Why should tax dollars support the arts?

As recent budget discussions have illustrated, governments fall into routine traps that they seem loathe to pry themselves from, in spite of the fact that simple logic should facilitate easy extrication.


As recent budget discussions have illustrated, governments fall into routine traps that they seem loathe to pry themselves from, in spite of the fact that simple logic should facilitate easy extrication.

For example, Councillors Cindy Jefferies and Chris Stephan got caught up in such a debate over Jefferies’ desire to have the city fund a gala for the Lieutenant Governor’s arts grants. The common refrain is that we “must support the arts.”

Why should we use tax dollars to support the arts?

Do we support the arts because we feel that artistic careers are something we would like to see our children involved in because they generally feature good pay and benefits that will help them provide a good living through which they can raise and support a family?

Well, if that’s the case, why does a good segment of the artistic community seem in constant need of government funding? If artistic ventures are so lucrative, why do we feel a constant need to keep funneling tax dollars in that direction?

Outside of government employment, lucrative careers should be ones that pay taxes, not receive them (notwithstanding the simple fact that there should be no lucrative careers in the public sector).

If artistic ventures don’t pay all that well, we have a responsibility to encourage our children to either eschew them entirely, or at least cultivate the commercial aspects of artistic careers before trying to make a living on the purely artistic side.

After all, last time I checked, we need more people who earn enough to pay taxes, not receive them.

Must we mandate support of the arts simply because the arts enrich us in ways to numerous to quantify?

If that were truly the case, then the collective wisdom of society would ensure that artists of all stripes were well supported by the fruits of their artistic endeavours.

Because the opposite is true, then we can essentially surmise that artists in general are essentially rewarded in a fashion commensurate with the value society places on their works.

Just because we apparently value midwives, welders and accountants more than we value those who labour as actors, painters and sculptors, does not necessarily make us uncultured louts and rotten-toothed hicks.

It’s simply a fact that most of us are obligated out of necessity to put a higher value on the services that artisans and craftsmen such as welders, machinists and cabinet makers provide.

Do we mandate support of the arts because we feel a need to help artists reflect our society back to ourselves? This is a stretch, as one will be hard pressed to find a notable Canadian writer who doesn’t stand miles to the left of the average Canadian, politically speaking. Actually, you’d be hard pressed to find too many Canadian writers who write books we actually read.

By contrast, 20-some years ago, I read a couple of pretty good Cold War novels by Canadian author Dennis Jones. You’ve never heard of him, yet two of his novels have outsold many of Margaret Atwood’s, and he’s never won a publicly-funded arts award.

Should arts awards celebrate success or failure? Successful artists don’t need government-sponsored awards and failing artists shouldn’t really get awards, should they?

After all, we don’t give the Stanley Cup to the first team out of the playoffs, do we?

Art is a lot of things to a lot of people. Almost all of us engage in some form of artistic expression. I became a machinist partly due to innate artistic ability. Some people quilt or sew, some cook, some paint, some write poetry that no one ever even gets to read.

When we decide to take public money and use it to support one form of art over another, or simply use public funds to purchase art, we have committed a deep and egregious breach of the social contract between the state and the citizen.

This is why you can easily find citizens of Red Deer who maintain strong negative opinions to this day of the public arts debacle of 1980, when publicly funded sculptures of dubious beauty were foisted upon us and paid for with money taken from us under threat of penalty of law.

The merit of the art was secondary to the issue of it being publicly funded.

Any artist who wishes to make their way through life on the value of their art has a simple obligation to do so by selling their art in the public square, just as a carpenter or welder does.

We, on the other hand, must be allowed the choice not to buy.

Bill Greenwood is a local freelance columnist.

Just Posted

Improving life for people with Alzheimer’s and their families is a priority for Raitt

The federal Conservatives deputy leader is dealing with the disease in her own home

PHOTO: International Peace Day

Visitors broke bread, made crafts and trading cards at a gathering marking… Continue reading

Snowfall warning issued for Central Alberta

Environment Canada issued a snowfall warning for Central Alberta Friday afternoon. Warning… Continue reading

POLL: Most Red Deerians don’t want cell phones in the classroom

Sixty-six per cent of Advocate readers who responded to an on-line poll… Continue reading

Grassroots movement to clean up Red Deer is gaining momentum

Homeless people need more attention than shopping carts, says former councillor Cindy Jefferies

Updated: Grey Cup in Red Deer to raise funds for military families

Money raised will go to the Military Family Resource Centre and be used locally

Dustin Byfuglien scores in overtime, Jets beat Flames 4-3 in pre-season

WINNIPEG — Bryan Little tied the game late in the third and… Continue reading

Mistrial denied in Calgary murder trial over jury’s visit to hotel Denny’s

CALGARY — A Calgary judge has denied a request for a mistrial… Continue reading

Former Canadian astronaut says space shuttle is a vehicle of hope

OTTAWA — Sending messages of hope from space is a big part… Continue reading

Canada requests trade panel on uncoated groundwood paper ruling by U.S.

OTTAWA — Canada has requested a NAFTA trade panel review a U.S.… Continue reading

B.C. premier apologizes for removal of 1950s totem pole at Canada-U.S. border

SURREY, B.C. — Three First Nations in British Columbia gathered today to… Continue reading

Tail with a happy ending: Dog rescued from fighting ring, ready for police work

Dallas’s ear-to-ear grin and bright brown eyes seem to sparkle with joy.… Continue reading

Liberal leader doubles down on notion that $75 weekly grocery bill is possible

MONTREAL — One day after being ridiculed for saying it was possible… Continue reading

Jury resumes deliberating man’s guilt in Calgary mother of four’s death

CALGARY — Jurors are continuing to deliberate the guilt of a man… Continue reading

Most Read