ‘strongly encouraging’ residents to wear non-medical masks in public

Red Deer Rebels forward Jayden Grubbe is one of three Rebels on the NHL Central Scouting players to watch list for the 2021 NHL Draft. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Three Rebels on 2021 NHL Central Scouting Players to Watch list

A trio of Red Deer Rebels has caught scouts’ eyes ahead of… Continue reading

Kathleen Finnigan, who was named superintendent of the Red Deer Regional Catholic School Board on Tuesday, has more than 30 years of experience as an educator. (Courtesy of Red Deer Regional Catholic Schools)
Kathleen Finnigan named Red Deer Regional Catholic Schools superintendent

The Red Deer Regional Catholic School Board will continue to be led… Continue reading

(Emily Jaycox/Bashaw Star)
Wreath laying ceremony held in Manfred, Alta.

Ceremony marks 64th anniversary of Hungarian revolution, honours settlers

The Red Deer Regional Hospital Centre could be affected by cuts to Alberta Health Services announced by the government Tuesday. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
David Marsden: Yes, we know how to do laundry

Union leaders would have us believe there’s something special about their members:… Continue reading

Most Read